r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Challenge The Magnus Carlsen but with some caveats

56 Upvotes

For anyone unaware the Magnus Carlsen whowouldwin scenario is you trapped with Magnus Carlsen in a room until you win at game of chess, everyone agrees it is basically impossible unless he gets a heart atack in the middle of a game.

However this time the guy trapped in a room is not a novice but a 1600 FIDE (1800-2100 chess.com).Also Magnus Carlsen only gets 3 minutes on the clock while our protagonist has unlimited time per move.

The guy has 1 month of prep time and during that time he is coached by Hikaru and has unlimited resources to learn/buy anything chess related.

Moreover once per game he can have stockfish tell him the best move, HOWEVER he will have no recollection of the best move stockfish told him last game, nor when it was played, he forgets all about stockfish help and "learns" about it at the start of each game as not to just make this him asking stockfish every move until eventually after 40-80 tries stockfish beats Magnus

Once per game he can have a 3 minute talk with Gothamchess where Gothamchess is fully aware of the current board state

Does the guy have any shot at eventually beating Magnus?

After each game he gets an analysis from Hikaru and Gothamchess


r/whowouldwin • • 4h ago

Battle Plankton has the Krabby Patty formula. Can he really run the Krusty Krab out of business?

9 Upvotes

I've often heard the argument that Plankton is such a terrible business owner that he wouldn't be able to beat the Krusty Krab even if he did somehow get the formula, and that the only reason he was successful selling Krabby Patties at the Chum Bucket is that Mr. Krabs was frozen at the time. But is this true? Would Plankton be able to take away Mr. Krabs' customers if he had the formula?


r/whowouldwin • • 29m ago

Challenge The Imperium of Man gets one of every Warframe. Can they save the galaxy?

• Upvotes

Been playing a lot of Warframe lately and came up with this idea. What if the Imperium in Warhammer 40K had warframes? A single frame would be an incredibly powerful combatant in the 40K verse, comfortably outstripping any basic unnamed unit from any faction, some of them sitting just below the heaviest hitters in the verse.

So let's say that the Imperium gets some warframes; to be precise, they get one of each unique base frame currently available in-game. That's 66 frames in total, starting with Excalibur and ending with Narin (no Primes).

Here are the rules:

- The Imperium's goal, as always, is to save the universe by purging all the filthy heretics and xenos from existence. This includes the Tyranid Swarm surrounding the galaxy.

- All 66 frames magically appear on Holy Terra with detailed instructions regarding their use and capabilities. The Emperor sends his Primarchs a psychic message saying that they can deploy the frames immediately.

- The Imperium does not get the Tenno themselves, only the frames; they will act and fight autonomously but always follow orders. No Transference, no Void powers, no time travel or Eternalism shenanigans.

- Since the frames do not have full consciousness, they will not be affected by Warp corruption. They can still be physically attacked by the forces of Chaos.

- Assume all 66 frames are fully modded for endgame content. They arrive armed with a full loadout with signature weapons for each frame (i.e. Narin will have her bow, pistols, and a melee weapon) but can also use any weapons available to them in the 40K verse.

- Each frame also comes with one Archwing, one K-Drive, and a Sentinel. These can only be used by the frames.

It's a well established fact in the 40K universe that humanity is, ultimately, doomed. But with every warframe, can the Imperium finally win? If they can, how long does it take?


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle France vs UK in 2026

• Upvotes

Rules for this scenario:

  1. No nukes
  2. No foreign interference (trade is okay, we're just going to assume every country has somehow taken a neutral stance on the war)
  3. They are both fighting seriously
  4. The goal is to get the other country to either fall or surrender

Which country would win in a war?


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle Spacecraft that maneuvers like an aircraft vs Spacecraft that maneuvers Newtonianly

10 Upvotes

By aircraft-like maneuvering I mean something like how starfighters from Star Wars move, by Newtonian I mean something like how ships from the Expanse or Star Furies from Babylon 5 move.

Both craft have the same weapons and same level of protection

Round 1: Starfighter (small, high acceleration, fixed weapons)

Round 2: Warships (Larger, lower acceleration, turreted weapons)

Battle takes place in empty space


r/whowouldwin • • 21h ago

Challenge Can any fictional lawyer save Tom Robinson from To Kill a Mockingbird?

100 Upvotes

In TKaM Tom Robinson, a disabled Black man, is falsey accused of raping a white girl. Atticus Finch, a dedicated white lawyer tries in vain to defend him. Tom is convicted by an all white jury in 1930's alabama.

Can any fictional lawyer possibly get Tom found Not Guilty, or atleast get a hung jury?


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle Werewolf Hellsing (Van Helsing movie) Vs. Werepanther (Primal)

9 Upvotes

Van Helsing in his Werewolf form he uses to fight Dracula from the Hugh Jackman movie Vs. The Werepanther/Werejaguar from Primal season 3 that fought Fang. The battle is in a dark forest. If Werewolf Hellsing can defeat the Werepanther, could he defeat the Night Feeder too?


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Matchmaker Base future trunks(during badidi and dabura fight)vs imperfect cell (the one he killed at the end of cell saga). Who do you think would win?

2 Upvotes

Trunks in his base form already displayed a feat back in the end of cell saga where he managed to damage cell though cell was off guard and of course he needed super saiyan to normally beat him. Could trunks beat this same imperfect cell now in his base form when he fought dabura and badidi which is 7 years after he killed cell(and had become a lot stronger)?


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Shin (Kingdom) VS Silat (Berserk)

7 Upvotes

Riboku is desperate to stop Qin, so he hires some foreign fighters to go kill Shin and his buds. Silat from Berserk fights Shin from Kingdom. Who is going to win? They're both pretty superhuman but operate in completely different contexts. Shin is slicing armored horses in half, and Silat is fighting monsters. They're both wickedly dangerous, which do you think is better?


  • Round 1: Unarmed.

  • Round 2: Both have all of their gear.

  • Round 3: Silat gets his four buddies. Shin gets Kyou Kai and Bi Hei.


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle Cosmic garou vs goku

6 Upvotes

Field is namek but it can’t be destroyed, ( like time chamber indestructibility) and this is anime Goku scaling since I haven’t read the manga
Which Goku can win against cosmic garou?
Round 1, namek Goku vs cosmic garou
Round 2, cell games Goku vs cosmic garou
Round 3: ssj3 Goku vs cosmic garou
Round 4: vegito vs cosmic garou but he knows but you all have a option here, cosmic garou is indestructible for 1 minute so he can learn vegito moves and then fights him, does he need this buff?


r/whowouldwin • • 11h ago

Battle Who would win: 100 limbless people vs 100 100 year olds

9 Upvotes

Rules:

No weapons on either side

No movement/disability assistance (no wheelchairs, no walking sticks, no zimmerframes, no prosthetic limbs)

The battle takes place in a gladiator arena

The battle is a fight to the death that only ends when one side is completly deceased.

Their is no time limit

Place your bets!


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle Who would win? Team avatar or the stardust crusaders

5 Upvotes

Team Avatar (Aang, Sokka, Katara, Appa, Suki, Zuko, Momo and Toph)
Vs
The Stardust Crusaders (Jotaro, Polnareff, Kakyoin, Joseph, Iggy and Avdol)

Scenario 1: aang doesn't have access to the avatar state and Jotaro can't pause time (aka right before the finale)

Scenario 2: Aang does have access to the avatar state and Jotaro can pause time (aka after the finale but all the crusaders are still alive)

Rules:
1: The battle takes place in a flat grasslands at day
2: each team must incapacitated all members of the other through either Death, Capture or rendering them unconscious
3: They must have 0 prior knowledge of each other before the fight
4: Team avatar can see their stands for the sake of fairness


r/whowouldwin • • 33m ago

Battle Alexander the great Macedonian army vs Harold Godwinsons shield wall

• Upvotes

Scenario 1: Harold Godwinsons wins the battle of Stanford bridge and hastily marches South to meet William the conqueror at Hastings. Except instead of William, it's Alexander the great that lands in England with an army of 5000. For Alexander's army it is the same one that he used in crossing the Danube consisting of 3500 phalanx infantry and 1500 companion cavalry. Harold's army consists of the original timeline of 7000 infantry in a shield wall with 20% of the 7000 being elite housecarls. Who wins?

Scenario 2, the battle of Stamford bridge never happens and Harold is able to arrive at Hastings with a fresh army of 15000 infantry with the housecarls making up 20% of the army. Who wins?

Both sides have the technology and military tactics of their own time period.

In both scenarios Harold arrives at senlac Hill and establishes the shield wall waiting for Alexander's army to attack.


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle Omega Leonidas (Bakugan video game) vs Kaos (Skylanders)

3 Upvotes

I was originally thinking "my favorite Pokémon vs my favorite Skylander" but then I remembered my favorite Skylanders are either crossover characters or Imaginators, and my favorite Pokémon is not that OP. then I saw a video power scaling Bakugan, and then I figured "my favorite Bakugan vs Kaos" and you can guess the rest.

anyway, rules:

this is an actual fight, not a Bakugan battle. last I checked, Bakugan has those.

the fight will take place in Skylands, let's just say Bakugan can access their full power in Skylands.

Kaos will be an amalgam of the games and Academy.

Kaos has access to all his powers and forms, but not tech.

Leonidas will be at his most powerful.

if it makes a difference, Leonidas will be Pyrus atribue.

fight is until either death or incapacitation of opponent.


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Kit Fisto (Star Wars) VS Davy Jones (POTC)

5 Upvotes

Tentacle head guy goes up against tentacle face guy! Who do you think would win if Davy Jones from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies set his sights on Kit Fisto from Star Wars? Let's say that Davy wants Kit as part of his crew. Kit isn't interested since it's against Jedi custom to become part of a ship. The Jedi confronts the magic fish man on the deck of the Flying Dutchman and they fight. Can Kit win?

Davy Jones's heart is somewhere on the ship. Davy has the key. Kit knows he has to destroy the heart. Kit has his lightsaber.


  • Round 1: Davy versus Kit. No one else will interfere.

  • Round 2: The crew and ship will aid Davy.

  • Round 3: Kit has to get through the Kraken first.


r/whowouldwin • • 1d ago

Challenge Batman and Superman are told that they'll die if they don't leak the others' secret identity. Who reveals it first?

207 Upvotes

Batman and Superman are contacted by a cosmic deity, one far beyond either of their comprehensions. It tells batman he has 24 hours to tell everyone Superman is Clark Kent, and it tells Superman he has 24 hours to tell everyone Bruce Wayne is batman. If neither of them reveal this, they'll both die

Rules:

Upon revealing the other hero's secret identity, it becomes public knowledge to anyone that wishes to know this information. Only one of their secret identities need to be revealed

They're not allowed to lie or otherwise manipulate this information (like framing someone else)

This information can't be removed from everyone's memory after the fact, this will be a permanent and well known fact

The information will be widely accepted and believed by everyone else

If the heroes choose to die, they then can't be revived

Breaking any of these rules ail result in the deaths of both of them

The cosmic deity can't be harmed or fooled in any way

Round 1

The heroes are left to their own devices. They're allowed to talk to each other, or anyone else they want to support them, but by the 24 hour mark, one of their secret identities have to be revealed

Round 2

Batman and Superman aren't allowed to communicate with each other in any way, and won't know what the other picked until the 24 hours are up. If they both reveal each other's identity, they both die (they know this)

Round 3

Lex Luthor is torturing batman, and Scarecrow is torturing a depowered superman, trying to get them to reveal the others' secret identity. Who succumbs and reveals the information first? There is no time limit


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Challenge Could the Guardians of the Galaxy survive the Ishimura? Or at least have one member left alive by the time of destroying the Hive mind?

1 Upvotes

MCU Guardians of the Galaxy, set right before Infinity War.

They have to fight their way through the Ishimura, survive the Necromorphs and kill the Hive Mind with at least one member alive to win


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Polar Bear vs 10 fully armoured medieval knights. Who wins

1 Upvotes

Polar bear - adult, male, full-sized

Knights - huge men, fully plated thick armour.. wielding longswords, poleaxes and warhammers

Does the Polar Bear take them all out or does he go down while at least one knight stands ?


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Challenge Can Claw (Mob Psycho 100) take over Brockton Bay (Worm)?

0 Upvotes

The terrorist esper organization gets teleported to Brockton Bay around the start of the story. Wanting to continue his world-domination plot, Toichiro first sets his eyes on controlling the city.

For the sake of the prompt Claw consists of:

  • Toichiro Suzuki (leader)
  • Sho Suzuki (who is still willing to betray his father)
  • The Ultimate 5
  • The 7th Division (Scars)
  • 600 artificial espers empowered by Toichiro

Win condition: Long term control over Brockton Bay through elimination or subjugation of other organizations.

Rules:

  • Claw starts out with basic intel (i.e. what can be reasonably found online)
  • No Scion interference
  • Assume that the language barrier is not an issue
  • The PRT may request help from heroes outside Brockton Bay if needed

Round 1: Verses are equalized
Round 2: Verses are not equalized


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Battle Casey jones (tmnt) vs Kickass vs Scott pilgrim

1 Upvotes

All out fight randomly on an empty street normal gear involved.


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Challenge Every bird on the planet vs human society.

2 Upvotes

Every bird on the planet gains human level intelligence and are all hive mind coordinated. They know they don't stand a chance against humanity's weapons and technology, so they utilize their new intelligence and coordination at psychologically breaking humanity by spreading out evenly across the planet and watching and staring at all the humans. How long can humanity handle this staring from the birds? Humanity wins by society not collapsing entirely, and the birds win if society collapses. If nukes are launched the birds win because they broke humanity to even consider nuking and destroying themselves just to stop being stared at.


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle Boros (one punch man) vs adults Naruto and Sasuke (boruto)

0 Upvotes

Let's say that instead of all the events of Boruto, the series begins with Boros's spaceship appearing above Konoha.

Lets say The rest of the ninjas have to stay on the ground and fight with Melzargard. Meanwhile, Sasuke teleports himself and Naruto inside the spaceship.

How the fight goes?


r/whowouldwin • • 22h ago

Battle USS New Jersey (1943) vs AC130U “Spooky II”

20 Upvotes

Rules - The AC-130 has to try its best to kill the NJ. If it runs out of fuel it loses, but can rearm.

Round One:
USS New Jersey is in its 1943 configuration, with 130 AA guns plus her main and secondary armament
vs
Two AC130Us in 2010 configuration, with a 25 mm cannon, a 40mm cannon (crazy enough still the same cannon as the NJ AA), and a 105mm howitzer.

Round Two:
5 A-10 Warthogs replace the AC130U- they have rockets and bombs in their armament.

Round Three:
USS New Jersey 1982 configuration: Phalanx CIWS, Improved Fire Control

My thoughts
AC130 will be pressed to do any damage to NJ without closing in. It’s AA guns have a range of almost 5 miles, with a ceiling of 30k ft. The 20 and 30mm cannons have a max range of 2 miles. Main and secondary guns can fire much further, and the AC-130 is fat and slow- I think they catch it with a 5in round

The hogs are relying on bombs in round 2. I don’t think the hellfire missiles do any damage. They bank on a hit with a laser guided bomb to the citadel but even then these bombs are much smaller than WW2 bombs- they get chewed up by AA as well.

Last one pretty much the same thing except much more interceptions and the A-10s get chewed up faster.


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Battle Hawkeye vs Red Hood

1 Upvotes

616 and Rebirth versions.

No prep.

In character.

Standard equipment.

Fight takes place in an empty parking lot.

They start 15 feet away from each other.

Round 2: They each get a week of prep.


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle Hitler-Ratte Kaiju vs. the Allies (1945)

• Upvotes

April 1945. As the Third Reich collapses, Hitler uses infernal powers to magically merge himself with the never-built Landkreuzer P.1000 Ratte, transforming into a gigantic biomechanical monster. Rita Repulsa then enlarges the entire creature until it stands 417 meters tall, approximately the height of the original World Trade Center's North Tower.

Hitler-Ratte retains Hitler's intelligence, memories, and personality. He knows Germany has already lost the war and has abandoned any hope of victory. His only remaining objective is revenge. He intends to inflict as much destruction and suffering upon the Allies as possible before being stopped.

Dimensions and physical characteristics:

  • Height: 417 meters.
  • Length: 1,327 meters.
  • Width: 531 meters.
  • Mass: approximately 54.5 million metric tons.
  • Maximum land speed: 40 km/h.
  • Armor and structural strength are magically reinforced to withstand the creature's enormous weight.
  • An antigravity system prevents him from sinking into the ground under his own weight, but does not eliminate his inertia or make him immune to external forces.

Armor thickness:

  • Frontal armor: 13.65 meters.
  • Side armor: 9.48 meters.
  • Rear armor: 7.58 meters.
  • Roof armor: 5.69 meters.
  • Belly armor: 3.79 meters.
  • Track plates: approximately 3.8 meters thick, with reinforced sections reaching 7.6 meters.
  • Each track is approximately 136 meters wide.

Armament:

His original weapons have been enlarged proportionally along with his body.

His primary armament consists of two gigantic 10.6-meter-caliber naval guns, each firing projectiles weighing approximately 18,000 metric tons.

  • Muzzle velocity: 890 m/s.
  • Kinetic energy per projectile: approximately 1.7 kilotons of TNT equivalent.
  • Rate of fire: 3 rounds per minute per barrel.
  • Maximum combined rate of fire: 6 rounds per minute.
  • All original secondary weapons are also proportionally enlarged.

Additionally, 1,000 conventional German anti-aircraft gun mounts from 1945 have been installed across his enormous upper surfaces. These are normal-sized weapons operated by fanatical Nazi crews.

Hitler-Ratte has an unlimited supply of ammunition for all his weapons.

Movement and special rules:

Hitler-Ratte can move at 40 km/h on land using his tracks.

If his tracks are destroyed, his antigravity system allows him to continue moving at 15 km/h. He cannot fly.

His antigravity system becomes severely overloaded when he attempts to crush his way through dense urban areas. The resistance of buildings and the enormous amount of debris dramatically reduce his movement speed. He can still demolish entire neighborhoods by advancing through them, but doing so is extremely slow. Consequently, using his artillery is generally much more efficient than physically bulldozing cities.

He cannot swim, but he can slowly walk along the seabed at 0.5 km/h. Crossing the English Channel would take approximately 68 hours.

His enormous height means much of his body would remain above the water in relatively shallow seas.

He has no regeneration. Any damage he sustains is permanent.

He is a single living biomechanical organism, not an ordinary tank with Hitler sitting somewhere inside it. His biological and mechanical components function together as one body.

Scenario:

Hitler-Ratte appears in Berlin in late April 1945, as Soviet forces close in on the city.

He is completely free to choose his targets and strategy. He may attack Allied armies, destroy cities, march toward Moscow, attempt to cross the English Channel to reach London, or pursue any other objective that maximizes Allied losses.

The Allies possess their actual military forces, weapons, industrial capabilities, and technology available in 1945. They receive no advance warning.

Nuclear weapons are permitted, but strongly discouraged.

The Allies may resort to nuclear weapons if they conclude that eliminating Hitler-Ratte through conventional means is impossible. However, using a nuclear weapon counts as a partial victory for Hitler-Ratte, since forcing the Allies to contaminate their own territory or occupied territory with radioactive fallout would itself fulfill part of his destructive objective.

The Allies cannot use nuclear weapons before they historically become available.

Can the combined Allied forces permanently destroy or neutralize Hitler-Ratte using conventional weapons? How much destruction could he cause before being stopped?