r/Borderlands4 • u/IfTheresANewWay • 6h ago
π [ Voting Poll ] The State of The Ultimate Vault Hunter Poll
Hello, y'all. I'm back. You may recall a few weeks ago were doing a poll to determine the best and worst Vault Hunters in the series and made it up through nearly top 10. And then... they stopped. What happened?
I got perma banned from the sub without warning or reason. I didn't think I broke any rules but I never heard back from the Mod team what happened. Eventually, some folks started reaching out to me to ask what happened, and even messaged the mods as well and made some posts here, which I greatly appreciate. I did eventually hear back that I was banned for Spamming which auto-mod assumed meant I was a bot so I had everything restricted.
So now that I'm back, will the polls continue? No.
The mods asked that the polls do not resume, and so we have to fill in the pieces of what's left. Before we do that, a question a lot of people had was "what are we even voting on?" I left that intentionally vague cause I wanted people to vote for what they deemed most important. If you felt a characters gameplay was paramount above all, I wanted you to vote for that, same as if you thought it was their personality, story, looks, or everything combined. In the end, the thing that ended up matter most to people was gameplay, but also story and personality. Those with more interesting skills, a greater impact on the lore, and cool voice lines ultimately lasted longer than those without. And to that end, the results for the polls was as follows:
Wilhelm. Many people found playing as a level 16 boss uninteresting and he was largely voted out first for his character.
Roland. Though Roland was one of the more important characters in the series, many people felt he had the single lamest ability and skill tree in the entire series
Axton. The solider class continues to prove unpopular as many people didn't care for his turrets, and found him the least interesting BL2 Vault Hunter in terms of personality
Aureila. Largely due to people not liking her character, nor one of her trees being largely worthless in single player.
Brick. After the soldier class, another thing that proved unpopular was melee characters, with Brick having the least interesting gameplay of that group. This one was extremely controversial as many people love Brick as a character
Claptrap. The randomness of his ability is what put off most people here, plus the fact that he's Claptrap
Gaige. Her ability proved too inconsistent for many players, with a lot of people noting it was frustrating to play as her at times
Nisha. Not really much to say here other than people not liking that she killed Brick's dog. This was sort of the turning point for people when the polls started to become a lot more difficult
Salvador. Lots of players noted he made the game feel too easy, and that his ability wasn't anything super creative or unique.
Mordecai. Another BL1 Vault Hunter falls mainly due to his ability not holding up as well as those who came after him
Lilith. The last BL1 Vault Hunter standing, mainly due to her character and impact on the story. Many people agreed she was the most fun character in BL1
Amon. Another melee focused character falls, though many voters felt people only remember back when he wasn't very good rather than how he is currently
Harlowe. Really not much to say here, just the weakest of the remaining options
Athena. Same as Harlowe though ranked higher due to her character and impact on the story
Amara. People found her the least likeable of the BL3 bunch but that was basically it.
And that's where we left off. As for who would've taken spot number 11, it seems like Rafa and Loveless were up next. The former people felt was the most generic of the BL4 bunch and latter people also found bland as a character.
So who would've won? This is purely theory at this point but based on the votes and comments, this is how I *think* the polls would've gone: Rafa would've been 11, then Loveless 10. Number 9 likely would've been Moze to eliminate the last of the soldiers, Number 8 for Jack purely cause people don't seem to care much for the Pre-Sequel bunch, Number 7 I think would've been C4sh as some people were let down by his personality but still enjoyed him as a character. Numbers 6, 5, and 4 would be between Maya, Zer0 and Vex and are too close for me to call between. 3 would've been Krieg as many people love him as a character and his story and likely only would've been held back by his melee focused gameplay
And the finals would've likely been Zane vs Fl4k. Ultimately, I think Zane would've won. He consistently got very few votes and I don't think I ever saw a single comment for him. I think Fl4k's abilities would've ultimately fallen below Zane for a second place finish overall
So ultimately, this is what I *think* would've happened. Thank you to everyone who participated and put your rankings below
Zane
Fl4k
Krieg
Zer0
Maya
Vex
C4sh
Jack
Moze
Loveless
Rafa
Amara (polls stopped here)
Athena
Harlowe
Amon
Lilith
Mordecai
Salvador
Nisha
Gaige
Claptrap
Brick
Aureila
Axton
Roland
Wilhelm
