r/nancydrew • u/fullybookedtx • 4h ago
ALTERNATIVES 🎮 My list of mystery games for Nancy Drew-lovers
| GAME NAME | DESCRIPTION | VOICE ACTING | JUMPSCARES AND CHASE SCENES | PRICE/SALE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detective Grimoire | This point-and-click whodunit takes place in a swamp and features simple puzzles and cartoony art. | Yes | No | $7, on sale for $2. Worth at full price, imo. |
| Tangle Tower | A sequel to Detective Grimoire, this game features a family living in a large mansion on an island, where a locked-door murder occurs. Great cast of kooky characters. There is another sequel called The Mermaid Mask I have yet to play. | Yes | No | $20, currently on sale for $4. Worth at full price, imo, if you enjoyed the first game. See bundle if interested in both. |
| This Bed We Made | You play as a 1950s hotel maid who finds a mystery while snooping through guests’ rooms. A short game at roughly 5 hours. Easy puzzles. Choices matter. Romance options. | Yes | No | $25. Sale recommended, due to shortness of game. |
| Call of the Sea | A 1930s wife looks for her missing husband in this unsettling island mystery. Things take a dark turn about halfway through. Some difficult puzzles. One choice at the end matters. | Yes | A few jumpscares involving images flashing like memories, but not anyone jumping out. No chase scenes. | $20, currently on sale for $5. Worth full price, imo. |
| Frog Detective (series) | A goofy frog does his best at solving light-hearted mysteries in this low-poly[wag?] series. Great silly humor. | No | No | $14 for bundle, currently on sale for $8 |
| Killer Frequency | Play as a small-town radio host assigned to be a police dispatcher for an evening while a legendary serial killer runs amok. This game is very dialogue-heavy. Excellent synthwave soundtrack. Simple puzzles. Choices matter. | Yes | One obvious jumpscare during the prologue wherein a person jumps out. None after, and no chases, just creepy atmosphere. | $25, sale recommended. |
| The Séance at Blake Manor | A point-and-click mystery at a manor in 1890s Ireland. I deeply enjoyed this game, despite the mechanics seeming intimidating. Every time you look at a clue, you lose 1 minute towards solving the case. I learned a lot about Ireland and its folklore. Choices matter. | Yes | A few flashing images like a person appearing in a flash of lightning, with a loud sound. No chase scenes. Spooky music. | $20, well worth it imo. |
| The Darkside Detective | This pixel point-and-click puzzle game features awful (wonderful) humor from a schlubby detective and his dimwitted cop partner as they solve occult mysteries. | No | No | $15 |
| The Silent Age | A side-scroller point-and-click game wherein you time travel between the 1970s and a post-apocalyptic future. Can you save humanity? | Some | No | $10 |
| Unsolved Case (series) | This game requires 2 players, each of you getting half of the clues. Work together to catch a killer (among other mysteries in the sequels). | Yes | No | Free |
| Duck Detective (series) | Play as a down-on-his-luck duck in this short whodunit about stolen salami. Cute art. Simple puzzles. There is also a sequel I have yet to play. | Yes | No | $10, currently on sale for $8 |
| Agent A: A Puzzle in Disguise | A suave spy tracks down the nefarious Agent A in this neo-noir puzzle game. Many puzzles, some difficult. Really enjoyed this. | Some | No | $20, worth it imo. |
| Overboard | It’s the 1930s on a cruise liner, and you’re the one whodunit. Avoid suspicion as you wait for the ship to arrive at port to make your escape. This game is very short and replayable. Choices matter. | No | No | $15, sale recommended |