r/warthundermemes • • 1d ago

Evolution of SPAA effectiveness against tanks

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

522

u/Flat-Cap-1063 1d ago

Flakpanzer 1 is a legit threat at rank I

175

u/12lubushby 1d ago

I have heard a few players say its mag size makes it the best rank 1 in the game

35

u/topfragger70 1d ago

Panzer II

50

u/12lubushby 1d ago

The improved turret speed (very important when fighting fast light tanks at this br) and 20 rounds vs 10 makes this better then the panzer 2 in most of the ways that count. The armour makes very little difference as its so unreliable.

The only real benefits of the pz ii is the extra man and slightly better pen.

I love pz ii and think its good but honestly think flak pz i is better

16

u/ProtoBacon82 1d ago

If you sit on a cap with the pz ii it will refill the mag before it is empty and you can fire forever lol

2

u/12lubushby 1d ago

Is that a bug because I only discovered it a few days ago and had a great time

6

u/Tool_of_Society 1d ago

Been like that for as long as I can remember.

When I'm playing low ranks it's usually under the influence and I'm there to do dumb/funny stuff. I find amusement in infinite ammo and shooting everywhere..

2

u/ProtoBacon82 20h ago

It’s not a bug, it’s just that the ammo reload on the cap is faster than the pz ii can empty a clip

18

u/BingusTheStupid 1d ago

One thing the Pz.2 has going for it is that the gun never overheats, so if you’re on a cap you can actually just fire forever.

5

u/Oberst_Stockwerk 1d ago

What slightly better pen? The KwK and Flak habe identical performance. Actually the Flak is even better in game, since it has a mixed HVAP API-T belt, which is better against angles, as well as has even more penetration since the first rounds velocity in the belt Applys its velocity to All shells, which means the 148g API-T is fired at 1050m/s and gives it slightly more than 50mm pen.

1

u/12lubushby 1d ago

Its subjective to be fair

34

u/marijnvtm 1d ago

Not just a threat but one of the best vehicles at its br

9

u/thrashmetaloctopus 1d ago

Any 20mm SPAA at rank 1 is lethal

8

u/Thing482 1d ago

When starting a new nation, I always look forward to the rank 1 vehicles. I did Italy a few months ago and I remember they had a large variety of vehicles that use a 20mm and it was very pleasant... Well, I remember disliking most of the other tanks for how clunky/slow they were.

2

u/thrashmetaloctopus 1d ago

Yeah Italy is nowhere near as bad as people seem to believe it is, you just can’t sit in the middle of a chokepoint and tank 30 rounds in any of its tanks

27

u/Spirited-Hamster6267 1d ago

Yeah but you can just mg it

94

u/S1k-puppy 1d ago

You can say the same about the 57-2

0

u/Spirited-Hamster6267 1d ago

but the 58 has an easier time 1 shooting things

49

u/Foraaikouu 1d ago

the Flakpanzer also 1 shoots stuff at it's BR

3

u/Kride501 1d ago

Your arguments do NOT hold up fam

28

u/KrokmaniakPL 1d ago

To be fair with .50 you can MG most tanks in rank I.

19

u/Valoneria 1d ago

Yep, the dual .50 cal British SPAA was a damn menace on release due to this, at 1.3 BR. Fast, and could penetrate tanks from all sides

4

u/Badass_C0okie 1d ago

You cant if he mg you first.

1

u/Thomastheactualtank 22h ago

Back in my prime when I was a CAS spamming cancer I once got dotted by a Flakpanzer 1 in my Phantom FG.1, thing is a menace 

1

u/BENJ4x 6h ago

I remember playing with/against someone with 10-15k games in the early Germany AA vehicles.

You find some nutters if you check profiles from time to time.

114

u/recoil-1000 1d ago

It is tradition at this point for the lobby to make fun of people spawning in the 30mm aa’s off the bat

64

u/trumpsucks12354 1d ago

One good thing about the T58 is that they can obliterate these hellspawns at the start of the match. Fighting cancer with cancer

65

u/posidon99999 Strongest 🅱️ESH user (yellow fuel tank) 1d ago

Moloch vs Baal

180

u/presmonkey JUG IS LOVE JUG IS LIFE 1d ago

The M16 slander will not be tolerated

-30

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

95

u/Georg3251 Hater of CAS 1d ago

"Effectiveness against tanks" read motherfucker (channeling inner samuel l jackson)

28

u/Mr_Nokhod- 1d ago

8

u/Georg3251 Hater of CAS 1d ago

I was looking for this, but couldn't find it. Gifs have become really shitty. Thanks

15

u/Ertyla SPAA main and StuH enjoyer 1d ago

Yes, and that's completely irrelevant to OP's point

27

u/STUPIDBLOODYCOMPUTER Peanut Butter Jelly main 1d ago

Shocked the Duster isn't here. Them 40mm are a menace if they catch you in the side

7

u/Upstairs-Rock-7332 1d ago

Yeah, its great fun!

(just like most of the other low tier 40mm SPAA)

2

u/WhiterThanRice 1d ago edited 19h ago

You can kill a panther if you catch it in the side

54

u/135686492y4 R3 T106 Enjoyer 1d ago

TBH tje Swedish TT gets nuclear SPAAs in the early-game

Not shown: western 20mm-armed junk.

11

u/Spirited-Hamster6267 1d ago

I was just choosing the obvious ones. sorry if I didn’t get all of them or the whole picture

37

u/Leopard_2K_MBT 🇩🇪 Peak German Engineering 🇩🇪 1d ago

Hey, OP, you forgot a couple which are DEVASTATING. For instance:

19

u/iranoutofuckingnames 1d ago

Bro that is not an SPAA. That's a "fuck whatever I'm aiming at" vehicle.

6

u/Own-Consideration854 1d ago

It literally has Flak in the name. WT brain rot is taking over.

3

u/gokartninja 19h ago

Because of the gun

5

u/iranoutofuckingnames 23h ago

Funny how the vehicle description says it's intended purpose was to be a tank destroyer, and the flak in it's name is only regarding the gun....but whatever, brainrot o algo.

5

u/Leopard_2K_MBT 🇩🇪 Peak German Engineering 🇩🇪 22h ago

It's called the "Flakbus" / "Flaktruck" because its primary purpose was firing (you didn't actually guess it) FLAK SHELLS! And "Flak" is short for "Fliegerabwehrkanone", which essentially translates to "anti-air cannon". It's an AA.

3

u/gokartninja 19h ago

No, its primary purpose was hauling the (Flak) gun around. It was originally intended to destroy fortifications, but also ended up being used against heavy French tanks

2

u/iranoutofuckingnames 17h ago

Please look up Sd.Kfz. 9, and READ what these ones were modified for. It literally was for anti-tank duties and nothing else.

I do NOT give a single, flying fuckshit about it's name, I can call a tank destroyer a SPAA, doesn't make it one.

3

u/F2d24 16h ago

I wish it would actually work as an AA in the game.

It would need a mechanic where the crew automatically sets the time fuse for the target aircraft to work in practise

18

u/morrison666 1d ago

Not mentioned are all the spaa equipped with the 40mm Bofors there's a couple at low tier that are absolute beasts. Also not mentioned is the super underrated Zut-37, yes it's apparently an spaa with the slowest turret rotation in the world BUT man that 37mm is so good at dealing with tanks it's honestly a better light tank then an spaa.

12

u/Mg42gun 1d ago

Swedish L/60 Bofors basically low tier OTOMATIC

7

u/WAiiNz 1d ago

once k vave been killed by a BUK, be careful out there guys

6

u/Shot_Reputation1755 1d ago

20-25mms and .50 cal anti airs are great TDs at their respective BRs

6

u/Onnispotente 1d ago

Mid?
MID????

8

u/Nack321 1d ago

I want to have the flakpanzer341 so bad

4

u/ElBaizen 1d ago

Its a fun demon but doesnt obliterate as much as 35mm spaa because at that BR theres far more armored enemies

4

u/Xx21beastmode88 1d ago

Ah the wirblewind at mid, I remember back in my day it was at 3.7 and a demon

1

u/Leopard_2K_MBT 🇩🇪 Peak German Engineering 🇩🇪 1d ago

Is it not still? If you can aim correctly, then it's more than capable.

2

u/Xx21beastmode88 1d ago

I only say mid because thats where it is on the image and because I haven't played it in so long

1

u/Leopard_2K_MBT 🇩🇪 Peak German Engineering 🇩🇪 22h ago

Oh, okay. It's still great at taking out just about everything.

1

u/ImpactDangerous3270 13h ago

It is nowhere near what it used to be with +60mm pen. That meant you could take on tanks like T-34s from 500m just by shooting through their turret face and T-34 sides were very vulnerable. Now T-34s turret even at point blank will just eat all the HVAP ammo.

5

u/MewllerLetLoose 1d ago

Literally dropped my 7th nuke ever in this

3

u/StandardCount4358 1d ago

Ive gotta a kill with the OSA before, after 500m it turns into an agm

3

u/johndaylight China🇨🇳 1d ago

Where the ADATS

3

u/Obvious-Yogurt1445 Dumbass 1d ago

Russian milk truck :D

6

u/ABT653 1d ago

Calling the wirbelwind mid is a wild take

2

u/Suruaku 1d ago

20mm at 3.something is quite mid at best against tanks

2

u/thatoneotterbuthot 22h ago

I mean… sir its an anti AIR vehicle, of course it isnt the best against tanks

2

u/Reasonable_Try143 16h ago

but they are ranked here not on the basis of anti-air capability

1

u/androodle2004 11h ago

Yes. Not the best. Not the worst. Mid. We are going in circles here

2

u/black_jaguar99_2 20h ago

This is an American main, the Sherman does not fear the .50 permeable.

1

u/o-Mauler-o 18h ago

After it’s AP nerf, it’s definitey mid against tanks now.

4

u/Realspeed7 1d ago

What the fuck why is the IRIS-T Terrible

13

u/Kride501 1d ago

Because you can't read. The title says "effectiveness against tanks." Now why would the Irist be terrible there hmmm

1

u/92-Uranium235 20h ago

But at the top tier, there are still SPAAs like the ADATS, LAV-AD, or even the 2S6 and Pantsir SM SV, which can be very dangerous.

1

u/Kride501 20h ago

They can be, yea, but the tanks around these br are at their peak of the br. They are faster, better armored, reload faster, punch harder and react faster. Getting a kill with one of those AAs vs then getting a kill with a Gepard at it's br is quite the difference.

4

u/KeyPhilosopher8629 Will possibly forget compression exists 1d ago

Because it can't do squat against tanks

7

u/Johni33 1d ago

I have 6 Tank kills with the iris-t

3

u/AverageDellUser Ace 1d ago

I’ve kill T-72s with the Flarak. Roland system, it is pretty funny to do.

1

u/Artygnat 1d ago

How?

2

u/AverageDellUser Ace 1d ago

Overpressure somehow, I panicked and hit either the top of his turret or the turret cheek, I can’t rlly remember which

1

u/Artygnat 23h ago

That’s fine, but how did you get a lock?

1

u/Johni33 23h ago

Flakrak is laser guided so you only need to aim at the rooftop of the tank

1

u/AverageDellUser Ace 18h ago

Don’t need one, the Roland system based on the marder chassis is SACLOS so it follows where your reticle is and does not require a lock. https://wiki.warthunder.com/unit/germ_flarakpz_1

1

u/Artygnat 7h ago

Ah cool

2

u/Mysterious-Goal-4086 22h ago

How

1

u/Johni33 22h ago

Well they spawncamped behind a Rock and iris-t has 3 vehicles so you can call in 3 artillery stikes at once. And one time my missle missed a drone and railed a random BMP in their spawn

1

u/VeritableLeviathan 1d ago

I've got several tank kills with the OSA as well.

That doesn't make it good at it lmao

2

u/wargamer19 1d ago

dude I've had CRAZY games with the flakpanzer. It shreds at low tier, you can even take it up to 1.7 or 2.0 and do alright with it

2

u/arturthegamer #1 Ariete simp 1d ago

I raise you otomatic it's pretty damn good, you just gotta remember the 12 apfsds limit and take some sap for safety

2

u/sharktail_tanker 1d ago

ISTG they are deliberately not fixing overpressure stacking at this point, a York can still pen a T-72 to the turret face with the SAP shells by killing the breech and triggering an overpressure kill

1

u/randommaniac12 Every ground tree but Israel 11.3 or abvoe 1d ago

I've bounced APHE rounds off of the loaders MG into the turret to get kills on T-55's, it's absolutely absurd

2

u/darkpheonix4565 1d ago

I remember when the wirbelwind was essentially the god of low-mid tier

4

u/Plastic_Ambition2572 1d ago

Idk what ur talking about. My favorite way of having fun is playing Flakpanzer 1 and getting about 20 kills each game

10

u/Spirited-Hamster6267 1d ago

seal clubber

1

u/hephaestusfiregod 1d ago edited 1d ago

Of the 2 demons shown, at least the ZSU-57-2 can be reliably killed with overpressure from any heat round (I play a lot of vehicles with high pen HEAT-FS) or 50 calibers. The flakpanzer is high key worse especially when you can’t see where you’re shooting. Dealing with a ZSU that is obscured by a hill just means arcing heat or he over the hill & hitting anywhere on the vehicle. The flakpanzer, however, requires actually hitting a weak point like your average medium tank.

1

u/Educational_Card_193 1d ago

What about the twin 30mm from russia, ive killed loads of tanks with that

1

u/Redpower5 1d ago

The terrible one I only have ONE apropriate reaction to

1

u/MrcooldudeSP M55 user 1d ago

now dis is some scary shih

1

u/PsychologicalGlass47 1d ago

ZSU-57-2 is coughing baby, WZ305 is atomic bomb

1

u/That_Pathetic_Guy 1d ago

Wirbelwind used to be a menace

1

u/AirFriedMoron 1d ago

Idk low tier SPAAs are pretty strong with the paper armour around

1

u/The_Lieutenant_Knows 1d ago

At least the damn Coelian dies when you kill it. The stupid Ameripard has the most advanced armor array in the world.

1

u/Scorchey_Bagel 21h ago

Where the T77E1 at? It's a budget CIWS at 4.0

2

u/ChesedSephirot 16h ago

The M13/16 is probably the best AA / AT for its BR

Edit: What can stop it? A PZ III E frontally, maybe the 38T and the Swedish things, but most things are dead frontally/ All things are dead from the side.

2

u/ImpactDangerous3270 13h ago

M16 is 2.7 at that BR pretty much everything that isn't Japanese has enough armor to stop 50cal from front and even M13 has to face PzIVs,PzIIIs, 2.3 Pz 38ts, T-28E, T60/T70/T80, Stuart 1/3, Ho-I, whole M13 series, Turan, M41s and basically most of French tree.

1

u/SexyStacosaurus 15h ago

When I want rely on my team to hopefully save me against planes but this is mindset I need to deal with.

1

u/Savings-Shape-3400 14h ago

poor M19 is a shredder of ground vehicles at 4,0

1

u/Wolfpirate20 11h ago

Do not dare call my Wirbelwind mid. I remember when I started playing germany. Its a beauty.

1

u/nothing_big111312 10h ago

Hey you forgot the swing fire

1

u/nothing_big111312 10h ago

But other wise I aggee

1

u/TheEschaton 6h ago

the fact that this lineup completely ignores WWII/Korea-era 40mm SPAA is hilarious to me. Do you guys seriously not know how great it is?

1

u/Hayds707 1d ago

Iris was so good when it first came out:( now it’s like they turned the IRCCM off

1

u/Zathral 1d ago

Using cold war time travel spaas in an anti tank role against ww2 tanks should just be banned somehow

0

u/Round-Suggestion-331 1d ago

coelian is literaly dogwater. at 7.0 there's many more AA that can clap tanks and putting it in with the ZSU is disguisting

1

u/HuskySkrr 1d ago

Tell me you don't know how to play coelian without telling me you can't play coelian

0

u/Tobipig 1d ago

The iris-t is god tier. I’d accept the buk being shit, but the iris-t??

1

u/Terrible-Apartment-2 1d ago

Read the title again.

-1

u/Tobipig 1d ago

DID I STUTTER

1

u/Terrible-Apartment-2 1d ago

You think the Iris T is god tier at killing tanks? 🤣

-1

u/Tobipig 1d ago

IF THE RUSSIANS USE S-400 AS A BALLISTIC MISSILE THEN ONLY GOD AND THE GUYS GALS AND NONBINARY PALS AT THE BAAINBW can stop me

0

u/Sherincal_of_Astora 1d ago

Where's the XM800T in SPAA role in all this though? 😂

0

u/Embarrassed-Hippo634 15h ago

Don't ever insult the m16 mgmc again bro.