r/AskBaking • u/PinObvious5176 • 18h ago
Cakes/Cheesecakes Virgin Pina Colada Cake ideas
Hi! I would appreciate some advice or tips about a pina colada I'm planning on making for my boyfriend's birthday.
It's difficult to get my hands on certain ingredients where I live, which is why I'm leaving out the rum in the cake, can't use whipped cream/cream cheese. Working with quite a bit of constraints lol. It also doesn't help that I've never actually have a pina colada or a pineapple cake.
My plan is to make a vanilla chiffon cake and soak it with coconut milk/cream instead of a sugar syrup. I will he making pineapple jam/filling from fresh pineapples and using them in between the layers, along with ermine buttercream. That's about it. Generally I make a variation of this with but with strawberries and it turns out great! Unfortunately strawberries aren't in season right now and would be quite expensive to get.
Do you think the coconut flavour won't be strong/noticeable enough? Or the texture of the overall cake might be off? Should I just pivot to a basic chocolate cake instead or try some other cake filling? Thank you for the help!
Edit: his birthday is on Halloween if that helps with suggesting anything lol