r/newborns • u/illGiveYou2 • 8h ago
Feeding Family Dispute
Okay I'll start by saying I do not have children. I repeat, I do not have biological children of my own. I have never been pregnant, I have never given birth, I have never breast fed an infant.
Now that's out of the way, I have a genuine question for those of you that have/are doing those things.
My sister in law asked my mom to watch her 4 month old for a few hours today. She pumps, but also has a bit of trouble producing enough at times. She left 4 ounces of milk with my mom today for about 3 hours total time.
My mom ended up feeding him a little over 3 ounces. When my SIL came to pick him up, she was quite irritated that my mom "overfed" him. She says he's on a strict 2 oz every 2 hours regimen, and now "she won't have enough to get him through the night" because my mom gave him more than 2 oz.
My mom called me and at first didn't mention it, but then I could tell something was wrong. She said she's worried they won't let her keep him anymore because she didn't follow their instructions.
Okay. I get it. They have a system, it works for them and my mom kinda messed that up. I get it. My SIL works full time, she's a new mother, she's going through it right now and now she has to pivot.
.
Last month, the pediatrician said he was underweight and needed more feedings. My SIL doesn't want to use formula (her choice), but acknowledges that she struggles to keep up with pumping.
I know absolutely nothing about feeding babies, and I've never felt the shame that some mothers feel because they can't produce enough. (I've had friends tell me that, again, never experienced it myself obviously). I can't imagine what that feels like. I'm not judging her at all. When she called me later talking about it, I opened my big fat mouth and said "have you tried supplementing with formula?" And ... That was the wrong thing to say apparently.
Anyway, how can I, someone who has never had children, even remotely suggest that maybe she should consider supplementing formula? Or do I need to have a seat and keep my mouth shut? If that's the answer, okay. I'll never mention it again.
My mom was really upset. I just want to make her feel better. Can y'all offer some advice?
ETA: thank you so much so far for the replies. I honestly think she's a new mom and she thinks she's doing what she's supposed to do. She would never harm him. I also feel the need to add, that I'm not there when he's fed. She very well may feed him more than 2 ounces at a time, but I'm only going by what I was told by my mom and my SIL. In other words, I'm sure she feeds him what he needs, but maybe didn't prepare for the extra that my mom fed him for that short time and that upset her routine. Please do not think she's a bad mother, she's just young and this is her first. She loves my nephew and takes care of him.
ETA2: thank you to each and every persont that took the time to educate me. I sincerely appreciate it. I realize I'm not there every single time my nephew eats, I'm not there and have no clue as to the feeding schedule. I've learned not to take things literally, that "2x every 2 hours" may mean throughout the day, not considering the overnight feeding and what goes on in their home. I've learned a lot from y'all, and thank you for commenting. I'm no longer going to reply to comments. Thank you again for responding and thank you for the education I've received. Those of you that believe in a higher power, I welcome prayer for my family. Those of you who don't, I welcome good thoughts and positive energy sent our way. ♥️ Thanks again