r/shortscarystories • u/CBenson1273 • 12h ago
New Age SSS - 1000 Words Or Less My Daughter Still Believed In Unicorns
“Unicorn! Unicorn!”
I looked to where my two-year-old daughter Katie was pointing. There on the screen was a unicorn in the cartoon we were watching.
“Yes, baby, that’s a unicorn. Very good.”
“Katie wanna unicorn!”
“Sure, baby, keep watching this show as long as you like,” I said, working on the report due tomorrow.
“Katie wanna real unicorn!”
With a sigh, I put down my laptop and looked at her. “Unfortunately, Katie, unicorns live in their own magical kingdom far, far away. They hardly ever come down to see us mortals, and people can’t get there.”
She looked up at me, her big blue eyes shiny with unshed tears. “No see real unicorns?”
“No, I’m afraid not, baby. But would you like me to get you a unicorn plushie?”
Instantly her frown of despair was replaced with a smile. “Plushie! Katie wanna unicorn plushie!”
“Then a unicorn plushie Princess Katie shall have.” Crisis averted, I kissed her on the head and put her back down on the floor, where she resumed her show while I picked up the laptop and got back to work.
At dinner that night, Katie was excited to tell her big sister about her latest prize.
“Katie gonna get a unicorn plushie! Like a real unicorn!”
“Oh, please,” said Katie’s older sister Alex. Alex was firmly into the teen years - Dan and I had taken a gap after our first child before trying for another - and had all of the surliness and moodiness that went with them.
“Don’t ruin your sister’s happiness, Alex.”
“But why are you lying to her? Everyone knows unicorns aren’t real.”
Everything stopped; silence overtook the table.
“Alex!!”
Alex just shrugged. “I just figured the kid should know the truth.”
“Just because you’re miserable doesn’t mean you have everyone else feel that way, too!” I chastised her as I looked back at Katie. She just looked up at me, eyes wide.
“Unicorns not real?” I could see her eyes beginning to brim.
“Of course they are, honey. Your sister is just messing with you. Right, Alex?”
Alex shrugged. “Whatever they say, kiddo. What do I know?”
“Mommy?” Katie asked, looking up at me. I just took her in my arms and hugged her. “Don’t worry, sweetheart - you’ll have a unicorn plushie before you know it. Then you can tell your sister all about it.”
That night, after putting Katie to bed, I went to Alex’s room.
“Alex, what’s going on with you?”
“Nothing,” she replied sullenly. “I’m fine.”
“Then why did you do that to your sister earlier? She’s just a baby. You know she still believes in Santa and the Easter bunny and unicorns; all the things you stopped believing in long ago.”
“Well maybe she shouldn’t!” Alex exclaimed. “Maybe she should know what the world’s really like!”
“She’s two, Alex. There will be plenty of time when she’s older for her to learn what the world’s really like.”
“Like you did when dad left?”
That was a low blow. She knew Dan leaving two years ago for his secretary was still a sore spot for me; I’m guessing that’s why she said it.
“You can try to hurt me all you want, but I still love you. If there’s something going on, talk to me. Maybe I can help.”
“You wouldn’t understand.”
“Then help me understand. I know things have been difficult since your father left—”
“It’s not just about him! I don’t know who I am! I don’t fit in anywhere! I don’t…”
“Alex…”
“Forget it!” she said, her eyes brimming with tears of frustration. “You wouldn’t understand anyway. Just leave me alone.”
Not knowing what else to do, I got up and left her room, closing the door behind me. I knew that Dan abandoning us had had an effect on her, but I wasn’t sure what to do. The therapist said she was still adjusting, but even with the sessions and the medication he prescribed, she was always so unhappy. She never had been before.
The next day, I got up, got dressed, made breakfast for everyone, reminded Alex to catch the bus, and drove Katie to day care on my way to work. I spent the day sitting in meetings and working on presentations while thinking about home. By the end of the day, I’d come up with a plan.
I left work and stopped at the pizza shop and the bakery. Afterward I picked Katie up from daycare and headed home. It had been a tough few months, but tonight, we’d sit around in our pajamas, watch cheesy movies, eat pizza and donuts, and just have fun like we used to.
I got home and opened the door, setting Katie loose and going to change out of my work clothes. She’d been talking about her potential unicorn plushie all the way home, and, while I was glad she was so happy, I was ready for a different topic of conversation. Suddenly I heard Katie’s ecstatic laughing from down the hall.
“Mermaid! Mermaid!”
Great, she’d moved on to another fictional creature. I guess it was better than more unicorn talk, but now I’d have to find a mermaid plushie. I walked to her room to find her, but she wasn’t there. Surprised, I followed her voice to the hallway bathroom.
“Mermaid, Mommy!” she said, giggling and clapping. “She mermaid!”
And there, at the bottom of the full oversized bathtub, surrounded by empty pill bottles, was Alex, her open eyes frozen, staring up lifelessly through the crystal clear water.