r/Saxophonics • u/justhereforamomemt • 1h ago
Erik the Flutemaker – Natural Alto or Tenor Sax? Need Advice! 🎷
Hi everyone!
I'm interested in purchasing a bamboo saxophone from Erik the Flutemaker, but I'm having a hard time deciding between the Natural Alto Sax and the Natural Tenor Sax.
I'm a female with medium-sized hands, and I have a background in playing classical piano. I've always wanted to learn jazz, but I've found it challenging on the piano since I'm more used to classical music. I thought learning jazz on a different instrument might be a fun experience, and Erik's bamboo saxophones really caught my attention because they're so unique!
I'm leaning toward the Natural Tenor Sax because I love deep, warm, and relaxing sounds. However, I watched one of Erik's videos where he recommended the alto for people with smaller hands, so now I'm unsure which one to get.
Has anyone here played either of these instruments? I'd especially love to hear from other women with medium-sized hands who have tried the Natural Tenor Sax. Is the finger spacing comfortable? Does it require a lot of breath control compared to the alto?
I'd really appreciate any recommendations or personal experiences before I make my purchase. Thank you!