r/mildlyinfuriating • u/ubu72 • 10h ago
Ruined by Technology These "Non-stick" pans from Costco
Apparently I'm an idiot. But they still aren't great
Update: going in for round 2 with a lot of butter and low heat. Stay tuned (10:58pst)
Update update : see pics below of retest on low heat with all the butter
113
77
u/IllustratorUsual5080 10h ago
I think the non stick is affecting your brain
3
u/Emotional_Cry_4066 10h ago
You joke but non stick coating actually contains PFAS that leaks into your food and into your body.
2
u/prettyokcake 10h ago
not all non stick coatings contain PFAS
2
u/Emotional_Cry_4066 10h ago
2
1
u/Emotional_Cry_4066 10h ago
1
u/dangforgotmyaccount 10h ago edited 9h ago
No intentionally added PFAS. Saying it then may still have PFAS and shouldn’t be used is at that rate “
Like putting something on the Prop 65 list. Just because it may have it, doesn’t mean that it does have it, and just because it may not have it, doesn’t mean that it doesn’t have it. No less. It’s a lot better than it outright having it.Unless you don’t drink coffee because it may cause cancer, can’t help you there.
45
u/jesusholdmybeer 10h ago edited 10h ago
Have you been hand cleaning or putting in the dishwasher
Dishwasher cleaning will very quickly run out its usefullness
-59
u/ubu72 10h ago
Dishwasher with plain detergent powder. Ugh I hate hand washing tho
56
u/Exceptional_Kumquat 10h ago
You literally removed all of the non-stick coating that way.
→ More replies (1)31
25
u/Ange1ofD4rkness 10h ago
You never wash these anti-sticks in a dishwasher. Even the ones that say they are dishwasher safe, you probably shouldn't trust that.
I've had anti-sticks for over a decade that still work (though one is a little worn and sticks tiny bit)
→ More replies (30)14
u/Electronic_Item6923 10h ago
Well, there's your problem. Non-stick cookware cannot go in the dishwasher as it ruins them.
18
18
16
15
u/sod1102 10h ago
Yeah I'm gonna guess this is on you, man. With nonstick pans: 1. never heat them more than medium, 2. always use oil, 3. wash them by hand every time, 4. never use metal utensils in them.
7
14
u/sentienttortoise 10h ago edited 10h ago
As a chef, this is honestly a skill issue.
1) your heat was too high. You should cook eggs on medium - low always
2) you probably didn't use enough (if any) fat. Whether that's oil or butter, it's up to you, but you need to use it and you need to let it preheat
Edit : also idk if you're showing the bottom to show the brand or the condition of it, but if it's the latter, the way the bottom of a pan looks doesn't really matter as long as it isn't warped or deeply pitted or something
11
u/ClassikD 10h ago
Learn to properly use stainless and you'll never go back. My non stick is a pancake and crepe pan only. That being said, people really underestimate how much oil or fats they should use even with non stick. Relying on just the teflon degrades it faster as does too high a heat
4
u/You-Asked-Me 10h ago
Yeah, people should try using about 4x the oil, at least once and see how it goes. It will help, especially since OP looks like they were making eggs.
Same with people who cannot get a good seer on a steak, people don't realize the the pro use a good 1/8" of oil in the pan.
2
u/HornyRaindeer 10h ago
I love the stainless, meat goes to stainless and nonstick is for pancakes, eggs etc that you cook with low heat.
12
u/Particular_Can_7726 10h ago edited 9h ago
That looks like a heat issue and not an issue with your pan. You are letting the pan get too hot.
11
u/ProbablyBannedOnMain 10h ago
Puts pans on max heat
"Why's my shit burning to the pan!?!"
2
u/False_Campaign4682 10h ago
My aunt does this then bitches the pans are worn. It's infuriating. . She's afraid of undercooked everything so she high heat speed cooks everything.
10
u/dangforgotmyaccount 10h ago
Those eggs are burning to the pan, usually due to no medium between them and the pan. It needs more oil and less heat if they are doing this.
Non-stick is a bit of a misnomer. It doesn’t make it impossible for things to stick, just less likely.
3
-2
u/ubu72 10h ago
This had a lot of olive oil and a bit of butter. Prolly started too hot but no matter what stuff still sticks
2
u/dangforgotmyaccount 10h ago
May have been too hot. I make eggs in a nonstick all the time and very rarely have issues. My mom cooks eggs in the same pan, and always burns them to the pan. The only difference is she has the heat a lot higher.
1
9
10
u/Ok-Egg-7475 10h ago
I know someone who buys brand new sets of non stick pans every couple of months because they "stop working and didn't work very well anyway". But this same doofus will use a fork and leave gouges in CERAMIC COATED PANS after their eggs stick a little because they dropped them in cold on cold and then blasted them on high heat. I've stopped correcting them.
8
u/Sparkysparky-boom 10h ago
Do you put the eggs in before the pan is hot?
What heat setting did you use?
Did you use any oil or butter?
My son and I use the same pan and it’s like this when he cooks eggs but not when I do.
9
7
7
u/Sir-thinksalot- 10h ago
Eggs will always do that when you dont use grease or cream. Its not the pans fault.
7
11
u/Machdame 10h ago
Imma be REAL honest here... if this is what you got out of cooking, you don't need a nonstick pan, you need a wok. You are cooking things hard and loose with next to no aftercare for the pan itself. You may as well just abandon the idea because it seems like the function is lost on this endeavor. At least with a wok, you can basically do the cooking equivalent of beating the ever loving shit out of it and it will still be functional for ages. But this? This is just sad.
1
u/j417 10h ago
do you have any recommendations for a good wok brand? my old one (15+ years of service) is pretty battered and I've been looking for a new one. I have a shitty glass-top electric stove so I need one that's flat on the bottom but all the woks I've found locally are non-stick coated (yuck). I'm willing to buy online but Amazon reviews are kinda hit or miss and I'd prefer the opinion of an actual human.
2
u/Machdame 10h ago
Not really. Mine has been in my family for over 30+ years and I'm still using it to this day. My recommendation is to get one from a local Chinese outlet and season it yourself. There's no magic answer I have in regards to brand because I would not have thought of it when buying a new one.
1
u/j417 9h ago
thanks! I've been looking at our local Asian market but I'm in a fairly small town and there's not a lot of selection. I'll definitely check around next time I'm in a bigger city.
1
u/Machdame 6h ago
I don't know where you are, but if you are coastal on the stateside, you should have a lot of options to choose from. The funny thing about Amazon is that a lot of products in there are also straight from China... They are literally selling you worse versions of what we would have used...
But I digress, I have gone to China and the options are great. I just never brought one back here because ours has not seen any level of decline. (it is a very well used wok)
5
u/Vegetable-Zombie7664 10h ago
This is why you just get stainless steel
6
u/Mizook 10h ago
If they can’t use a non stick properly, they sure as hell won’t do well with stainless steel.
2
u/squirrelpickle 10h ago
If they're going to put in the dishwasher either way, at least the stainless steel can take it.
1
u/ubu72 10h ago
This will be my next purchase
1
u/Vegetable-Zombie7664 10h ago
Just keep in mind to properly heat your pan when cooking or everything will stick
5
u/Lazy-Opportunity-520 10h ago
Even if this is nonstick, you should at least put a little bit of oil or butter for lubrication
6
6
u/Guilty_Increase1173 10h ago
Looks like you left the stove and prayed the nonstick would do the rest, pre-heating with oil works fine for my steel.
4
u/Exceptional_Kumquat 10h ago
Fill the pan with water and reheat the pan and let the water boil for a bit until that comes loose.
4
u/Emotional_Cry_4066 10h ago
You still need oil. Plus if you use that hard side of sponges that scratches your pan and removes the non stick. You have to use the soft side of the sponge only.
5
4
5
u/JoeBethersonton50504 10h ago
I have this set. I haven’t had any issues with it.
The few times I’ve had some residue stick a bit, I just soaked it with warm water and dawn for a few minutes and then it cleaned easy.
4
5
u/nclay525 10h ago
The pan is likely crap, yes, but that's not the major issue here. You have to baby pans like this, and it doesn't look like you have.
5
4
3
4
u/be_easy_1602 10h ago
This is a steel pan, and Tramontina is a good brand. I have a set and have used them for like a decade. There’s definitely a learning curve.
You have to cook on steel in a specific manner. It is nonstick, but you need oil and you have to have the pan at the right temperature. You have to let the food crust just a bit and shake loose. It’s a bit more active of an experience I think.
You can’t compare this to a Teflon or ceramic “non stick” pan. This is user error. Just soak it, clean it and try again.
4
u/Sin_of_the_Dark 10h ago
Do yourself a favor, pick up a couple Lodge cast iron pans. Easier to cook and clean with, no toxicity, and you get a little extra iron in your diet 😉
No matter what you cook with though, always start low and slow before upping the temp. I put my skillets on 'low' while prepping, and then turn it up to what I need. Food is fickle. If the temp is too high, it sticks. If the temp is too low, it sticks. If there's not enough oil/butter, it sticks (although less so with cast iron). Look at it wrong? It sticks.
1
5
7
6
u/beatbox9 10h ago
Presumably your hand didn't stick to the handle and you were able to free your hand in order to take the picture? Yes? Then it's non-stick.
I swear, some people....
3
3
3
u/GlitterFactoryOfDoom 10h ago
Getting major "Marie Calendar ruined Thanksgiving" vibes off this. OP doesn't know how to use nonstick pans.
3
3
3
3
u/Ilickedthecinnabar 10h ago
Oil, high heat, and non-stick pans are not a good combo - the temps should never get anywhere near the smoke point of whatever cooking oil you're using. Cooking spray, like Pam, is usually a no-go with non-sticks as well.
And always handwash non-sticks with soap and a soft cloth - you don't want to scruff it up and make it lose its non-stickiness. (If its in good shape, there isn't really a lot to clean off anyway)
5
u/Limp-Appointment-564 10h ago
Use the water test. If the water beads and moves around the pan, it's ready to go! If it evaporates, it needs to keep heating. The add the food. But never crowd the pan.
2
4
u/imaguitarhero24 10h ago
Fellas I've cooked raw egg and nothing else on a good non stick pan and you can avoid this if you keep stirring. You don't need butter or oil in a good pan. It definitely helps but the pan has a little bit to blame I say.
10
u/OhWhatATravisty Blue Crayons have the most flavor 10h ago
I'd be more worried about the harmful chemicals it's probably leaching into your food.
13
4
u/nekomata_58 10h ago
arent these pans ceramic? i dont think you have to worry about chemicals. the downside is they aren't really as non-stick as the teflon ones.
1
u/OhWhatATravisty Blue Crayons have the most flavor 10h ago
I added this below in another comment but that's not a for sure thing. Now again I'm not saying every cheap pan is suspect, or going to poison you or anything. But it's possible, and one place that would give me concern is a pan that shows it's not up to the quality marketed.
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/household-products/safe-use-cookware.html some ceramic glazes from some cheap manufacturers can contain pigments that include undesirable inclusions like lead and cadmium.
5
u/Flashy-Outcome4779 10h ago
Aren’t modern non stick pans made with material that’s essentially inert?
3
u/HarryRulez 10h ago
Most of them are ceramic so they're non-toxic.
2
u/dangforgotmyaccount 10h ago
Even if they aren’t ceramic, they are most likely Teflon, which as long as you follow the instructions and don’t go all bobby flay on the thing are just fine. The biggest thing being not using metal utensils.
1
u/archercc81 10h ago
Nope, "better" but most of them are still plastic coated and you just cant avoid it, they just changed how they were made so they werent using the chemicals we know was bad, but to new ones we dont know are bad yet basically. Its like getting BPA out of bottles, they just had to use a different plasticiser.
You can get ceramic ones but they are dog shit for non-stick.
The only real solution is one of two.
Just get a cheapish classically non-stick pan and use it as a wear item for really sensitive things ONLY. And only use plastic/silicone on it. And the moment you see any signs of wear, toss it.
The other is cast-iron or carbon steel that is seasoned (which is basically turning cooked fats into a type of plastic as well, but a known risk) AND cooking with fats. You can get the same non-stick performance but it does require technique and maintenance.
1
u/Flashy-Outcome4779 10h ago
I’ve got tons of plastic in my balls as is, a little more can’t be too bad…
0
u/OhWhatATravisty Blue Crayons have the most flavor 10h ago edited 10h ago
Assuming it's from a reputable source. There's heaps of evidence out there that huge swathes of the industry do not fall into that reputable category. The coating is also not the only part of the pan that needs consideration.
ETA: I don't mean costco. I mean the manufacturer. Added some resources below. Far from all encompassing. Note: I'm not saying buying cheap pans is GOING to poison you, or that there's inherently something wrong with all of them. But it's well documented by reputable sources that SOME manufacturers provide products that leech harmful chemicals from either the base material of the pan or the coating. This includes lead from aluminum based cookware. Cadmium etc from certain ceramic glazes.
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/household-products/safe-use-cookware.html
1
u/Emotional_Cry_4066 10h ago
I found the product on Costco’s app and it says no intentionally added PFAS, but it is not PFAS free.
0
u/Uncynical_Diogenes 10h ago
Inert? Yes. No chemistry in your body will be displacing any of that flourine from that carbon.
But that means there is a high likelihood that polymer is going to stay inside of you essentially forever if it find somewhere to get stuck, and we don’t know what the consequences of that are yet.
1
u/GhostMcFunky 10h ago
Not all non-stick these days means teflon or something similar.
Ceramic lined, coated or solid ceramic are all entirely non-toxic and probably the most popular cookware these days.
2
u/moomoomoomoom 10h ago
Just get steel pans, let them preheat until you can drop little droplets of water in the pan and they seem to glide over the surface. Then put in a little oil.
Learning how to use steel pans correctly has been a gamechanger. I swear those things are more nonstick than nonstick pans and are probably better for your health in the long term.
2
u/SparkyMuffin 10h ago edited 10h ago
You need oil or something on the pan for eggs. I use pam cooking spray.
Also you should be making sure the pan is hot before you put the eggs on there. Far less likely to stick to the pan that way
1
u/False_Campaign4682 10h ago
Canola and butter for me. Plus low to med low heat and a lid to steam the whites no reason to rush breakfast
1
u/SparkyMuffin 10h ago
Sunnyside side up eggs?
1
u/False_Campaign4682 10h ago
Yep. Warm runny yolk, mostly set white. I serve them on oil warmed/barely fried corn tortillas kinda huevos rancheros style and soaking up the yolk after with the tortilla is great.
1
u/copacetic1515 10h ago
I thought you weren't supposed to use cooking spray on nonstick? Something about the propellant damaging it.
2
2
2
2
u/RareRestaurant6297 10h ago
That's the exact pan I have and have used hundreds of times without anything sticking once.
Are you cooking your eggs in 3s flat because you crank the heat to maximum or something? Holy.
2
u/dislob3 10h ago
I use the Greenpans from costco. Never had this problem.
3
u/ObsessedWithReps 10h ago
Yeah green pans are money. Slight scraping but it all comes off pretty easy
3
2
u/LeatherGrade713 10h ago
That’s the ceramic on stainless steel. We have the same ones. While they are somewhat nonstick they aren’t like teflon pans. It doesn’t leach any forever chemicals onto your food though. You need to learn to use them with oil.
2
2
u/Muted-Mammoth8304 10h ago
Silicone or plastic only on ceramic and nonstick. No dishwasher. It has an aluminum core so it responds to heat change quickly. You have a gas stove.
You need to control temp a little better. Be mindful of how hot it is. You need oil or butter or a fat of some kind.
I cook only on stainless steel even eggs. With proper temp control and use of a fat, even steel is "non stick".
4
u/Misanthropic_Mutters 10h ago
You’re an idiot that puts cooking pans into the dishwasher.
The fault isn’t Costco or the manufacturer but yours, you melt
0
u/ubu72 10h ago
Super helpful. Thanks
1
u/Misanthropic_Mutters 10h ago
It was, wasn’t it? I educated you on the reason why your pan is trash: You trashed it.
Go forth with this newfound knowledge and besmirch beloved Costco no longer, thy whales vagina!
3
u/Schnupsdidudel 10h ago
Non stick pans in general are really the biggest scam since bottled water.
Spent 10 years of my life buying new pans until I stumbled upon a carbon steel one.
Burnt in once, be set for life - and can use metal objects to stir argain!
2
u/Nervous-Fennel3325 10h ago
Never had an issue with stainless. Just takes a little bit of relearning to cook, but i will never go back to teflon
2
u/Schnupsdidudel 10h ago
Stainless is also fine! Or cast iron!
All three will probably outlast you and do not put forever chemicals in the environment for absolutely no reason.
3
u/molotovzav 10h ago
Non stick does not mean eggs won't stick to it without some oil coating. This is basic cooking 101 and I am honestly shocked somehow new adults come out not knowing this as kids.
2
u/5MinuteDad 10h ago
Thats why you dont cook eggs in a hot pan start em cold
2
u/Deaths_Smile 10h ago
You can cook eggs in a hot pan, just be sure to put a decent amount of butter or something in it first.
2
u/Velocityg4 10h ago
They never seem to work with eggs. A quick tip though. While the pan is still piping hot. Put in a little water, not a lot. It’ll immediately loosen the stuck eggs. Then quickly scrape with the spatula.
1
2
u/BecaBakes 10h ago
Hey OP, I work in the corporate sector these days but spent over a decade in the restaurant industry. If i can offer my advice is to get some stainless steel and some olive oil/butter.
I don’t know if you have any formal training or experience in the kitchen, but these pans are notorious for being considered “training wheels” for cooking. Theyre good for learning, but stainless will teach you how to better manage heat and cooking times. Hopefully the next purchase doesnt go this way lol. and yes, as others have said…no dishwasher.
4
u/EdgyPun34257 10h ago
This person is burning eggs onto non-stick cookware and you think the solution is change to stainless?
-1
u/BecaBakes 10h ago
Yes, stainless is one of the best pans/pots you can get for catch all cooking. Based on the comments, this individual put it through the dishwasher, this removes any non stick properties the pan had.
This won’t happen with stainless. But that also tells me this person might not have a lot of experience or knowledge in cooking, so pointers to the right tools will help. The end result here isn’t that they burnt eggs in nonstick, it’s that they didn’t know how to take care of a nonstick the best way which resulted in burnt eggs. Hope this explains my rationale in why i said what i said, and i stand by it.
In the words of Gusteau, anyone can cook.
1
u/EdgyPun34257 10h ago
You're missing the point.
You're suggesting they buy new pans that are notoriously one of the most difficult to learn to use, and learn to use it properly.
When it's the same person who couldn't even use non-stick properly.
1
u/Unusual_Flounder2073 10h ago
Scrambled eggs are pretty easy to get stuck like that. Even in my hex clads. But maybe it got overheated over scrubbed and damaged the non stick. I had a set of cheap ones my kids still use from Costco that worked great.
That said. It’s Costco. Take them back and try a different set.
1
1
u/Pure_Possession_1KG 10h ago
Never put these in the dishwasher, you have to hand wash them with dish soap.
1
u/solarnuggets 10h ago
I thought we weren’t using these things anymore cause of the chemicals they leach off
1
1
u/ImSoCul 10h ago
OP I won't roast you because there is already a decent amount of flaming in comments lol. I assume you're still new-ish to cooking, eggs are by far one of the stickiest things to cook. I keep a teflon pan on hand largely for eggs. Pretty sure what you have is a ceramic non-stick which kind of works but not nearly as non-stick as teflon. Don't use dishwasher- nonstick pans should be super easy to handwash if maintained, most of the food just wipes out with almost no effort. If it degrades, toss it and get a new one (nonstick usually ~1-2 year lifespan depending on use).
If you're worried about chemicals, carbon steel is the way to go and if properly maintained, work almost as well as teflon. If not properly maintained however, it sticks like crazy. You have to season it and maintain seasoning which is not very beginner friendly, but once it's properly seasoned (basically a plasticized layer forms from heating oil) then it's the best, safest, lasts forever nonstick option. Heat control is also your friend- look up "water bead test" on Youtube
1
u/GromOfDoom 10h ago
I hate those smooth "non-stick" pans. I have slowly shelled out for hex clad part by part, no disappointment so far. Does still scratch if you use force with metal utensils, but I try not to. Haven't had anything truly stick where it doesn't clean off easy
1
1
u/Phoenix_SWA 8h ago
That looks like burnt eggs or smth?
Yeah sorry to tell you but burnt eggs will stick to ANYTHING imo.
1
u/Spaceman_John_Spiff 10h ago
Costco has a 100% money back guarantee on your membership. You can cancel and get a full refund.
1
u/AngryIronToad 10h ago
Instead of cancelling, they have an amazing returns policy, they can return the pan and get their money back
1
u/Spaceman_John_Spiff 10h ago
Right, but they specifically called out Costco, not the maker of the pan.
0
u/Skylantech 10h ago
2
u/sevinup07 10h ago
I've never used their non stick stuff, but I have a bunch of their stainless steel pans and they work great. No problem with sticking, good heat distribution. You just have to know how to cook.
1
u/Skylantech 10h ago
You know, you bring up a valid point. Knowing the fundamentals of cooking and heat distribution is key.
But the point you've kinda made is about stainless steel pans. Cheap or pricey, I don't think I've ever had a bad experience. Stainless steel is absolutely goated, but there is a slight learning curve for people coming from using non-stick or ceramic.
-2
u/Violet_Apathy 10h ago
The only good nonstick is Teflon. All the crap out today is garbage. The toxins make the difference 😤
You're going to have to learn how to Cook on cast iron. They're the closest you're going to get to nonstick. You can cook eggs on stainless or carbon steel but the learning curve is higher.
2
u/Lytesnam_drobster 10h ago
Worst part is, the teflon itself isnt toxic, its how they make the teflon which makes it toxic, if they just changed the recipe to not have the toxic thing it would be fine, that or hand making the teflon which wouldnt happen because its slower
0
u/Sentient_StickyNote 10h ago
Use cast iron. If correctly seasoned and taken care of, they will be non stick. And bonus, if you accidentally abuse the thing, ruin the seasoning, let it get rusty or whatever, you just clean it really well and season it again. It's a junk of raw iron, you really can't destroy it completely even if you tried.
0
u/Fibrosis5O 10h ago
Ninja set I got has lasted for 3 good years of many cooks hand washes and some dish washer use
They’re the best set I’ve ever had
0
u/GhostMcFunky 10h ago edited 10h ago
For probably less than a set of those you can get ceramic coated Cuisinart pans that nothing sticks to, without PFAS/OS/OA that require about 30% less heat than a standard stainless pan.
I’m sure the higher end ceramics are even better but I’ve never told anyone about my cookware so much until I got a set (not sure I ever even talked about cookware at all) and honestly when I replace them I’ll probably just go to a higher end version of the same.
EDIT: Ceramica XT is the set I have currently, if anyone is interested. Looks like you can get a whole set for about $150.






417
u/danny_ish 10h ago
Yeah, op you still need to learn how to cook