We go down to Disneyland 2–3 times a year, and this was our first trip to the parks since the Frontierland pin trading changes.
We originally started pin trading as a way to keep our son occupied and give him something to do while resting, allowing our older girls to go on rides.
After the 70th key release he decided he wanted to go down the D collecting route (We had previously picked up Mickey & Tiki in 2019 and Pirate Mickey in 2021).
Over three days, my son found 15 D’s on boards, lanyards, and through trivia. He could have found 20+ if he hadn’t been encouraging kids in front of him to grab D’s for traders on the kids’ boards. He only took 3 from kids’ boards / kids’ trading boxes (Timothie, Louisa, and Lucky) as they didn’t have the board due to rain on Sunday.
Highlighted in yellow on the photo: What he found
Highlighted in green on the photo : What he traded for using other D’s he found
His finds:
* (2) Marie
* (3) Lucky
* (1) Hades
* (2) Belle
* (1) Tweedle
* (2) Louisa
* (1) Simba
* (1) Koda
* (1) Jacques
* (1) Timothie
Some of the trades he made:
* Found Tweedle → traded for Gus
* Found Hades → traded for a Toon Town D
* Found Lucky + Louisa → traded for a Jungle Cruise D
* Found Koda (with additional bundled pins) → traded for Wendy + an additional pin
He also started collecting the headbands. I had purchased a bundle of 2026 wave A traders on Facebook to use as traders, but he ended up wanting to collect the entire set.
Pink = what he traded for with other guests.
* Belle D → Steamboat Willie headband
* Lucky + Louisa D’s → Aurora headband (not pictured)
Green = what he found on boards/ trivia.
I also had my 11-year-old niece with us, and she decided to start collecting, too. She started with 10 traders and left with 10 authentic Haunted Mansion/Nightmare pins she traded for.
For me, the best part of this experience wasn’t the pins themselves. It was the interactions.
The organic nature of seeing someone with a pinfolio or lanyard, approaching them, starting a conversation, and asking to trade was such a great experience for my 12-year-old. Those are genuine social interactions that might not have happened otherwise.
We’ve also tried to teach the kids that trading isn’t about winning every transaction or getting the most valuable pin. It’s about helping people build their collections and finding things that make them happy.
They gave away 10+ pins to people who were just starting their collections and didn’t have traders my kids were interested in. We want them to understand that if they find something they absolutely love on a board or through trivia for their personal collection, they should leave something behind that someone else will enjoy just as much. Only to leave authentic pins that others will love.
The change to Frontierland trading ended up creating some incredible interactions for our family that we wouldn’t have had otherwise. From that perspective, we really enjoyed the experience and appreciated what it gave the kids.
That said, I still 100% agree that Disney selling hundreds of thousands of dollars’ worth of pins every day while limiting opportunities to trade them is baffling.
My son wasn’t able to add many new pirate pins to his collection because of the lack of large binders. Trading is a huge part of the hobby, and I wish Disney would find a better balance between its new system and the collecting community.
P.S.
If anyone wants to know the future dates for the hidden Disney releases, apparently you just need to look at our travel calendar. Wave A and Wave B both followed the same pattern this year. My prediction? The next release will be the Tuesday after we fly home from our trip.