r/whowouldwin • • 12h ago

Challenge Can any fictional lawyer save Tom Robinson from To Kill a Mockingbird?

55 Upvotes

In TKaM Tom Robinson, a disabled Black man, is falsey accused of raping a white girl. Atticus Finch, a dedicated white lawyer tries in vain to defend him. Tom is convicted by an all white jury in 1930's alabama.

Can any fictional lawyer possibly get Tom found Not Guilty, or atleast get a hung jury?


r/whowouldwin • • 41m ago

Battle Shin (Kingdom) VS Silat (Berserk)

• Upvotes

Riboku is desperate to stop Qin, so he hires some foreign fighters to go kill Shin and his buds. Silat from Berserk fights Shin from Kingdom. Who is going to win? They're both pretty superhuman but operate in completely different contexts. Shin is slicing armored horses in half, and Silat is fighting monsters. They're both wickedly dangerous, which do you think is better?


  • Round 1: Unarmed.

  • Round 2: Both have all of their gear.

  • Round 3: Silat gets his four buddies. Shin gets Kyou Kai and Bi Hei.


r/whowouldwin • • 21h ago

Challenge Batman and Superman are told that they'll die if they don't leak the others' secret identity. Who reveals it first?

183 Upvotes

Batman and Superman are contacted by a cosmic deity, one far beyond either of their comprehensions. It tells batman he has 24 hours to tell everyone Superman is Clark Kent, and it tells Superman he has 24 hours to tell everyone Bruce Wayne is batman. If neither of them reveal this, they'll both die

Rules:

Upon revealing the other hero's secret identity, it becomes public knowledge to anyone that wishes to know this information. Only one of their secret identities need to be revealed

They're not allowed to lie or otherwise manipulate this information (like framing someone else)

This information can't be removed from everyone's memory after the fact, this will be a permanent and well known fact

The information will be widely accepted and believed by everyone else

If the heroes choose to die, they then can't be revived

Breaking any of these rules ail result in the deaths of both of them

The cosmic deity can't be harmed or fooled in any way

Round 1

The heroes are left to their own devices. They're allowed to talk to each other, or anyone else they want to support them, but by the 24 hour mark, one of their secret identities have to be revealed

Round 2

Batman and Superman aren't allowed to communicate with each other in any way, and won't know what the other picked until the 24 hours are up. If they both reveal each other's identity, they both die (they know this)

Round 3

Lex Luthor is torturing batman, and Scarecrow is torturing a depowered superman, trying to get them to reveal the others' secret identity. Who succumbs and reveals the information first? There is no time limit


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Who would win: 100 limbless people vs 100 100 year olds

6 Upvotes

Rules:

No weapons on either side

No movement/disability assistance (no wheelchairs, no walking sticks, no zimmerframes, no prosthetic limbs)

The battle takes place in a gladiator arena

The battle is a fight to the death that only ends when one side is completly deceased.

Their is no time limit

Place your bets!


r/whowouldwin • • 32m ago

Battle Kit Fisto (Star Wars) VS Davy Jones (POTC)

• Upvotes

Tentacle head guy goes up against tentacle face guy! Who do you think would win if Davy Jones from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies set his sights on Kit Fisto from Star Wars? Let's say that Davy wants Kit as part of his crew. Kit isn't interested since it's against Jedi custom to become part of a ship. The Jedi confronts the magic fish man on the deck of the Flying Dutchman and they fight. Can Kit win?

Davy Jones's heart is somewhere on the ship. Davy has the key. Kit knows he has to destroy the heart. Kit has his lightsaber.


  • Round 1: Davy versus Kit. No one else will interfere.

  • Round 2: The crew and ship will aid Davy.

  • Round 3: Kit has to get through the Kraken first.


r/whowouldwin • • 13h ago

Battle USS New Jersey (1943) vs AC130U “Spooky II”

15 Upvotes

Rules - The AC-130 has to try its best to kill the NJ. If it runs out of fuel it loses, but can rearm.

Round One:
USS New Jersey is in its 1943 configuration, with 130 AA guns plus her main and secondary armament
vs
Two AC130Us in 2010 configuration, with a 25 mm cannon, a 40mm cannon (crazy enough still the same cannon as the NJ AA), and a 105mm howitzer.

Round Two:
5 A-10 Warthogs replace the AC130U- they have rockets and bombs in their armament.

Round Three:
USS New Jersey 1982 configuration: Phalanx CIWS, Improved Fire Control

My thoughts
AC130 will be pressed to do any damage to NJ without closing in. It’s AA guns have a range of almost 5 miles, with a ceiling of 30k ft. The 20 and 30mm cannons have a max range of 2 miles. Main and secondary guns can fire much further, and the AC-130 is fat and slow- I think they catch it with a 5in round

The hogs are relying on bombs in round 2. I don’t think the hellfire missiles do any damage. They bank on a hit with a laser guided bomb to the citadel but even then these bombs are much smaller than WW2 bombs- they get chewed up by AA as well.

Last one pretty much the same thing except much more interceptions and the A-10s get chewed up faster.


r/whowouldwin • • 13h ago

Battle 2026 Mexico and Cuba vs 1939 United states and Canada

13 Upvotes

United states and Canada think they're dealing with 1939 Mexico and Cuba, they do not know they got swapped

Every other nation in the world declares total neutrality. This means no foreign aid to either side.

Us and Canada win con is to take over Mexico and Cuba.

Mexico and Cuba's win con is to hold out for 1 year


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Battle What disaster level would each of these dragons be in the world of One-Punch Man?

3 Upvotes

Notes:

Dragon #1: Smaug [1] as a Wight/Ice Dragon (The Hobbit x Game of Thrones)

Dragon #2: Darkeaster Midir W/ The Intelligence and Abilities of Seath the Scaleless (Dark Souls)

Dragon #3: Red Death/KieranH10) W/ Toothless's Speed and Electric Cloaking (How to Train Your Dragon)

Dragon #4: Kaido [Dragon Form Only] (One Piece)

Dragon #5: Dragonite [1 2] (Pokémon - Anime)

Dragon #6: Bayle the Dread (Elden Ring)

Dragon #7: Ender Dragon [1)] (Minecraft x Dungeons and Dragons)

Dragon #8: Mister Liu [1] but his Dragon Form is killable (Invincible - Comic + Show)

Dragon #9: King Ghidorah (Monsterverse)


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle Garth Marenghi vs Sutter Cane, The Metafictional Titans of Horror,Who Would Win?

3 Upvotes

>First Round : pure brute strength
>Second Round : their mortal wealth and fame leveraged against eachother
>Third Round : they both have Eldritch Reality warping abilities


r/whowouldwin • • 2m ago

Battle Juuzou Suzuya vs Hidan

• Upvotes

Two light haired scythe wielding maniacs go at it. Who comes out on top. Win by death or K.O.

Round 1: Base Juuzou

Round 2: Arata Armor Juuzou


r/whowouldwin • • 5m ago

Battle 1939 Unified Europe vs. Modern day Unified Africa

• Upvotes

My buddy asked this question yesterday in our group chat, who would win if you took a completely united Europe from 1939 including tech, weapons, food, infrastructure, etc. vs. a united Africa from today.

I believe Africa would be a pretty decisive winner due to their air force, satellites, advancements in chemical warfare capabilities, food, medicine and clothing advancements, in my opinion they would be able to cripple Europe pretty quickly from the start and would easily be able to hold off any counter attack with their superior weapons.

He believes Africa does not have enough munition, weapons, or resources to sustain a war and what they do have is not enough to hurt Europe enough before they run out.

Just curious on what other opinions are on this topic!


r/whowouldwin • • 43m ago

Battle Ukraine 2026 vs Russia 2022

• Upvotes

Allies are helping. Fallen soldiers and civilians come back to life, citizens who had left the country return, the future is known four years in advance, and infrastructure, gear, ammunition, and weaponry are at 2026 levels. Russia is at the same level it was at the start of the 2022 war, and it assumes that Ukraine is also still at its 2022 level.


r/whowouldwin • • 4h ago

Battle Semi-Composite Jaeger (Pacific Rim) vs MonsterVerse Antagonists

2 Upvotes

Notes:

Round 1: Ramarak

Round 2: Male MUTO

Round 3: Rodan

Round 4: Female MUTO

Round 5: King Ghidorah

Round 6: Skar King and Shimo


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Challenge All humans' shadows come to life and try to kill them. Can humanity survive?

5 Upvotes

Rules

• All at the same time, every person's shadow comes out of wherever they are and morphs into the exact figure of their respected individual, except they are completely dark throughout the body.

• Each one is bloodlusted, and so they will immediately attack that person. If thry manage to kill him or her, they will start going after others as well.

• Every shadow has the same stats as their normal counterpart, such as in power, intelligence, and everything else. In the dark, not only are they harder to see, but they are 1.5 times as durable. In contrast, in light areas they are half as durable. Also, they don't need to eat, drink, or sleep.

Can humanity continue to survive if their shadows come to life and try to kill them?


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Challenge The RPC Authority has to contain SCPs

1 Upvotes

The RPC Authority, set up slightly differently than the SCP Foundation, is tasked with capturing and containing all known, and most popular, SCPs. Can they do this given that their cannon is more set than the changing cannon of the SCP Foundation? How would they categorize the SCPs within their classification system?


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle Reinhard Van Astrea (Re:Zero) Vs The Simurgh (Worm Parahumans)

2 Upvotes

The fight takes place in Canberra, Australia.

For one reason or another, Reinhard Van Astrea is set up against The Simurgh. One is the Sword Saint of Lugunica, considered the country's WMD, while the other is an Endbringer responsible for the deterioration of Earth Bet.

Reinhard has his vast number of divine protections, retains his connection to Od Laguna, and is partially immune to the Simurgh's precognition, while being entirely immune to her mental effects. The Simurgh has a number of non-active Parahumans in the city, including a variety of Tinkers, Brutes and Strangers to toy with, and while she is hampered by not being able to directly see Reinhard, she can infer information from self-targeted precognition and analysis of their surroundings.

Round 1: Canon Reinhard vs Canon Simurgh. All interactions play out as though each party retains in-character approaches and actions.

Round 2: Bloodlusted Reinhard vs Canon Simurgh. Reinhard is indiscriminate in his attacks and values eliminating the Simurgh above all else. Civilians and environmental factors are no longer taken into consideration for him.

Round 3: Bloodlusted Reinhard vs Unrestricted Simurgh. The Simurgh is no longer Manton-limited, meaning her telekinesis effects living organisms, her scream doesn't need to be audible to others, and her Tinker abilities have improved to intuitive speeds. Consider her reach, multitasking capabilities and general viciousness improved as well.

The match ends in ten minutes, or when either party has killed the other permanently.


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Liv Morgan vs Mandy Rose. brawl on a mat

1 Upvotes

Sonya Deville had mentioned in an interview that Liv and Mandy got into an actual brawl in training and they had to be separated. Who would win an actual brawl on a mat with no weapons of any sort.

source - https://www.wrestlinginc.com/2041401/wwe-sonya-deville-liv-morgan-mandy-rose-fight-performance-center/


r/whowouldwin • • 22h ago

Battle A Primarch(WH40K) enters the world of One Piece. What's the strongest opponent he could beat?

30 Upvotes

Suppose Jaghatai Khan, having become lost in the Webway. Or Leman Russ, having disappeared into the Warp, somehow ended up in the world of One Piece.

He has nothing but his armour and weapons. He has no support from other Space Marines, mortal auxilia, or Imperial Navy fleets. How far could he get on his own?

  1. Axe-Hand Morgan
  2. Arlong
  3. Smoker(the Loguetown arc)
  4. Rob Lucci (the Enies Lobby arc)
  5. Donquixote Doflamingo
  6. Charlotte Katakuri
  7. Kaido
  8. All three Marine Admirals working together: Aokiji, Akainu, and Kizaru
  9. Gol D. Roger, Edward Newgate (Whitebeard), and Monkey D. Garp working together during the God Valley Incident

r/whowouldwin • • 21h ago

Battle A legendary difficulty Halo 2 jackal sniper has agreed to meet Arthur Morgan in the town center for a duel.

23 Upvotes

A Jackal Sniper from Halo 2 on Legendary difficulty has ended up in 1899 and challenged Arthur Morgan to a duel in the Wild West.

Arthur has his usual weapons and access to Dead Eye. The Jackal has his Covenant Beam Rifle and has Legendary difficulty accuracy and reaction speed.

R1: A traditional Wild West quick-draw duel in Valentine. Both start 20 paces apart, weapons holstered, and draw when the signal is given.

R2: The Jackal crash-lands on Earth, 50 miles outside Valentine, with only his standard equipment. He knows killing Arthur will teleport him back to the Covenant. The Jackel magically speaks English and knows what Aruthur looks like and his name, but nothing else and will have to find Arthur himself. Arthur knows the Jackal is coming for him.


r/whowouldwin • • 17h ago

Battle Yelena Belova (MCU) vs Solid Snake (Metal Gear)

9 Upvotes

R1: Hand to hand only, Takes place in Yelena's... "Office" during Brand New Day, Snake takes Spider-Man's place in that scene. Win by KO.

R2: Both get all of their standard gear, takes place at the top of a parking Garage. Each get a day of prep time, win by KO or Death.

Snake Respect thread

Yelena Respect thread


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle Would 15 siren heads win against 2 Godzillas???

0 Upvotes

Siren head as a deafening sound to distract Godzilla but Godzilla as the ultimate atomic breath. Who would win??


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle Medieval knight vs modern MMA heavyweight

1 Upvotes

Knight:

  • Lighter mail armor (chain mail with a padded jacket, ~12 kg) and an open-face helmet
  • Arming sword (a one-handed medieval sword) and a small round shield
  • 15 years of combat training, including wrestling

MMA heavyweight:

  • A modern riot shield and a 60cm steel baton
  • Motorcycle helmet, MMA gloves, padded jacket
  • Elite wrestling and striking. Former college wrestler

Arena: 20m × 20m grass, 22°C. Fight to knockout or submission.


r/whowouldwin • • 16h ago

Battle Roman Empire vs. Assyrian Empire

6 Upvotes

The Roman and Assyrian Empires existed centuries apart, but are considered two of the top military powers of their respective eras. If they fought each other at their peak of their powers, which empire would be victorious?


r/whowouldwin • • 12h ago

Battle Humanity vs the most realistic zombie scenario I can think of

3 Upvotes

A biotech company from San Francisco experiments on various diseases. They start messing with the rabies strain and tested it on a rat. Guess what, on the night of Christmas Eve, December 24th, 2015, as the scientist leaves the lab he forgets to close the rat cage, the rest you guys already know.

Here's how the virus work:

  1. The virus does not kill you (similar to 28 days later), so the infected still need water and food, and will seek when needed. Infected are still human, it loses a lot of blood or takes a headshot it obviously dies.
  2. Being a modified version of rabies, infected are absolutely enraged and will kill you on sight, regardless of hunger
  3. The virus can infect any sizeable living being: rats, dogs, cats, birds...
  4. The infected have the host's mobility, so yeah... they run
  5. Due to the virus not rotting the host right away, the infected still maintain their intelligence but on a lower level. Yes, they can open doors and they know that there are people inside house/apartments
  6. Infected may ocasionally fight each other, and in extreme cases eat each other.
  7. Now this is interesting, the virus will initially take a full day to show effects on humans, then it will adapt and take 20 to 30 seconds to turn people (realistic timeframe for full body blood circulation)

"It's just 28 Days Later with extra steps!"

Who would win? And how would they do it?


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Battle Invisible John Cena vs a fully grown male elephant

2 Upvotes

Rules: You can't see him, so John Cena is invisible until the elephant or him die. The elephant can feel touch and hear him but can not see him (he doesn't have a shadow or any sort of reflection either). Fight to death.