I’m planning a trip to NYC in mid-October with my boyfriend, 8 days total for my 30th birthday. We’re coming from Italy and staying in Guttenberg, NJ to keep costs down, so we’ll be taking the NJ Transit bus to Port Authority every day (and maybe the NY Waterway ferry once or twice). We are trying to diversify and not overstay in Manhattan, as you can see with a full Brooklyn day and half a day in Queens.
EDIT: Please, I’m not looking for suggestions to stay somewhere other than Guttenberg. The accommodation is already booked, and changing it isn’t really my call: this whole trip was planned and gifted to me by my partner, and it wouldn’t feel kind to ask to change it.
What we’re into: art, architecture (both Gilded Age and modern), film, public transit, and just strolling around nice neighborhoods.
I know this is very ambitious and I’m sure we’ll end up cutting or moving things around once we’re there, but this is the rough plan:
Day 1:
Land at JFK in the early afternoon and head straight to Chelsea, leaving our bags in a luggage storage spot.
Chelsea galleries and the High Line at sunset.
Pick up the bags and head to NJ for an early night, we’ll be tired.
Day 2:
Moynihan Train Hall, Morgan Library, Grand Central, Ford Foundation atrium, NYPL and Bryant Park.
St Patrick’s and Rockefeller Center in the late afternoon.
Broadway show in the evening (already booked).
Day 3:
Prospect Park and Park Slope in the morning, lunch there.
Transit Museum, then Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO.
Walk the Brooklyn Bridge at sunset, dinner in Chinatown.
Late set at Smalls (already booked).
Day 4:
The Met and Central Park, then a walk past the Fifth Avenue mansions.
Guggenheim during pay-what-you-wish hours.
Halloween streets on the Upper West Side in the evening.
Day 5:
MoMA, plus a look at the Seagram and Lever House.
Flatiron, Union Square, East Village, Washington Square, West Village.
Comedy Cellar in the evening.
Day 6 (BDAY):
Harlem and Hamilton Heights in the morning (Strivers’ Row, City College), then St John the Divine and Columbia.
Unplanned afternoon. But my parents are gifting me currently unknown observation deck tickets for sunset.
Day 7:
Roosevelt Island Tram and Four Freedoms Park, Upper East Side mansions.
SoHo cast-iron buildings, the Whitney, and Little Island at sunset.
Day 8:
Astoria and the Museum of the Moving Image.
Stop at the TWA Hotel before our evening flight from JFK.
Some things I’d love feedback on: is Day 5 realistic or should we split it? Is there anything you’d drop or anything overrated? Any hidden gems along these routes we shouldn’t miss? And since we’re staying in NJ, any tips for getting back late at night?
Thanks in advance!