r/whenthe • • Apr 15 '26

the daily whenthe "It's cheating!!!"

15.8k Upvotes

482 comments sorted by

View all comments

163

u/Strant2 Apr 15 '26

Best argument against people who hate on keep inventory is a question what do they do with the world after dying

55

u/SadDairyProduct Apr 15 '26

You get your stuff back? Or if it burned you rebuild

55

u/Strant2 Apr 15 '26

Most people just delete the whole world

42

u/WHYISEVERYTHINGTAKNN Apr 15 '26

which is funny because it would take way longer to come back lmao. especially if you have a base with supplies to recraft tools and armor.

7

u/Milor214 I've trapped some poor soul in this text box, say hi Paco ‼️🆘️🙏 Apr 15 '26

it's true but for many people they get a renewed sense of progression and may try different things or change where they would build a base in a new world, instead of grinding for the sake of getting back where you were, even if it could be thinked as doing the same thing

1

u/Skiller_Overyou Apr 15 '26

Early/Mid game is usually the most fun imo, so starting anew and maybe doing some things differnt from the last time is also a way to have fun.

1

u/ReggieCorneus Apr 15 '26

Early game is full of rewards and progression. It takes longer but is more fun.

14

u/ookmedookers Apr 15 '26

People delete their world after dying one time? Is that not just hard-core which doesnt matter for keep inventory?

1

u/ReggieCorneus Apr 15 '26

If you have spent a week grinding and getting into all kinds of danger, finally get the full kit and then.. die... Grinding it back has has no reward, you are not getting anything better but you are now grinding to get back to a point where you can start doing what you wanted to do in the first place.

Starting over has tons of rewards and you feel the progression. It is more fun to grind a week to get that full set again than to grind a day to get back where you were before grinding started..

You also start to dislike the world itself, your starter base looked awful, you made mistakes while building it that haunt you still, you know often more so you could do it better.. so you do that rather than just grind gear back.

2

u/seriouslees Apr 15 '26

This outlook needs to be studied my mental health experts.

1

u/ReggieCorneus Apr 15 '26

Why? And i think that is all very basic stuff, exists in your and me.

24

u/Piyaniist Apr 15 '26

Who the fuck is "most people"?

20

u/Makine7 Apr 15 '26

Ain’t that just hardcore then ?

1

u/ReggieCorneus Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 15 '26

Nah, you grind iron gear back fast, even if you had some diamond tools it not that big of a loss but once you lose full kit, all of the enchantments you worked so hard for, that is when starting a new world becomes more fun... when you got to grind to get back to where you were there is no real sense of accomplishments in it, it is just a grind without a reward. But early game.... "you got a new recipe" every few minutes...

HC punishes you in the beginning too, when you are most likely to die... you lose the world and don't have an option to start again. Even in the early game you usually have some random resources, there is the old kit in the chest somewhere, you got food, fuel, wood, stone, maybe even few iron ingots...

18

u/AwfulUsername123 Apr 15 '26

Yeah, that's not true.

10

u/Glittering_Seat9677 Apr 15 '26

most people go on reddit and say shit that isn't true

25

u/SadDairyProduct Apr 15 '26

What a boring way to play. But to each their own

7

u/baprapcat Pizza stealin rat Apr 15 '26

"what a boring way to play"

meanwhile me using keep inventory so I don't have to grind for hours all over again just to get my diamond armour/enchants back or spend an ungodly amount of time just walking to get out of a cave or to get back from a long expedition

besides most the time I get back to my stuff without it on its despawned or there's like 5 skeletons camping it because having mobs spawn constantly as long as its dark is good game design

I would rather not waste time backtracking/grinding to get stuff back when I could be building, progressing, farming, fishing ect

26

u/SadDairyProduct Apr 15 '26

I said to each their own, I find the grind fun. Gives me something to do.

I don't play Minecraft alone, I usually play when listening to an audiobook, so the grind is good

3

u/baprapcat Pizza stealin rat Apr 15 '26

fair

0

u/TheForbidden6th yellow like an EPIC lemon Apr 15 '26

What a boring way to play

constant grind isn't any more fun btw

2

u/No_Bedroom4062 Apr 15 '26

If you do that you have some weird problems

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '26

You're confusing KI Off with Hardcore

1

u/VinylDjPon3 Apr 15 '26

I highly doubt that. 

Early game you aren't dying far enough away from your respawn, you can just go get the stuff back.

Late game 'rebuilding' takes an hour unless it was netherite gear.

-36

u/GMFafr Apr 15 '26

Let's not count most people for they are casuals

27

u/Glad_Pangolin_1976 Apr 15 '26

"let's ignore the majority of people" yea that always works out great