I'll start first. It's easily Gabe.

Gabe's main flaw that I can understand is that he's reckless around others. But the moment where somebody pushes back against him, Gabe starts becoming unreasonable. For example, after Kate was shot and was brought back to Prescott to be aided by Eleanor, Gabe wanted to help her but due to him seeing her bleeding out too much, he chooses to distance himself from the situation and goes outside and beats himself up from running.

And when we talk to him later as Javi, we learn his main motivator as a character is that he doesn't want to be helpless and he has to be a man, just as David was. He does promise Javi that he "is" going to do something instead of sitting back and watching.

After Prescott is attacked and Javi and the others began to flee on a road where Conrad starts to get blame Javi, Gabe then chooses to aim his gun at Conrad after he felt Javi was being threatened (which is understandable to an extent even though Conrad was just pointing a finger at Javi). But instead of Gabe trying to give Conrad any meaningful input to help him come around after the recent loss of Francine, Gabe then just chooses to run away, even though that was the EXACT same thing Gabe chose to beat himself up over.

It just goes to show how the writers just dismissed at the opportunity of Gabe becoming a "man" in that scene. The writers could've also made Gabe relate with Conrad with the recent loss of his sister Mariana.

Gabe then throughout the season then proceeds to become the exact same person that he was from before without barely any growth. (aside from the Conrad choice)

In the end, Gabe "could" change, but never would. He truly is a potential man.

II’m replaying The Walking Dead. In my previous playthrough, I saved Carley, but this time I chose Doug. I noticed that Carley is the one who gives Lee the opportunity to tell the group about his past as a convicted killer. Since I saved Doug, is there another dialogue option where I can tell Kenny about Lee’s past? Also, if Kenny finds out about Lee’s past through Lilly instead, does that negatively affect Kenny’s willingness to help Lee save Clementine?

A lot of people see Arvo as purely evil, but I honestly think there's more to him than that. To me, he's just a scared teenager who's been through a lot of trauma and doesn't really know how to deal with it.

One of the biggest reasons people hate him is the ambush at the end of Episode 4. The main argument is that even if you choose not to steal from him, he still sets you up. But honestly, I'm not convinced the ambush was even his idea in the first place.

Throughout the entire confrontation, Arvo seems more guilty and terrified than anything else. He's visibly miserable, keeps stumbling over his words, desperately begs everyone to stop fighting, and even looks genuinely shocked when he realizes there's a baby with the group.

My theory is that when Arvo told his group he'd been robbed/threatened, the others decided to go after the group for revenge and forced him to come along. Arvo always struck me as a pretty peaceful and coward person, and I don't think he has much say in what his group does. The other guys seem to be the ones calling the shots. If I remember correctly, you can even try to make a deal with Arvo during the confrontation, and he seems willing to consider it, only for one of the other guys to tell him to decline.

Then there's the frozen lake scene and Luke's death. I don't think Arvo deliberately planned for that to happen, but even if he did, I still don't think his actions after the shootout can be explained by him being pure evil. There's clearly a lot more going on.

Imagine desperately trying to save your sick sister, only to watch her and everyone else in your group die. Then, instead of being given any time to process what happened, you're taken hostage and subjected to constant abuse by someone who treats you like a punching bag.

And let's be real, a lot of Arvo's actions toward the end are directly tied to Kenny's treatment of him. Being subjected to that kind of relentless cruelty, especially after losing everything, could push just about anyone to their breaking point.

What's interesting is that we see a similar pattern with Kenny himself. The more people he loses and the more trauma he goes through, the more volatile and aggressive he becomes. Both characters are shaped by their suffering, and both end up lashing out at others because of it.

That's why I think Arvo shooting Clementine is more complicated than people make it out to be. I'm not saying what he did was okay, and I'm definitely not trying to justify shooting Clem. But after everything that happened, I can see how the constant abuse from Kenny pushed Arvo into a state of desperation where he just snapped and acted out of pure survival instinct.

I just think Arvo is a much more tragic and complex character than people give him credit for. He's not innocent, obviously, but I don't think he's the one-dimensional villain so many players make him out to be.

I finished the whole series and am replaying it again

And I always wondered, was the reason Lee cutting off his arm didn't work because it was too late or did they just not want to kill Clem in the last season?

Cause I think them backing out of the already sorta cheap full circle was weird, especially because we go the whole series believing that it doesn't work-

We're back with the Fourth Round! Here's yesterday's top comments

1. Lilly (Oregon) goes into Defense Mode (2 Upvotes)

2. Tavia (Nevada) invades Clinton (California) (2 Upvotes)

3. Pete (Guam) bombs Ben (Palau), Abel (Hawaii), and Samantha (NM Islands) (1 Upvote)

Here's what happened

Lilly's Defense Mode healed her 12 HPs, she's now on 17/25 HP

Tavia's wannabe invasion failed costing her 11 HPs, leaving her on 14/25 HPs... Clinton's invincible I guess

Pete's bombings were the real winners here, dealing 5 HPs to Ben who's now on 16/25 HPs, 8 HPs to Abel who's on 17/25 HPs now, and 15 HPs (the max for a bomb attack) on Samantha who's now on 10/25 HPs

Let's see what's next!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kKDQxWnOSEzetQj6iM_Yixrn8oN2e3z7KMqBWOGjdVM/edit?usp=drivesdk

Lee is obviously obama

Luke is bernie bro

I recently replayed S3 + S2 (in the wrong order, I know), and I'm very curious to ask y'all something.

I know that there are many opinions on S2, especially regarding the ending. But I'm gonna give you all an opportunity to talk about 1) What you liked about S2? and 2) what you did not like?

Personally, I prefer S2 over S3 + S4, mainly because I think S2 captures the same bleak tone as S1 (if not bleaker). Upon revisiting both S2 and S3, the emotional weight is undeniably incomparable.

On the other hand, I do find it very frustrating how everyone (and I mean EVERYONE) seem to depend on an 11-yo to do EVERYTHING. I get that it'd be boring to have Clem do nothing, sure, but it would not have hurt to have a few more competent adults >.<

Who else would you add to this wonderful list of the most charming people?😘

Live now on NexusMods! Download it at

https://www.nexusmods.com/thewalkingdeadthetelltaledefinitiveseries/mods/309

Major Character Fates and Deaths we'll be discussing throughout the season:

• Omar took Minerva's place as the brainwashed Delta Soldier
• Mitch took Brody's death in the basement
• Who takes Marlon's place? and Who takes AJ place as the shooter? *(*Shot and killed with a revolver after confessing to trading away Omar and Sophie, plus murdering Brody)
• Who takes Mitch's place? *(*Stabbed in the neck with a knife during the Delta's raid)
• Who takes Louis and Violet's place in the raid? (Who is captured and who is saved)
• Who takes Abel's place? *(*Severely injured and falls from a balcony; dies of internal bleeding).
• Who takes James' place? (Killed/Dissapointed by whoever takes Lilly's place in the final fight in the boat)
• Who takes Lilly's place? (Killed/Spared by whoever takes AJ's place in the final fight in the boat)
• Who takes Minerva's place? *(*Severely bitten and mauled by walkers on the bridge, it doesn't have to be her counterpart, Omar)
• Tenn (This one is determinant, but we'll have it as canon. He's killed in order to save whoever takes Violet's or Louis spots.
• Clementine (We are making it canon here. Is bitten on the leg by a walker and but down by in the barn)

TODAY: Who takes Marlon's death and who shoots?

So, everyone knows how this goes:

You comment to kill and/or defend a character to influence the fate being discussed today. Keep in mind that insightful comments count as 3 votes! The idea is to give some extra weight to people who put a bit more thought into their arguments, rather than simply leaving a name.

What counts as an insightful comment? It doesn't have to be an essay, not stress over writing a book, this is just made so the people who bothers to leave a thought feels somewhat rewarded. Just give a thoughtful argument, an interesting perspective, or a solid explanation of why you think a character deserves their fate. A little reasoning goes a long way, and these are purely judged in base of that, not whether I agree with them or how popular the opinion is.

Simply repeating a character's name or saying you agree with someone will count as a vote, but is not the same

A quick disclaimer:

This is just a fun community game, not a serious competition.

The insightful vote bonus is only meant to reward people who put extra thought into their comments. It isn't meant to invalidate anyone else's opinion or turn every discussion into a debate. You can still participate with a simple comment, and nobody is expected to write an essay to have their voice heard.

No need to stress over it

@eths_artdump on Instagram

Like i said in the title, i recently got the definitive edition since ive been planning to replay seasons 1 - 2 for nostalgic purposes, im currently in episode 4 of season 2 but when i finished episode 3 it says i chopped off saritas hand but in the end i killed the walker biting saritas hand. I tried replaying ep 3 multiple times at this point but that end choice just wont change

Honestly, this made my day.

I got a reply from Jared Emerson-Johnson, the composer behind the music of Telltale's The Walking Dead Season 1, and I'm genuinely so happy about it.

I shared some images with him, especially related to my favourite track, The Gauntlet ie Armed with Death.

These tracks have always stuck with me. The music in Telltale's TWD is such a huge part of what makes the game memorable, and Armed with Death in particular is just incredible.

Never really expected to get a response, so seeing one from the actual composer feels pretty surreal. Just wanted to share this here because I figured people in this sub would understand why I'm so excited about it.

Still can't believe it haha.

Locking me in a shed and almost shooting me.then Be an asshole to me after shouldve been out the door right then and there. Even tho I don't fw kenny like that id still prefer to stay with him and his group

I recently replayed the whole series, and I think S1 is obviously the og and is a very solid game, emotions, intensity and character depth.

But I think it's not very immersive, and telltale games and choose your own adventure are kind of supposed to be super immersive.

S1 and S3 felt very....cut and dry? It felt like it had a set course you had to take and the mcs weren't really a product of your creation, now they get a pass on that bc the mcs in S1 and S3 are building Clem not themselves. But the game itself doesn't feel immersive

I have my qualms with s4, I think it's a fabulous game, I cried for like an hour after finishing it, but it felt...out of character almost? But it was a beautifully immersive game. I love the detail of collectibles and wish they introduced that earlier into the series.

S2 is by far my favorite, I think it's the most solid game in the series, it's really intense, it's emotionally taxing, it feels like the choices you make and the things you say matter, its immersive, you can tell s2 is what truly built Clem. And the cast was actually likable.

I know that a lot of people really like S3, and I loved Javi with my every being and it had so much potential but I feel they kind of forgot about it in all honesty.

And S4 I felt was a beautiful game and I loved how full circle is was to S1 but it didn't feel...right? If that makes sense. It felt like we brought up this character through her whole childhood and she just flipped a switch suddenly. Especially for those of us who chose "Always Keep Moving"

I helped Kenny “kill” Larry but he didn’t do fuckall to save me. His dumbass face was through the gap in the door and then Lilly had to jump out and save me instead

But I’ve seen clips where Kenny DOES save you, and it’s pretty much the same animation as what Lilly did for me

Why didn’t Kenny save me?

Welcome back to TWDG All Out War!! Last top three comments were

1. Lilly (Oregon) invades Clinton (California) (4 Upvotes)

2. Sarah (New Jersey) invades Christa (New York) (4 Upvotes)

3. Ben (Palau) invades Pete (Guam) (4 Upvotes)

How did these orders go?

Lilly's invasion FAILED terribly and almost got her out of the game, she lost 20 HPs and is now on 5/25

On the contrary, Sarah's invasion was a huge SUCCESS, dealing an insane 25 HPs, destroying Christa of New York, making her our first elimination. Very sad indeed for Christa fans... Which is me btw... im devasta-- ANYWAY, New York has become a Substate of New Jersey, and Sarah has received 3 extra bombs from the corpse of Christa. Insane.

Ben's gonna take us back down because his invasion also FAILED but not as terribly, he only lost 4 HPs

Our first state has fallen... let's keep going!!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kKDQxWnOSEzetQj6iM_Yixrn8oN2e3z7KMqBWOGjdVM/edit?usp=drivesdk

^ For rules and character stats