r/amiwrong • u/Nurgle24Knack • 8h ago
Am I wrong for refusing to hand over a cake my roommate sold when the customer showed up at our apartment?
My roommate started selling custom cakes about four months ago. She's actually pretty good at it, and I was happy for her when she started getting regular orders.
We share a two-bedroom apartment. At first she was making maybe one cake every other weekend, which was fine.
Now our kitchen is basically a bakery. There are cake boxes stacked on top of the microwave, frosting supplies everywhere, and usually half our fridge is occupied by orders.
We've had a few conversations about it. I don't mind her baking, but I told her I don't want strangers coming to our apartment for pickups, and I'm not comfortable being involved in her business.
She agreed.
Saturday morning, around 10:30, someone knocked on our door.
It was a woman picking up a birthday cake.
My roommate wasn't home. She'd gone to work at her regular job.
The woman showed me their messages. My roommate had sent her our address and written, "My roommate will be there, she'll give it to you."
Nobody had asked me.
I texted my roommate and she immediately called, telling me the cake was in the fridge and I just needed to give it to the customer.
Then she mentioned I was supposed to collect the remaining $45 in cash.
I said absolutely not. I'm not taking money from strangers, dealing with orders, or being responsible if something goes wrong with a cake I didn't make.
The customer looked genuinely upset. She'd driven about 35 minutes and needed the cake for her daughter's birthday party that afternoon.
I felt terrible for her, but I told her she'd have to arrange pickup directly with my roommate.
She left without the cake.
My roommate ended up leaving work early to meet her, and apparently the customer was furious. She demanded a partial refund for the wasted trip.
Now my roommate is saying I deliberately sabotaged her business over something that would've taken thirty seconds.
She's right about that part. The cake was sitting right there. I could've handed it over.
But I also feel like she deliberately put me in a position where saying no would make me look like an asshole.
We both pay rent, and I never agreed to turn our apartment into a place of business.
Am I wrong for refusing to help in that particular moment, knowing the customer was the one who'd suffer?