r/highschool • u/Due-Return1371 • 9h ago
Class Advice Needed/Given My friend asked me to critique his essay. I’m more concerned.
galleryHello! My (17M) friend (16M) recently asked me for assistance on what seems like a pretty monumental essay for his grade. He sent me his finished piece, and .. well. I was shocked.
He’s a junior in high school (11th grade), and I’m a senior (12th grade). This writing isn’t gibberish, but it’s.. It looks incredibly barren for what someone his grade should be writing.
I was beginning to markup his paper when he told me to stop, because he turned it in and got a perfect mark. Am I crazy?! I wasn’t even finished editing the first paper when he messaged me that he’d gotten an A.
I really feel like the school system just wants to push him out and isn’t taking any time to build his essay-writing or general english skills. Apparently, he told me it’s the same with mathematics (he expressed that he knows he’s delayed when it comes to mathematics).
Am I being hypercritical, or is this essay just not up to par? A few of our other friends told me I’m just being an asshole, but I’m genuinely concerned that they’re just passing kids because they don’t want to spend the time honing their academic skills.
I’ve offered to tutor him and he accepted, but our other friends say I’m dragging it out and that it isn’t this serious.
What about when a college asks for a 10-pager? What about any college work, actually??
Help!!! 😭 This is kind of an AITA post, I just really need a second opinion.