r/ArtCrit • • Sep 07 '26

FINALLY! The Place To Sell Your Art And An ArtCrit Casual Sub By Yours Truly

27 Upvotes

You asked for it.

We heard you.

We delivered!

In our last news update we touched lightly on how much your words of encouragement mean to us. The sub has grown tremendously in the past year and we couldn’t be happier to see you all giving constructive feedback to one another.

We’ve also heard the people who have enjoyed our moderation style, but wanted something more lighthearted and discussion-focused. We’re also well aware that there’s a lack of subreddits where people are allowed to self-promote and advertise.

That being said, I’m happy to introduce our two new subs!

r/ArtistNook is a casual, cozy, discussion-focused sub moderated by leighabbr and myself. While r/ArtCrit has strict rules on posts, r/ArtistNook is much more laid back.

You can share information, talk about your artwork or OCs, post your work with links to your social media, and even ask for pricing help if you share the required information so people can actually help you with your prices.

This sub has been up for about two weeks, so there’s some light activity already.

We can’t wait to see you there!

r/ArtStore is an active, large sub focused on connecting artists and buyers. You can self-promote, sell your prints, advertise your commissions, shops, and handmade goods. We do not allow drop shippers or mass-produced goods of any kind.
With the holiday season approaching, this may be just the sub you need to get eyes on your work!

Leighabbr and I are so honored to be leading these communities. We’re still fine tuning them both and, like when we took charge in r/ArtCrit, we’re open to ideas and feedback.

Thank you all for your continued support! We honestly couldn’t have gotten this far without you!


r/ArtCrit • • Sep 01 '26

STUDY SERIES Study Series: Part 2 - Composition

Post image
2 Upvotes

Welcome back to the Study Series!

Moving away from values and contrast, we’re moving into the next important part of your work – composition!

Composition is the way an artist arranges the pieces of their image to help guide the viewer’s eyes where they want it to go. A strong composition can be used to create a specific mood, tell a story, create balance, and direct attention to important areas of the piece.

For those commenting, think about where your eye goes first when you look at the image. Does it feel balanced or does the image seem to “lean” to one side? Are there any distracting areas or does anything feel crowded or awkward?

Let’s work together to create stronger pieces with composition!

REQUIREMENTS FOR POSTING

Please note that all general sub rules apply (no AI, no fishing for compliments, no giving personal info, etc). Only our post requirements are different here.

- Pieces must;

a) Be no more than 6 months old and/or

b) Must still be being worked on and/or

c) Must have the intention of being recreated.

- Works must follow our NSFW rules.

- Since no context is required in these posts, draw and paint-overs are automatically expected. If you don’t want these, say so.

GIVING CRITIQUE

Only critique the piece regarding the topic of the week. If the artist would like additional critique, they can make a post in the main sub. Critiques are still expected to be constructive and polite.


r/ArtCrit • • 20h ago

Does this fall flat?

Thumbnail
gallery
151 Upvotes

So this is half of my painting thus far. It’s oil on canvas. What do you think of it? i’m planning on leaving more and more of the red to bleed through as I paint the foreground because it’s so bright. Idk does it fall flat to you? like not impressionistic enough or not realistic enough. Too much detail or not enough? Do you think there’s life to it?

I know a lot of people love negative space but that wasn’t my original goal with this so the huge bright red chunk will not be there as it progresses.

Also i’m painting this to hang in my house, not to give to someone or sell it. I like to paint things for my house that I think are pretty. The original video reminds me of my childhood. The reference photo is a screenshot from Mateusz Kalafut’s instagram video of his beautiful garden. This won’t be used for anything commercial. i’m asking for opinions because most people are more cerebral when it comes to art than I am, the different ideas help me get out of my own head. I’m trying to develop my painting ability but still just painting whatever speaks to me lol. At some point i’ll have to paint lemons or something and actually get better but until then this is what im doing .

Also if you’ve seen this post on another r/ i’m sorry I wasn’t sure where would be the best spot to post.

thanks :)


r/ArtCrit • • 3h ago

Critique on this artwork? It's finished, but I want to know anything I could have done better!

Post image
6 Upvotes

I only used references of my own OCs, and I briefly looked at pictures of lantern festivals to get an idea of what they're like. The goldfish on the left was designed on the spot, inspired by floral japanese kimonos.


r/ArtCrit • • 12h ago

my first sticker sheet design!!(wip) any tips/feedback so far??

Post image
17 Upvotes

I’m working on a 4x6 sticker sheet! The original theme was dark fantasy, but now I’m just going for a more gothic/ritualistic/religious vibe I think??

I’m still rendering a few things like the heart (potion maybe?) and pomegranate, but any feedback on the layout, elements, and overall cohesiveness so far would be much appreciated :)

(I used a combo of a few different references and can post them in the comments if needed, but I didn’t heavily reference a single image in particular)


r/ArtCrit • • 7h ago

Anatomy and shading practice, something is off...

Post image
4 Upvotes

Tried doing memory, minimal references except for some muscle group guides


r/ArtCrit • • 11h ago

First time drawing realistic eye (first photo is the drawing. Rest refs)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

(Yess I know about the extra ring and that it’s not a perfect circle)

First time doing a realistic eye. I’ve done an eye one other time, but I had pink involved and it was more of a, “I shade in this color then that color and call it an eye” than an eye, eye. The second photos are the references. Also I’m pretty sure that third photo is AI but I still added it because the darker shading at the top gave me an idea to add that.

Just looking for critique on how one would improve from here. Obviously it’s not super good but it’s the best I got right now. Also funny enough, the highlights started to build themselves, so I leaned into it and that ended up working out pretty well.

I probably should clarify, I’m not planing to push into art or anything. If it develops naturally, it develops naturally. I was just wondering what all I missed. And my experience with trying to truly make art, is near zilch. So..??

(Better photo in the comments, in the replies of a half face art piece)


r/ArtCrit • • 22h ago

UPDATED WORK This feels much better. Thanks for all your help yesterday! [before and ref included]

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Still not PERFECT, but it’s time to step away for a day or two.


r/ArtCrit • • 14h ago

Is there too much going on here?

Post image
6 Upvotes

This piece is my outlook on AI, simply as an introspective study. What if “we” as in billionaires did achieve this “enlightenment” that allowed them to create a “perfect” world. I used no reference for this. It is being completed with oil paint and it is on canvas.

In the foreground the viewer is place looking out through a window into the perfect world. There are human batteries on conveyor belts and then being led to this gear device (still working this out). To the left along the border there are openings in which these human batteries are coming out. Leading to the top left which has a human like face that is being bent like pipe work. This large red pipe I want to be a recurring theme throughout my series.

The mid ground is a woman being created by this AI “underworld” piece of machinery on the middle window area. I’m trying to insinuate that she is about to walk out the door. There is a cave behind the woman. Above towards the top I want another perspective leading off back into the underworld.

In the right window, there is an outside landscape that I am still working out.

Thanks!


r/ArtCrit • • 5h ago

Looking for crit - and help!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

hello! I'm doing a class in tone and here is some of my work so far, and the set ups that we were given as references.

I'm really shaky with still life, and all that comes with it (perspective, composition, accuracy) and that first bit is my weakness among others, but I think learning tone is giving me a bit more practice.

I'd love to learn more, but how do I become more accurate with my drawings?


r/ArtCrit • • 16h ago

What's off about my drawing?

Post image
7 Upvotes

No reference was used.

For context, the two characters are supposed to be having an argument and the figure on the right is supposed to be crossing his arms

My main problem is how flat and stiff things look.

I think something is off about the anatomy and posing but I can't pinpoint what. Any advice is appreciated, thanks in advance


r/ArtCrit • • 18h ago

Finally finished it, some stuff are off but I still like it tho (ref at pic 2)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/ArtCrit • • 18h ago

Clothes practice, what am I doing wrongly?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I'm not satisfied with the end results, but don't know how to fix it, especially the last one, I don't like how the shadows and the light in the shadows look, I want to give the clothes a semi realistic style and make jt look painted

reference is included


r/ArtCrit • • 16h ago

How can this be less flat?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I’m working on a tinyyy canvas for a group show and was really excited about my concept. Trouble is I don’t normally work on canvas 😅 this does not use a reference.

I use gouache and would typically do some shading with layers of color but I’m kind of stuck and don’t know how to make it more interesting.

The work in progress (second photo) looked more interesting to me 😅 I kind of wish I’d stuck to the monochromatic theme and used a few different layers of magenta (the base color).

I painted this using acrylic gouache (sooo acrylic).

Any advice would be greatly appreciated 😅


r/ArtCrit • • 15h ago

Trying to emulate the spiderverse artstyle. critiques?

Post image
1 Upvotes

This is a scene in an animation I’m making and I have this fridge that I’m trying to have match (or at least inspired by) the spiderverse artstyle, but I feel like it falls flat. To me it looks boring and 2D. It’s not complete, but what do you think?

Don’t really have a reference, but I’m trying to make it seem like light is coming from a window and shining on the refrigerator.

Made on ibisPaint


r/ArtCrit • • 15h ago

Color help?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I am aware the line art as is could use some work, which I'll refine more later, but how would I make this color palette be similar to a "two/three pallette"? The best one I can think of is the MC ui from Persona 3 Reload. Here's the reference for him on slide 2


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

Something is off with her face. [ref included]

Thumbnail
gallery
230 Upvotes

r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

I'm not quite sure what I'm making, but I like making it...

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Good day artists! I'm hoping for some critique on a new process I've been working on to convert my old photography into physical crafted art pieces. In a nutshell I'm making digital 'marquetry' pieces, but because I design everything digitally, and then print the pieces with FDM printer, I have a bit of imposter syndrome when trying to stand up against hand-cut wooden marquetry or mosaic work. I love the idea of revitalizing my old art in a new way and these are relaxing to work on.. but will the fact that a 3D printer is involved harm perception and make people think of them as cheap trinkets? I'm also a bit worried that they're coming out too impressionistic in cases like the woodland scene attached... are they to the point where they're just blobs of color on a board, or do you still see them as recognizable forms?

This is my latest piece "Cat Nap" and is appx 16 x 20" with over 500 pieces in 10 colors. 26 hours print time / 15 hours assembly.
(Also a few other works that came before, all 12 x 12" and anywhere between 150 and 300 pieces.)

(Rather not post the reference for "Cat Nap" as its of my young daughter, but the others have their references attached)

Thanks for looking!


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

needing some critics on stippling work

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

i don't typically use the stippling method, i don't enjoy it but i'm trying to get better at it. I could really use some constructive criticism on how to do it better, it looks strange to me.

I used random reference pictures from pinterest for the line work, none of them were made with this kind of shading. i can try and find them for anyone who'd like them!


r/ArtCrit • • 23h ago

Need some help with lighting, anatomy, and clothing

Post image
0 Upvotes

I use references all the time but I prefer if someone would markup or even tell me what I need to improve and recommend any references or websites I can use to improve my art


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

i feel like both of these just look off but can’t tell how?

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

i can’t tell if it’s proportions or angles or both… reference photos at the end are what i’m trying to emulate. also i feel that the drawing doesn’t match the picture but i don’t know what’s off TvT


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Help with posing for fire breather

Post image
3 Upvotes

Started this piece a while ago and just looked at it again and I feel it has promise but it just looks off. It’s supposed to be provocative (hence wide open legs) and she’s supposed to be holding a match to her lips. I’ve tried changing the left arm (her right) position but it just looks weird. (Feet are closer to digitigrade than plantigrade)

Digital, Procreate
No references used
Looking for anatomy critique


r/ArtCrit • • 1d ago

Likeness help request!

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hi hi! Trying to do a fan art of my sweet boy, Kim Kitsuragi of Disco Elysium fame. Thing is, he's a fictional man, and the official art of him is 1) very stylized, and 2) has him wearing big ol glasses so I feel like I'm struggling to pick out what makes Kim so Kim-like here. Any guidance/suggestions super welcome. I fear I have just gone and drawn a generic handsome man once again.

Reupload because I forgot to mention that the reference is the second image in the text body

Medium is digital painting, procreate.


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

Recent practice

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

Cant change tag for some reason?

Anyway. Color has always been one of my weakest areas. I feel pretty confident in finding form, but color are so hard... I feel like I am getting better at understanding chroma and value, but it's still not there. Heres some recent practice using drawme-requests I made these by picking colors myself, portraits took just under 1 hour each, the gentleman with the glass just below 2 hours. I don't know if that's good or bad, but it's a lot faster than I used to need for something like this.

Like, I can see looking at these that the colors don't match the references, but I can't quite look at these objectively to figure out if I made good choices or not. All thoughts on these or on how to improve in general are most welcome.


r/ArtCrit • • 2d ago

Looking for anatomy help

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I am working on this digital painting but I don’t like the anatomy much right now. I’m looking for help spotting the problem. I’ve included a picture of the reference I used. It’s not the best I know, but I liked the pose.

The character is also supposed to be muscular so I tried to include that.