r/nancydrew • • 4h ago

ALTERNATIVES 🎮 My list of mystery games for Nancy Drew-lovers

53 Upvotes
GAME NAME DESCRIPTION VOICE ACTING JUMPSCARES AND CHASE SCENES PRICE/SALE
Detective Grimoire This point-and-click whodunit takes place in a swamp and features simple puzzles and cartoony art. Yes No $7, on sale for $2. Worth at full price, imo.
Tangle Tower A sequel to Detective Grimoire, this game features a family living in a large mansion on an island, where a locked-door murder occurs. Great cast of kooky characters. There is another sequel called The Mermaid Mask I have yet to play. Yes No $20, currently on sale for $4. Worth at full price, imo, if you enjoyed the first game. See bundle if interested in both.
This Bed We Made You play as a 1950s hotel maid who finds a mystery while snooping through guests’ rooms. A short game at roughly 5 hours. Easy puzzles. Choices matter. Romance options. Yes No $25. Sale recommended, due to shortness of game.
Call of the Sea A 1930s wife looks for her missing husband in this unsettling island mystery. Things take a dark turn about halfway through. Some difficult puzzles. One choice at the end matters. Yes A few jumpscares involving images flashing like memories, but not anyone jumping out. No chase scenes. $20, currently on sale for $5. Worth full price, imo.
Frog Detective (series) A goofy frog does his best at solving light-hearted mysteries in this low-poly[wag?] series. Great silly humor. No No $14 for bundle, currently on sale for $8
Killer Frequency Play as a small-town radio host assigned to be a police dispatcher for an evening while a legendary serial killer runs amok. This game is very dialogue-heavy. Excellent synthwave soundtrack. Simple puzzles. Choices matter. Yes One obvious jumpscare during the prologue wherein a person jumps out. None after, and no chases, just creepy atmosphere. $25, sale recommended.
The Séance at Blake Manor A point-and-click mystery at a manor in 1890s Ireland. I deeply enjoyed this game, despite the mechanics seeming intimidating. Every time you look at a clue, you lose 1 minute towards solving the case. I learned a lot about Ireland and its folklore. Choices matter. Yes A few flashing images like a person appearing in a flash of lightning, with a loud sound. No chase scenes. Spooky music. $20, well worth it imo.
The Darkside Detective This pixel point-and-click puzzle game features awful (wonderful) humor from a schlubby detective and his dimwitted cop partner as they solve occult mysteries. No No $15
The Silent Age A side-scroller point-and-click game wherein you time travel between the 1970s and a post-apocalyptic future. Can you save humanity? Some No $10
Unsolved Case (series) This game requires 2 players, each of you getting half of the clues. Work together to catch a killer (among other mysteries in the sequels). Yes No Free
Duck Detective (series) Play as a down-on-his-luck duck in this short whodunit about stolen salami. Cute art. Simple puzzles. There is also a sequel I have yet to play. Yes No $10, currently on sale for $8
Agent A: A Puzzle in Disguise A suave spy tracks down the nefarious Agent A in this neo-noir puzzle game. Many puzzles, some difficult. Really enjoyed this. Some No $20, worth it imo.
Overboard It’s the 1930s on a cruise liner, and you’re the one whodunit. Avoid suspicion as you wait for the ship to arrive at port to make your escape. This game is very short and replayable. Choices matter. No No $15, sale recommended

r/nancydrew • • 11h ago

BOOKS 📚 Having new Nancy adventures even after finishing every game

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/nancydrew • • 5h ago

DISCUSSION 💬 Nancy Drew escape room?

17 Upvotes

I’m getting married at the most Nancy drew venue ever. The reception is very lightly based on the night circus, so it’s black and white and has little tents guests can go into. One of the tents we are hoping to have a game/riddle/puzzle element to either enter the tent, or, ideally, a mini escape room once people are in the tent. We love the Nancy drew games and would love for it to feel like a Nancy drew puzzle. Does anyone have any wild ideas for how to pull something like this off?


r/nancydrew • • 1d ago

#14 DANGER BY DESIGN 🇫🇷 You can stay at JJ's house for 99 days

Post image
692 Upvotes

JJ was baking those cookies every morning for over 3 months 😳No wonder there was a mint shortage lol


r/nancydrew • • 53m ago

#22 TRAIL OF THE TWISTER🌪 No Walkthrough Run… fell at the third hurdle 🤧

• Upvotes

Since the Steam sale, I’ve stocked up on games and am trying Master Sleuth runs with no walkthroughs. I’ve played ND games since I was a kid- I miss the feeling of just trying to brute force my way through the games 🤭

Finished WAV and CRY successfully! I am so proud of myself for learning the buzzard puzzle in CRY. It was the bane of my existence before.

However, I finally caved after spending hours on the transmission puzzle in TOT 🫠 I had taken so many notes and gotten soooo close, but there was just one particular gear position I hadn’t considered possible that ended up being a roadblock. I’m disappointed that I didn’t power through, but after genuine hours, I was like this isn’t fun anymore lol

What games are you unable to do without a walkthrough?


r/nancydrew • • 20h ago

DISCUSSION 💬 You ever just jam out to some of the game music? Pop from SAW is a particular favorite

Thumbnail youtu.be
58 Upvotes

r/nancydrew • • 1d ago

RECREATIONS 👥 Sea of darkness in animal crossing new horizons

Thumbnail gallery
314 Upvotes

My little vacationer is Soren of course skiing around making trouble. Downstairs is the inside of the shop. Upstairs is magnus’s cabin with hidden treasure of course.


r/nancydrew • • 1d ago

BOOKS 📚 Next Nancy Drew Book

Post image
58 Upvotes

I finally finished the atrocity that was Magnolia Mansion, and I’ve moved onto this one for Halloween. Hoping it’s better than the last


r/nancydrew • • 1d ago

#20 RANSOM OF THE SEVEN SHIPS 🐒 Invitation to RANt - SPOILERS Requested Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Okay I have come out of a 10 year ND-less stupor and found my collection of games in my parent's basement on a visit - truly bless their hearts bc if roles were reversed I would have donated them long ago! Warmed my heart and was gagged to find my old sticky notes of puzzle solutions and hints in each DVD case, atrocious handwriting and all. Needless to say I am replaying them in my spare time, and with adult eyes, can I just say these games hit different? I am cackling half of the time at the silly situations and dialogue, and don't think they really struck me as funny as a kid who loved Nancy Drew books and a good whodunnit. ANYWHO back to my original reason for coming to this community - I recently opened my Ransom of the Seven Ships case to find one of my disks split from center to edge 😬 it is alas unplayable, but I was interested to replay it bc though I remember nothing generally about it besides it not being my fave, I read somewhere RAN had a black-face character - is this true?? With all of these games, I remember the general themes and plots, but most of them I don't remember the culprits or minutia, which has been fun to rediscover, but GOOD LORD that was jarring to read because I don't remember this game besides it had a parrot, there was lots of digging and sand and translating, and Bess goes missing but we obvi find her...can someone tell me more about what happens in this seemingly problematic children's computer game?


r/nancydrew • • 2d ago

RECREATIONS 👥 Making Nancy Drew good irl

Thumbnail gallery
673 Upvotes

Recognize the games these are from? 👀 full video of the all day stream where we had a blast making this is on my YouTube channel - LibbyLoo :)

*Food not good lol


r/nancydrew • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION 💬 Just want to share an idea and discuss

11 Upvotes

Hey pals and gals. I watching a Vote 4 Holt video, and I got inspired by their Team Ned devotion. I started writing a short story for fun, and it quickly developed into a game idea. Would any of you ever want to see a Ned centered game? I’m curious how any of you would handle a Ned storyline.

My idea: Ned and Nancy are on a date at a museum, and catch up with Joanna (who has moved on from Beech Hill). While the 3 are going through the exhibits, Nancy recollects her time at Beech Hill, and says “but what are the odds of a crime like that happening a second time?”

Well, it happens a second time. A group of thugs lock down the museum so they can steal some artifacts. Nancy snaps into detective mode and enlists Ned and Joanna to help.

The three tag team like in Alibi using their phones to switch between characters to complete tasks, create distractions, and stop the robbery.

At the end, Nancy has a heart to heart with Ned about how much she appreciated his help. She talks about how she hasn’t been the best girlfriend and realized through their teamwork how much he’s there for her. She says she wants to do better by him, and work on making him a priority.

Ned…has the opposite realization. He talks about that he loves helping Nancy, but this was the first time he felt more like a utility than a teammate. Doing tasks, following orders, just made him realize his place in Nancy’s life: a tool. He says he would like some space, and maybe once Nancy figures out how to balance her work and their relationship, they can try again. Maybe being the key word.

The game ends with a heartfelt goodbye, and Nancy stating: I guess my next case is the mystery of finding balance.


r/nancydrew • • 2d ago

#12 SECRET OF THE OLD CLOCK ⏰ I forgot how pushy Nancy is in Secret of the Old Clock

45 Upvotes

She's just deadass like "Hey man, is your bank broke?" and "So how did this old guy die?" like that's normal information for a banker to share with a random ass girl he's never met 🤣.

I don't remember this game at all basically (I think I only played it once or twice) but WOW Nancy really does fit the 1930s books version of Nancy and her nosey ass well!


r/nancydrew • • 2d ago

RANKING 🏆 Numerical Data from Ultimate Nancy Drew Tier Ranking Polls

Thumbnail gallery
56 Upvotes

hello! I wanted to share this in case anyone else might find it interesting. while u/southernfirefly13 has been running their polls ranking the ND games into tiers, I've been inputting the data into a spreadsheet that calculates the average score of each game based on the votes received. each vote for A = 4 points, B = 3, C = 2, D = 1, F = 0. the screenshot of the spreadsheet shows the games in descending order by average score. then I put the games into a tier list and ordered them by score within their tiers. for the S tier on this list, I moved the five highest-scoring games from A tier up into S tier (WAC only lost out to DDI by .01!).

anyway here's some stuff I thought was interesting from the results:

  • Secret of the Scarlet Hand ranked into A tier, but ended up with a lower average score than three of the B tier games
    • this also happened with The Silent Spy (ranked into B tier, scored lower than two C tier games) and OG Secrets Can Kill (ranked into C tier, scored lower than every D tier game lol)
    • OG SCK and Creature of Kapu Cave ended up with the only tied scores (1.61), but CRE technically scored a little bit higher with a 1.608 over SCK's 1.605
  • people were the most passionate about showing up to vote for Warnings at Waverly Academy and The Shattered Medallion (they had the highest and second highest total number of votes), with WAC ending up in A and SHAT ending up in F and yes I know what its real abbreviation is
  • three games got 0 votes for F: Message in a Haunted Mansion, Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake, and Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon
  • only OG SCK got 0 votes for A tier but tbf it did not have its own actual poll, while Midnight in Salem and Mystery of the Seven Keys each only got 1 vote for A
  • the most mid game, depending on how you look at it, is:
    • the Captive Curse, which ended up with the median score of the series
    • or Trail of the Twister, which had the highest total number of votes for C
    • or Danger by Design, which had the highest percentage of votes for C

so yeah! this is how the games stacked up by numbers. I created the spreadsheet and interpreted the data myself and I got a D in statistics in college so sorry for any bogus-looking data :~)

thank you so much u/southernfirefly13 for running these polls, they have been really fun and intriguing to follow and I've really enjoyed watching and participating in the voting the last couple months!!! <3


r/nancydrew • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION 💬 Frank Hardy and Nancy Lore

21 Upvotes

I’m doing a play through of the games, but just doing it in random order based on vibes so I don’t really have a good cohesive timeline. I just played Midnight in Salem, and picked up on a crush dynamic between frank and Nancy - Ned even commenting that Frank was there and seemed jealous. Is this an underlying storyline in the games? A love triangle between Ned, Frank and Nancy? I’ve never noticed it before. so it feels out of left field and curious of opinions.


r/nancydrew • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION 💬 About HeR…

11 Upvotes

While I actually love their posts they have been posting but the fictional detective in me is like what are they up to? There was a show that I watched that had the main character spotting something off with his people that he trusted and so he couldn’t help himself being too nosy 😅

Anyone have this feeling? I totally get privacy and respecting the decisions they may be making and being patient and doing other things but I’m just missing the old days! (I am slowly learning a game engine so who knows what I might make 😄)


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

#18 THE PHANTOM OF VENICE 🎭 Playing Phantom and was caught off guard

Thumbnail gallery
188 Upvotes

Apologies if this was done following the event.. I had no idea she was featured in this game. As a big fan of hers, and recently listening to her audiobook.. this was bittersweet ❤️


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

#11 CURSE OF BLACKMOOR MANOR 🐺 Curse of Blackmoor Manner is entirely too hard

239 Upvotes

Seriously guys, I finished it last night and now I remember why I didn't like this game as a kid. I'm 35 and working on a masters degree and I'm not smart enough for that game, how the hell were kids meant to be smart enough for it???

I cheated my ass off to finish it! It took me like 12 hours of gameplay according to Steam before I gave up and started cheating to finish it.

I feel dumb AF after all that, y'all 😔


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

#16 THE WHITE WOLF OF ICICLE CREEK 🛷 Icicle Creek Lodge dinner

Thumbnail gallery
975 Upvotes

r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

#14 DANGER BY DESIGN 🇫🇷 Weird Background Noises in Danger by Design (SPOILERS) Spoiler

42 Upvotes

So I’m replaying Danger by Design right now and in this most recent stretch of the game, I heard some odd background noises.

I just went into the tunnel you can unlock in the park. And when walking through this tunnel, it’s like you can hear faint moaning in the distance the whole time.

Then it was dark by the time I left the park, so I automatically went back to JJ’s to sleep.

This is the REALLY WEIRD moment. Nancy walks out into the kitchen in the morning and I swear I heard what sounded like a person being attacked. Like they were screaming outside repeatedly until the screaming turned into a cry and finally what kind of sounded like laughter at the end.

I know this is a sound bite from when Minette throws her first tantrum and you hear her through the door. But THIS didn’t sound like Minette. It also wasn’t the same exact order as she goes in during that part of the game.

Has anyone else heard these or am I going crazy? 😂


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

#22 TRAIL OF THE TWISTER🌪 Has anyone ever seen this observation?

Post image
233 Upvotes

I'm playing Trail of the Twister and I noticed this observation, so I fact checked it and its true! I love learning random facts from Nancy Drew 😂


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

ALTERNATIVES 🎮 New Upcoming Nancy Drew Inspired Game Demo Out Now!!

Post image
147 Upvotes

Hi guys!! I'm the creator behind Co-Ed Casualty: A Chandler Chase Case (a Nancy Drew inspired game) and wanted to let you guys know my game's demo is available on Steam now! Any feedback, bug reports, etc etc etc would be AMAZING! Would also love any suggestions or tips:) this current build runs on Windows only!! Working on a Mac build soon!!

Please leave feedback and bugs here

Follow along with development:

Instagram

Youtube

Reddit

Dev-Logs


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

TECH HELP ⌨️ Playing old games

10 Upvotes

Hello! I recently purchased a large quantity of the games off facebook marketplace and am so excited to play them all! My husband and I like to work on them together. We noticed that we had a hard time downloading the older ones like #1 and #2 etc. We moved up to Blackmoor manor and that one works, but is there a way to still run the older games? We just use an external hard drive hooked up to our normal laptops. TIA!


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

RANKING 🏆 The Ultimate Nancy Drew Games - FINAL TIER RANKINGS Spoiler

Post image
47 Upvotes

Hey Clue Crew!

No "gotcha!" moment this time!

Over a period of three and a half months, you guys have been voting to decide how YOU, as a collective, would rank all the Nancy Drew games, including a bonus round to rank the top 5 S-Tier games! Voting ending last night before midnight, and now the results are final!

From left to right are the Top 5 S-Tier games, out of 167 ranked choice responses....

1st: The Secret of Shadow Ranch - This game was the clear winner by the end of the very first day of S tier voting. This game received the most votes for first place, being neck and neck at one point with Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon.

2nd: Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon - There was a point this game was neck and neck with Shadow Ranch, but alas, it only received half the first place votes and received more votes for second place.

3rd: Danger on Deception Island - Third place came very close to going to another game: Treasure in the Royal Tower. Deception Island beat it out by six votes.

4th: Warnings at Waverly Academy - 4th place's only competition was Danger on Deception Island, but as that game received more votes for third place. Curse of Blackmoor Manor came close to taking this spot, too, but trailed by a few votes.

5th: Legend of the Crystal Skull - Up until yesterday, Sea of Darkness was leading for 5th.

Thoughts?


r/nancydrew • • 3d ago

ALTERNATIVES 🎮 Do you prefer playing on console? Alex Hill: Whispers at White Oak Inn will be coming to PlayStation and Xbox soon!

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/nancydrew • • 4d ago

#24 THE CAPTIVE CURSE 🇩🇪 Thrift store find

Post image
135 Upvotes

Pretty stoked I was able to find this today for $2.50