Recently I broke up with my cis girlfriend due to domestic violence I was enduring, especially physical abuse. A few of the reactions I’ve gotten from people hearing this news has been upsetting to me.
I think it stems from people gripping to this idea that because I am trans and MtF (male to female) that means I’m strong, and stronger than basically any cis woman. It angers me how people judge my physicality based on nothing, like is it true that most people are this uninformed on my biology as a trans person?
For reference I’m a 24F trans woman who has medically transitioned for over 3 years. I’m 172cm (5’7.7”). I was always very skinny, what people would call a “twink” body type at like 130 pounds but I got up to 165 pounds in the last two years during the relationship. I’m not active at all, so all the weight was fat, which kinda just developed the “feminine body” type features I wanted, as I started from basically a skeleton. So I didn’t have like any muscles prior, and even less so after hrt, I have felt how the strength I used to have has been diminished so much.
My cis ex gf on the other hand is a thin person, she was like 140-150 pounds at over 5’10. She was a figure skater coach so she had defined legs but other than that she looked very thin in arms and everywhere else. Maybe slightly broader shoulders than average but that’s it.
Our relationship dynamic was always established as me being the “submissive” one, and her being the “dominant” one, both socially and sexually. Which is what we both liked and felt comfortable with. She was much more physically stronger than me, she could pin me down with her weaker or “bad” arm and I would lose the battle, she could overpower me with little effort, which again I loved in our dynamic. It’s just nice when you’re in the submissive role to know that the other person is actually stronger than you and you aren’t just both faking, ya know?
But then there were arguments where she used that strength against me, she restrained and pinned me to the floor or couch without my consent, with me struggling and yelling trying to get free, and failing. Also times of grabbing and holding my wrists or hair as if they were a leash when she was angry. These were awful experiences and I’m still hurt by them, and by the bruises and marks she left.
Upon a few close family members hearing about this after the breakup, most of their first reactions was “why didn’t you just overpower her or get up”. They were surprised that she was stronger than me. One of my family members straight up not believing me about the fact that I tried to get up and couldn’t.
It feels like they didn’t take it as serious or of an issue, it felt dismissed because they wrongly assume in their head she somehow wasn’t a threat to me, when she was the much stronger one in our dynamic. I feel like they treated me like this strictly because I’m trans and the assumptions they put on me for that.
This really made me think about the other times I experienced these assumptions.
1. a cis girl who I was friends with trying to educate me on how much weaker it feels for her compared to guys in rock climbing, with her assuming I’m like those mentioned guys and not comparable to her. Even tho she works out, is my height, and has actual visible muscles, I guarantee she is physically stronger than me. I would be on a similar playing field as her if I try building up muscles now with my current biology.
2. A few family members, and friends of my mom, assuming I was just wearing a bra to events because I’m trans and want to “look like a woman”, and not actually because I have actual boobs?!? They didn’t know what hrt was and had no idea I had full on c cup breasts.
3. My ex gf complaining to her mom about not being able to open the pickle jar, and her mom asking why she didn’t just get me to do it. While in reality we were both at home struggling with the jar for an hour, and again, my ex was much more likely to get it open than me.
4. Women friends asking me what shapewear I’m using to give my shape, I don’t use shapewear. And then asking how I was able to get a “woman’s ass”. Ummm probably because my weight is programmed genetically and by the activation of estrogen to go to my hips and other typical female areas?
5. My own family doctor scaring me with the diagnoses of anemia. Later casually mentioning “yeah yoir abnormal, your blood levels are in female ranges”. With my other doctor for trans medical issues having to contact her and inform her that YEAH YOUR BLOOD LEVELS BECOME FEMALE TYPICAL WITH FEMALE HORMONES.
Like are these just cherry picked ignorant examples or do the majority of people not know hrt changes like your entire body and how it develops your sex? Do most people know trans people basically go through another puberty, developing sex characteristics, and can sometimes be comparable physically in strength and body to their cis counterparts? Or do most people actually think every single trans woman that exists = 6’2 completely biologically male (phenotypically) who just likes wearing dresses and wigs? Like do they even know hrt exists?
I know there are tall and large trans women, young and old, and every trans person is valid regardless of any medical intervention or physical aspects. But I feel like that kind of archetype is what is assumed for all of us, which just isn’t right to do. I feel like this is one of the main reasons for ignorance in talking about trans people in sports, with people not knowing regulations with hrt existed or what some trans bodies can look like. We aren’t seen as individuals, we are seen as a single stereotype.
I don’t know if it’s as bad as I’ve felt or experience but are most people this uninformed on trans people, what we go through, and just on biology in general?