For transparency: I'm trying to sort through something personal, relevant to my community but not urgently / directly, so I'm using the "Ethics" flair here. I'm going to try to keep things kinda vague because I want to hear different perspectives to inform a decision. I am not currently pregnant, nor looking to adopt.
Background: due to my particular community and culture, many people I love and care about were abused as kids. They're no-contact with their families of origin, and they wish they'd been adopted by non-abusive families.
And even more people in my life, like this poster, suffer due to poverty and would trade their relationship with their family for wealth. [I originally put more details here, but it felt too personal so I deleted it. Tldr vers.: my loved one developed CPTSD from severe childhood poverty + parents not being able to pay for medical care nor treatment for their own mental illnesses.]
The thing is, being adopted is romanticized in my community / subculture. There's a lot of love for "found family" narratives, as well as the idea of giving your child something you were denied. The fantasy is also about automatically being wanted, rather than being seen as a burden until you prove otherwise.
But part of the romanticization comes from how uncommon it is. I can only think of 3 people in my real life who were adopted, and all had upper middle class or wealthy adoptive families--very different from most people in my circle!
(Not including kinship adoption, which is more common, but also usually unofficial if that makes sense. Like if you can take care of your sister's kids during a hard time, you do it, no reason to go to court over it).
Ethics question: I'm hoping to hear from people with different perspectives, from different cultures and backgrounds. Particularly from:
- Adoptees whose adoptive families are wealthier than their first families
- Low income parents who either placed their child up for adoption, or considered it but eventually decided against it
Based on your experience, what factors make placing a child for adoption into a wealthier family the right or wrong decision?
I have heard from many who wish they'd been placed for adoption, and I'd like to get a fuller picture with multiple perspectives outside of what I hear regularly.