r/leanfire • u/foggyfinch • 3h ago
Financial planning tools for people with stock options and RSUs?
I've been comparing eight financial planning tools, and noticed that most focus on 401(k)s, IRAs, and retirement projections.
But for tech workers with RSUs, ISOs, or NSOs, things get more complicated: AMT, exercise timing, capital gains, and concentrated stock positions can significantly affect long-term financial plans.
I put together a comparison of Boldin, ProjectionLab, Nauma, Origin, Empower, Secfi, Fidelity, and Appleseed, focusing on taxes, investment simulations, Roth conversions, and equity compensation.
Do you use separate tools for equity compensation and retirement planning, or have you found one that handles both well?
| Platform/ Tool | Tax Engine | Investment Simulation | Roth Conversion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boldin | Federal/state tax; manual equity grants; No LTCG and AMT Support. | Monte Carlo; scenario analysis; adjustable returns; Portfolio Glide Path (comparison-only, not integrated into main plan). | Yes - Roth Conversion Explorer, strategy optimization, manual conversions, lifetime tax impact modeling. |
| ProjectionLab | Federal/state tax, AMT, NIIT, RMD, IRMAA, ACA; RSU grants; Support LTCG. No ISO/NSO support. | Monte Carlo; historical backtesting; adjustable returns; integrated stock/bond Glide Path; account-level allocation settings. | Yes - Roth Conversion Optimizer; tax-bracket and IRMAA-aware strategies; lifetime tax comparisons. |
| Nauma | Federal/state tax, ISO/NSO; concentrated stock; QSBS; exchange funds; VPF; DAF/CRUT; QCD; LTCG; ACA/IRMAA/RMD. | Monte Carlo; goal probability; investment allocation and integrated Portfolio Glide Path affecting financial goals and success probabilities. | Yes - models Roth Conversions and tax/ACA/IRMAA/RMD impact. No Terminal Wealth Optimizer. |
| Origin | ISO/NSO/RSU; ISO exercise and AMT simulations. No LTCG Support. | Equity Simulation Tools | No Roth Conversions Support |
| Empower Retirement Planner | No Tax Engine. The user needs to specify Effective Tax Rate. | 5,000 simulations for fixed 6.6% annual return and 10.7% volatility. No Portfolio customization and Glide Path support. | No Roth Conversions Support |
| Secfi | Federal/state equity tax scenarios, ISO/NSO exercise tax modeling; AMT estimates; Support LTCG | Equity valuation and exit scenarios; exercise timing comparisons; No portfolio-wide Monte Carlo and Glide Path. | No Roth Conversions Support |
| Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | No Tax Engine. | Monte Carlo. No Glide Path support. | Separate Roth Conversion Calculator |
| Appleseed | Federal/state tax; LTCG, FICA, NIIT, IRMAA, RMDs and RSU taxation; detailed tax breakdowns (Pro); No ISO/NSO exercise or AMT modeling | Monte Carlo; No Glide Path support. | Roth Conversion Optimizer (Pro). |