r/weddingshaming • • 16d ago

Tacky The ugliest fake wedding cake I’ve ever seen

1.3k Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

882

u/412_15101 16d ago

It reminds me of the cake. The three fairies made in sleeping beauty if it was just in white kind of lopsideed & a little tipsy Turvey layers everywhere.

68

u/Apart-Wrangler6917 12d ago

That was my dream to eat that cake as a kid! My mom would tell me if I slept like Sleeping Beauty, maybe a fairy godmother would bring it to me. Her a$$ lied.

35

u/nerdKween 16d ago

I also thought this

90

u/pinkdoodle_ 16d ago

It really has that messy fairy tale charm like the Three Fairies were decorating it together and just kept adding crooked layers until they finally called it done

19

u/PalmtopPixie 16d ago

Thank you! I was trying to remind myself what this made me think of and liked it lol

29

u/Strange_Explorer_780 15d ago

10

u/Beneficial-Produce56 14d ago

This! First thing I thought of. Perfect for a mummy wedding.

673

u/Taleke 16d ago

I really like the idea, but the execution is a bit.. sloppy? It looks untidy some how

300

u/wewakeful 16d ago

It's all the end bits of fondant ribbon cut so bluntly and just pressed on. A little bit more care and pizzaz and it would have been much prettier I think.

240

u/Nightmare_Gerbil 16d ago

That’s not fondant. That’s fondon’t.

56

u/FunnyC0comelon 16d ago

u/Nightmare_Gerbil I died at "fondon't" 😂 That thing looks like it was iced with drywall spackle and bad decisions.

12

u/Top_Environment9937 14d ago

I’m sure there was alcohol involved. Lol.

32

u/OreoStark 16d ago

Just use clay???? Like it’s a fake cake, why are you making it out of fondant? Just cover some styrofoam with clay.

16

u/lionhearted_sparrow 15d ago

I know my sister made one for a class assignment  while getting a culinary degree! So the point is knowing how to make and interact with with actual mediums (fondant, icing, chocolates, etc)

Still silly to put it on styrofoam but I do understand wanting to have one intact consistent base for everyone 

8

u/OreoStark 15d ago edited 15d ago

I mean, that feels like something you don’t sell. Especially if it turns out like this C+. Edit: I looked at the later pictures and would like to amend my grade to a C- at best.

7

u/lionhearted_sparrow 15d ago

I mean yeah sure it’s definitely something you don’t buy

But I’m pretty sure the dumpster is their only other option, so, meh? The only thing they have to lose is a couple minutes to post it… and their dignity when it gets circulated around social media being roasted. 

10

u/doesanyonekno 16d ago

Exactly this, it'd be so much cleaner if more care went into placing and hiding those blunt edges!!

2

u/riflow 15d ago

Yeah normally they cover those cut ends up right? I Def think I've seen it as a trick on a baking yt channel before at least.

31

u/LittlestEcho 16d ago

It reminds me of a wedding dress with a lot of pleats that's slowly been worn out after an entire night of partying. Lol

29

u/CampClear 16d ago

It looks like a pile of white laundry.

5

u/triciann 16d ago

It’s kind of Dr. Seuss-ish.

3

u/Traditional_Set_858 15d ago

It sort of reminds me of auroras cake in sleeping beauty

164

u/Suspicious-turnip-77 16d ago

I get the vision. I imagine this is what they are going for….

23

u/Aggravating-Day2370 16d ago

It's like those Pinterest pictures you see where someone tried to make a cake they'd seen on Pinterest but it came out...interesting

8

u/Rocket_Panda_ 11d ago

Pinteresting? 👀

3

u/Aggravating-Day2370 10d ago

Darn it, I missed a really good opportunity there. Well done you!

3

u/Rocket_Panda_ 9d ago

Hahah thanks!

418

u/amyfigures 16d ago

Honestly not mad at the design for a fake cake. Could use colour

187

u/trolldoll26 16d ago

I can absolutely see the vision but the execution didn’t align

20

u/twistedspin 16d ago

Right, this is like half of one of those "inspiration vs reality" posts, on the reality side.

40

u/lifegoeson5322 16d ago

It looks like it's melting.

17

u/Relative-Accountant2 16d ago

Fake flowers ftw!

1

u/Walk_the_forest 12d ago

So I’m not judging, just not familiar and curious: what’s the purpose of a fake wedding cake? 

2

u/amyfigures 12d ago

Some people do it for photos and for decor in the background. Wedding cakes that size are very expensive

90

u/MeltedChocolateOk 16d ago

That at least looks better than this.

30

u/Sunshine030209 15d ago

That looks like it's made out of play-doh 😂

14

u/Original-Metal-1921 16d ago

Okay wait but how? I'm such a terrible baker but I've managed layered cakes... They'll go off kilter but this... It's just.. A blob. Did it melt somehow?! 

1

u/Rocket_Panda_ 11d ago

Best guess it’s a science assignment for vulcano that somehow merged with wedding planning.

82

u/AppointmentMountain8 16d ago

Many (not all) cakes at weddings aren't real. This is why you never see them cut the entire thing. The top is usually real. Usually they have a display for the awwwww factor. I was at a wedding with a 10 tier cake. Once the couple cut the bottom staff took it to the back and in less than ten seconds staff came out with cake slices.... I was like what kinda ninja cutting..... then someone told me. Color me uninformed 😂😆😂

46

u/katieh809 15d ago

Most cakes are real. It’s the ones where either they’re so elaborate and the design would collapse the cake, occasionally budget is a concern (although fake tiers cost the same or more than real cake) or like you said- the size is FAR greater than the number of people. In that case some of the cake is real, usually for the number of ppl there and the rest is styrofoam or there are sheet cakes in the back plus the top anniversary tier. The piece you see cut is literally a chunk cut out of the Styrofoam and a real slice inserted. It’s marked somehow (flower or other decoration) so they know where to cut.
I know this as I was a pastry chef for 20 yrs in Chicago for high end cakes. High end like a $20,000 order. That one was fake. Here I am with it standing on a table minus the top tiers! I’m 5’7” for reference.

4

u/USAF_Retired2017 14d ago

That behemoth was or wasn’t real? Because Jesus that cake is huge.

1

u/AppointmentMountain8 15d ago

Oh my. Thay is huge!!

16

u/Used_Evidence 16d ago

I kinda get the idea, but it's too droopy. Almost like it's melting. My eyes don't know where to look

63

u/Layla_Wilson11894 16d ago

Why would anyone need a fake wedding cake, I’m confused

62

u/Frillback 16d ago

These are common for photo ops since real tiered cakes are expensive. A few have a slot for a real piece of cake if you want to simulate.

12

u/KathrynTheGreat 16d ago

Some also have a real top tier for the couple to save. I think my sister and her husband's wedding cake had a real bottom tier and too tier, and a fake middle tier. Then they had a sheet cake. But that was also 25 years ago and I was a young teen so I don't fully remember lol. I do know they saved the top at least.

2

u/hcfort11 14d ago

Most bakeries will make a new cake top for your anniversary, because frozen cake sucks after a year. They don’t expect you to save it anymore.

22

u/Suspicious-turnip-77 16d ago

Cost. You get the pretty wedding cake for photos (well not so pretty in this case) and serve the guests cheaper slab cake.

3

u/crazypurple621 12d ago

Also a real 3 tier cake serves 75-100 people. So if you have fewer people than that you're going to have a ton of wasted cake. A fake cake display+ sheet cake gives you exactly the number of slices you actually need to serve. 

28

u/Sea-Librarian-275 16d ago

We did. I have some pretty severe food allergies and it would have cost a ridiculous amount for a professional cake. My mom and I made the fake cake itself and she made the top layer (lemon verbena pound cake with raspberries and lemon curd frosting) for the cake cutting. We had an enormous dessert bar instead.

43

u/Sea-Librarian-275 16d ago

The cake topper was from my parents’ wedding.

12

u/Hita-san-chan 16d ago

Omg its gorgeous!! I love the purple .゚+.(・∀・)゚+.゚

3

u/Layla_Wilson11894 16d ago

Yes that does make total sense

2

u/Available-Face5653 15d ago

so they can eventually end up in a landfill.

1

u/fakemoose 16d ago

Yea I’m curious what the context for this is.

12

u/kitty-yaya 16d ago

Maybe it's for mummies.
https://giphy.com/gifs/uFmBZOtRinLlPey3Ta
a mummy wedding

66

u/AcheyShakySpoon 16d ago

I can’t explain exactly why, but it feels…vaginal

32

u/pluto222moon 16d ago

all the folds probably lol

19

u/AcheyShakySpoon 16d ago

The big flower is just a clitoris in a wreath

8

u/AmenaBellafina 16d ago

To me the top without the drapery makes it look more phallic, lol. It's a cake with a foreskin.

7

u/AcheyShakySpoon 16d ago

If you had to pick, would you rather have a dick wedding cake or a vagina wedding cake?

10

u/alleecmo 16d ago

Por que no los dos? It is a wedding after all. Two become one and all that jazz.

7

u/MartinisnMurder 16d ago

I say vaginal because there would be more texture with the folds. The dick would be boring, your cake could end up looking like Peppa Pig’s dad. The first time I saw that cartoon at my friend’s house I was like are their talking dicks on your kid’s cartoon?! No one can tell me that wasn’t done on purpose.

4

u/Junior-Fox-760 15d ago

Depends on if the dick wedding cake has cream filling.

I'll show myself out

1

u/Available-Face5653 15d ago

a penis wedding cake is the proper term.

1

u/Longjumping-Solid680 15d ago

Definitely wrong for a Jewish wedding.

4

u/CrunchyFrogWithBones 16d ago

The middle part of the big flower is giving cervix.

9

u/Electrical-Alarm2931 16d ago

I have seen wedding dresses that look like this

6

u/NewHampshireGal 16d ago

Looks like a mummy to me lol

6

u/MartinisnMurder 16d ago

Right in time for Halloween season, maybe it’s a themed wedding? 😅

1

u/blurblurblahblah 15d ago

Looks like laundry day with my duvet & sheets in a pile at the bottom of the bed

7

u/SilverHour6277 16d ago

It looks like the sorting hat from Harry Potter

1

u/TheDeterminedBadger 16d ago

My thoughts exactly!

6

u/Acceptable-Target97 16d ago

How many times has this been used? It looks like it fell off the table….. a few times.

8

u/ImACarebear1986 15d ago

Why would you have a fake wedding cake at your wedding? So you don’t have to share cake or buy it?? 

Read a post elsewhere yesterday of an awful wedding someone went to that had barely any food for over 200 people (I think), and when they brought the cake out, it was a very small sheet cake which the couple cut a tiny square of for photos and people to watch and as soon as they did, the cake was wheeled away behind the scenes.. 🤦‍♀️ 

6

u/hcfort11 14d ago

It’s fairly common to have a styrofoam cake with one real tier for cutting pictures and sheet cake cut behind the scenes for guests.

10

u/RBFsaysitall 16d ago

Im getting Little Mermaid vibes....when Ariel washed up on the beach and draped herself in the rag she found on the shore lmao.

Perhaps its a Disney theme?

Or penis/vag work too

5

u/KathrynTheGreat 16d ago

I love that your two options are Disney and genitals 😂

19

u/give_me_goats 16d ago

It looks like a bunch of kids TP’d a cake instead of a house

4

u/Humble-Pineapple-329 16d ago

It’s melting.

3

u/Excellent_Kiwi7789 16d ago

It looks like what Ariel wrapped herself in when she first became human.

4

u/Amegami 16d ago

Looks like a stack of dirty towels.

5

u/OkCryptographer1922 16d ago

I see the vision, it has potential to look like a Greek goddess but it didn’t get executed very well

3

u/Junior-Fox-760 15d ago

Looks like Miss Havisham's cake that sat for 20 years untouched.

4

u/AmazingSupermarket33 12d ago

It's almost like the sorting hat got dressed up for a wedding.

4

u/kikimdmistake 12d ago

Actually, it has a wicked charm to it. It would take a very special bride to carry this off!

3

u/larapu2000 16d ago

It looks like it's pulling up its pants somehow.

3

u/Sufficient_Energy_32 16d ago

A bleached roast beef sandwich

3

u/Bleu_Cerise 16d ago

It’s like the Sorting Hat is getting married

3

u/AliceTawhai 16d ago

Done in icing by a pro that could have been really cool

3

u/JoyfulandHappy1965 15d ago

I kinda like it.

3

u/CheezwizOfficial 15d ago

I mean... I can see why it's "faux"

3

u/Available-Face5653 15d ago

are those dusty old things still around?

3

u/MelonBoba59 15d ago

This is why we need r/fondanthate

3

u/Tiny_Ebb_3615 11d ago

What's the point? More plastic?

3

u/gemgirlshari 11d ago

The biggest joke ia the original price!

3

u/BurgerThyme 11d ago

That cake looks like it might have shit stains on it.

3

u/Evening_Delay_1856 11d ago

That’s really bad!!! 😆

5

u/OK_LK 16d ago

Faux

Just say Fake, Margot. It's a fake, melting mess of a cake

3

u/Aggravating-Day2370 16d ago

My ex mother in law once gave me a faux fur blanket and called it fox fur blanket! Still laugh about that one

2

u/LolaBee33 16d ago

Ooooo now I can’t unsee it

2

u/nik_el 16d ago

Is anyone else seeing a munmy?

2

u/rose442 16d ago

It’s just a little TOO disordered.

2

u/APEmerson 15d ago

I think this looks like some dresses I have seen. Maybe they were supposed to match.

2

u/Historical_Cook3366 15d ago

Upcoming of some old bras?

2

u/West-Application-375 11d ago

It would look better to cover some stacked boxes with ribbons lol

2

u/No_Lingonberry6785 7d ago

It looks like the Harry potter sorting hat

5

u/Practical-March-6989 16d ago

A mate of mine of her second go round decided to do a cheeseboard instead of cake. Stacked up on various boards, it looked great and was appreciated by the maturer crowd.

I dont see the point of a false cake, unless for like a film or something?

7

u/blumoon444 16d ago

It's intended to save money. Fake cake for photos, serve the sheet cake that's already been cut up back in the kitchen.

Some fake cakes have a spot in the bottom tier you can still cut with a piece of real cake slotted in.

3

u/Crepesuz-zq 16d ago

Thank you - I was similarly confused by all of this

5

u/shrimptetra 16d ago

more for show and tradition. ‘Everyone else had a beautiful tiered wedding cake so i need one too. but thats really expensive so im gonna order a fake one (maybe it has one real slice in it for a photo op of the couple eating from it) and then hand out sheet cake to everyone else to save money.’

5

u/KissyChristmas 16d ago

The drapping is really cool in my opinion. Makes it look like the bottom of a dress

3

u/koifu 16d ago

I got dress vibes too.

3

u/CyberClawX 15d ago

I agree. Looks like a wedding dress, that's what they were going for.

3

u/AnastasiaNo70 16d ago

For when you just really don’t care enough to try…

3

u/RHND2020 16d ago

But why does it exist?

3

u/Used_Evidence 16d ago

Save money. Get pictures with the "pretty" cake while you save money by serving sheet cake

2

u/RHND2020 16d ago

Ah. I didn’t know that was a thing.

2

u/Flat-Nectarine-1957 15d ago

Reminds me of the Sorting Hat in Harry Potter

1

u/Weekly_Cobbler_6908 16d ago

It looks like a torso, is it supposed to?

1

u/VivianDiane 16d ago

What made it so bad?

1

u/Jerry-Goosey 16d ago

It’s gloopy.

1

u/OkNews8776 15d ago

Looks like a mummy

1

u/generallyintoit 15d ago

the styrofoam base still has some value but.. not that value.

1

u/susanna514 15d ago

This is the only fake wedding cake I’ve ever seen, so it’s both the best and the worst.

1

u/cookieprincess0 15d ago

I want to know the story behind this picture. Sooooo many questions.

Was this the day after the wedding? Was the cake caught in a storm?

But most important did THIS CAKE actually make an appearance at a wedding? In this condition?

1

u/Si_Es_Contigo_Mejor 15d ago

It looks like I want to tug it's skirt up because it's falling off. That, and it's missing the topper.

1

u/racoongirl0 15d ago

The idea is actually pretty. It’s the execution that made it this way

1

u/Which-Appearance9857 15d ago

I don't see it as bad. Is fine.

1

u/fearthainne 15d ago

I understand what they're going for but this looks like I made it. 😬

1

u/TemperatureHot8915 14d ago

I think it's inspired by the wedding dress

1

u/Floxesoffoxes 13d ago

It could be really nice but it's just off slightly. I think the top tier not being done makes it look like the fondant is slipping off.

1

u/LocalMossCryptid 13d ago

I've never seen an uncircumcised wedding cake before

1

u/adoginthewindow 13d ago

It looks like rawhides 😭

1

u/lightyana 13d ago

Put two eyes on top and it’s a mummy cake for Halloween

1

u/Annonomouse1234567 13d ago

Proof of how hard this style is to do well.

1

u/Affectionate-Face432 13d ago

I'm kinda into it. Like a frank Gehry wedding cake.

1

u/beingleigh 13d ago

I mean, I don’t love most wedding cakes anyway - I’ve never really understood the tradition of a giant super expensive cake. But this isn’t the worst thing I’ve seen. I’m more shocked that people would get a fake cake in the first place. Why not just not do a cake? So odd.

1

u/Asleep_One4584 12d ago

I love it except for the top. It’s so campy

1

u/Sakeandme 12d ago

Maybe it’s mummy themed for a Halloween wedding I HOPE

1

u/Chance_Fate66 12d ago

I guess that’s protection against the drunk party goer who smashes into the table and knocks the cake over

1

u/visceralthrill 12d ago

Oof, it looks like it's been used and being resold. Dry but also overly heavy that some places are stretched with holes. Just so very sad. The first wedding cake I ever made looked better than this.

1

u/Citroen_05 12d ago

My sister had a fake cake far less attractive than this one.

Her friends shared decor incl fake bouquets, and had church basement potluck receptions, so I guess the styrofoam cake was practical.

1

u/Good_Reward2734 12d ago

O boy 😳, honestly, my daughter made a similar cake in school, and it looked 300% better...

1

u/Sorry_Pin5021 11d ago

It’s interesting

1

u/Pantles 6d ago

This might look good when it’s finished! 😂

1

u/grenouille_en_rose 16d ago

I would be so incredibly proud if I'd made this. Less sure if it meets the standard of expect from a professional cake costing hundreds or thousands (I have no idea how much a wedding cake costs)

1

u/sysaphiswaits 16d ago

I kind of like it, but not for a wedding.

1

u/PukeyOwlPellet 16d ago

I like what they were going for but they just missed the mark, oh dear!

0

u/OK_LK 16d ago

Faux

Just say Fake, Margot. It's a fake, melting mess of a cake

1

u/Ok-Ad3906 9h ago

It's like a gown alteration gone wrong...