r/AskVegans • u/Icy-Mess-860 • 10h ago
Ethics How do you feel about killing spotted lantern flies or other invasive species?
I was talking to my sister last night who is a vegan (I am a vegetarian) and the topic of invasive species came up since my state (in the US) has recently had spotted lantern flies arrive and the official recommendation is to kill them and report them as they are extremely invasive and kill local plants. I said that when I have to I squish them but I don't take any joy in it, I think that doing what I can to preserve our local ecosystem is more important than the life of these insects. She said she hasn't come across any where she lives yet but would likely take the same stance as me.
I was wondering how other vegans feel about this? Or about instances where institutions might be killing invasive species but you are not directly being asked to do so (for instance, invasive Lion Fish are killed but you aren't personally doing the killing).
I think it's complicated because invasive species are always introduced by human error or ignorance, so it isn't their fault they are there but at the same time are so detrimental to the ecosystems they are introduced in that for the greater good they should be limited somehow, and while somehow limiting the breeding population would be ideal imo sterilization isn't really feasible so for me it lands on a utilitarian tilt of what the greatest good or least harm would be in the big picture. I often see vegans talk about being against the exploitation of animals and I think this creates an additional layer since it isn't necessarily exploitation (although often times these animals were introduced due to some sort of exploitation)