r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 4d ago

[Xbox Series X] Ace Combat 8 vs Star Wars Galactic Racer

I'm a big fan of racing games. I absolutely loved Ace Combat 7 when I beat it on my PS5 last year. I genuinely cannot decide between the two so I guess the question is which should I buy first? Of course with only Ace Combat 7 to go off of, 8 would be a bit more interesting to pick, at least at first. But Galactic Racer is 10 bucks cheaper and honestly I've never been a huge fan of rogue like elements. I am willing to go out of my comfort zone and give it a try though. Heard GR gets compared to the Burnout series, if that's true this is gonna rock.

9 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

10

u/liamo6w 4d ago

ace combat 8

7

u/Kylestache 4d ago

Galactic Racer for my boy Ben Quadinaros

3

u/Pikminer5087 4d ago

Guy totally deserves a second chance after his podracer fell apart like that in 1999

2

u/fingerbanglover 3d ago

Biddy Blas all day

1

u/Kylestache 3d ago

Scrib doon, baby, scrib doon

7

u/AiHaveU 3d ago

Ace Combat 8 is a masterpiece

6

u/SloppityMcFloppity 3d ago

Ace combat 8, no questions. I like GR, but I'd wait for a sale. It felt quite simple, almost early access like in terms of available content

5

u/Demons_Of_Razgriz 3d ago

If you don’t like or never played Ace Combat, you should try 8

If you have played and loved a previous entry, man what are you waiting for. AC8 is top 3 in the series and A LOT better than 7

6

u/D3mentedG0Ose 3d ago

Ace Combat 8 is amazing in every way. Pick it up

5

u/KandyKane829 3d ago

Starwars will be 50% off within 6 months easily

5

u/Andrew225 4d ago

Galactic Racer I tried and am looking forward to playing

AC8 is the best of the series ever. It's phenomenal. Just play it

6

u/shadow00940 3d ago

If you liked AC7 then you’ll love AC8. It’s what 7 would have been if it hadn’t been in development hell.

5

u/Sebanimation 3d ago

Galactic racer is superfun and crazy addictive. Has me hooked and I am not even a racing guy.

4

u/DillDeer 3d ago

Ace combat 8

9

u/JaSonic2199 4d ago

Ace combat 8 was fantastic and life changing

3

u/EngagedInConvexation 4d ago

Prob AC8 if you like 7 so much.

Racer is available through Prime/Luna though, if you want your cake and to eat it too. (And have the access)

3

u/Metadomino 3d ago

Get both, but 8 is a masterpiece

3

u/Pyronatic 3d ago

Little biased, but I just finished Ace Combat 8. If you loved 7 you need to play 8.

3

u/RoadsideDavidian 3d ago

Galactic racer is not worth $60, which is why it’ll be 50% off before long

3

u/thisrockismyboone 2d ago

Massive fans of both franchises here. I would assume racer will be cheaper faster than ac8. So maybe wait for sale and enjoy ac8 now, the newest entry in one of the all time greatest series of video games

2

u/CMDR_Duzro 3d ago

Ace combat 8. It's most probably the best game I've played and will play this year.

2

u/ReadyPlayerFour 3d ago

I’ve got both and would just like to say you’re going to have a fantastic time with both! Galactic Racer is the closest thing we’ve had to a new Burnout which is super fun. While I liked the last Ace Combat, I’m loving this one.. seems like a big improvement in terms of mission variety

2

u/Ophys79 3d ago

I'm playing through Ace Combat 8 now, it's absolutely amazing.

I saw Vinesauce play some of the Galactic Racer and it looks cool but I'm not sure if it has enough variety to pay full price for.

1

u/ShogunAE86 3d ago

Its 60 bucks...technically not full price.

2

u/MrZagary 3d ago

Havent tried star wars yet. But ac8 was amazing. Actually cared for my squad.

2

u/Calinks 3d ago

Neither genre has been my thing but I got both. I'm looking Ace Combat more but I have only played like 3 missons. Galactic Racer is good but I'm not great at it and it just hasn't pulled me in as much as Ace.

2

u/CynicalNextDoor 3d ago

Played both, and Ace Combat is way better. Galactic racer is not bad, is just not worh its normal price tag, only get it on a deep discount

1

u/CelebrationLeft8607 3d ago

also played both and agree completely. I think Galactic Racer is very good, but AC8 is easily on my top 3 of the year so far.

2

u/Turbo-Chook 2d ago

Both are absolutely excellent.

2

u/Eat--The--Rich-- 4d ago

Galactic racer is really shallow. Almost no customization and you don't really get your own speeder/racer to drive. It also has really extreme rubber banding. Ive been seeing people I wrecked and blew up literally 8 seconds ago passing me like nothing happened. That being said the racing itself is super fun and super fast.

4

u/MemoryNonExistent 4d ago

My exact thoughts. They really should have just remastered ‘Episode I: Racer’ and watched the money roll in.

1

u/VenomBadger 3d ago

Mug off Galatic Racer and play Wipeout HD Collection or Burnout 3.

Ace Combat 8 is the best since Zero.

1

u/HubRumDub 3d ago

Do what I did
Get both

1

u/Rhinoserious95 2d ago

They're equally worth your money

1

u/HarmonizedSnail 2d ago

I finished my first run in AC 8 and then got Racer. I still go back and forth. You'll be able to as well.

Galactic racer does have the rogue like aspect to it - starting runs, getting little upgrades as you go along, then losing and being able to add small permanent upgrades and starting a run again. But to be fair, any racing game has a repetitive aspect to it, so that shouldn't really be a huge factor.

1

u/Worldly_Lunch_1601 2d ago

The biggest thing about galactic racer that I don't see discussed about is that, more than being a racing game,once you start getting good at it, it's a game about systems management.

Keeping track of your boost and your ramjet, and then deciding whether you should go through a heated tube to defrost your vehicle so that it can steer, or stay out of the heated tube to keep your engine cool so you can keep it full throttle.

Most racing games you end up in this zen-like Flow State where everything is working properly and the world kind of floats around you . That never happens in galactic racer. you are always doing 10 things with your adrenaline flowing.

1

u/Agile_Commission_693 3d ago

I refunded Galactic racer after I realised how bad the rubber banding was. In a 4 lap race I’m pretty sure you could sit still for 2 then use the catch up to win,

1

u/CelebrationLeft8607 3d ago

do you mean online or campaign?

1

u/Agile_Commission_693 3d ago

Didn’t play online as it had the 3 player limit and there 5 of us on at the time.
So I tried out the campaign.