r/nfl • u/jnightrain • 14h ago
The real NFC East curse is winning back to back division titles
EDIT: I worded this poorly i didn't literally mean back to back but more consecutive titles. could be a run of 2 or 5 or 6 or whatever. Just saying the year the runs ended the teams did not make the playoffs, which isn't crazy i'm finding out.
so people are pointing out it's not that crazy so i looked it up and it really isn't but figured i'd share what i found. NFC North only the packers have won consecutive division titles and made the playoffs the following year. They have won consecutive titles 5 times and made it to the post season the following year twice.
There are 3 teams in the NFC West who have made the post season after consecutive titles, I'll let you guess which one didn't. Of note the 49ers did this 6 times and made the playoffs the following year 3 times.
NFC south no team has done it and every team but the falcons has had consecutive titles.
AFC west both the bills and pats of accomplished this with the bills being 2 for 2. Oddly the Pats missed on year despite going 11-5 but made the playoffs finishing 4 out of 5 with a 9-7 record
AFC north has two teams who have accomplished it, steelers and ravens
AFC south has two teams as well, Cotls and Texans
AFC West also has 3 teams wh ohave done it, chargers, raiders, and broncos
So I'll say it was a dumb thought i had on lunch break and not as crazy as i thought, carry on.
With how bad the Eagles season is going this year I decided to look at what their season looked like the last time they won back to back (to back to back) division titles which was 2001-2004. They finished the 2005 seasons with a 6-10 record, good for last place in the division and obviously missed the playoffs.
That season also saw WR1 drama which was TO wanting a new contract and being very vocal about it. That lead to the team suspending him after the 7th game. They also had a lot of key injuries but most notably McNabb and Westbrook and 2 starting offensive lineman.
I then decided to look at the last time every NFC East team won back to back division titles and realized that the last time every one of them won back to back titles they failed to make the playoffs the following year. In fact, in my very quick PFR research, the Cowboys are the only East team to win back to back titles and then make the playoffs the following year without winning the division.
*after getting done with the post I looked up how many times each team won back to back titles in the super bowl era and it's really just the cowboys so that last stat not a big deal I guess. Giants have done it once, Eagles twice, Commanders once, Cowboys three times. Cowboys made the playoffs the following year 2 out of 3 times.
The Giants last won back to back titles 1989-1990 and in 1991 they had an 8-8 record. That season they lost "The Bills" coaching and also lost Hostetler to a broken back after 11 games.
The Commanders last won back to back titles 1982-1984 and in the 1985 season they went 10-6 but missed the playoffs. They were the only team to post a winning record. They also lost Joe Theismann to a career ending leg injury
The Cowboys last won back to back titles 1992-1996 and in the 1997 season they went 6-10 and missed the playoffs. The team didn't fall to injury's but just an implosion inside the team. Aikman and Switzer fighting and a bunch of off the field issues.
I have a feeling this streak will continue this way unless the East somehow sends two teams to the playoffs.

