Just finished my first playthrough. The combat is undeniably fluid, but if I'm being honest, it gets a little repetitive by the end. Aside from that, the story and the overall vibe are fantastic. I'd rate it a solid 8/10.
They absolutely nailed the M-rating. The gore and dismemberment are exactly what you want when you're playing as Logan, and it's great that they didn't pull their punches to do the character justice.
I just wish they had expanded the combo system to be on par with Spider-Man 1 and 2. Still, it’s a great experience that you can easily get 2 or 3 playthroughs out of with NG+. Probably won't be coming back to it for a while, though.
Did Insomniac rely too much on the M-rated gore to carry a shallow combo system? Does Wolverine's combat actually pale in comparison to Spider-Man's, or does a simpler, more brutal brawler style just fit Logan's character better? What did you think?