I recently changed jobs and as I work with a more diverse population, I am beginning to see I have a penchant for certain client populations, some that aren’t my cup of tea, and some I’m indifferent about. As I learn this about myself, I’m questioning if this is “normal” and sometimes if it’s ethical (for me, and for our field).
I’ve seen therapists say they prefer to work with a particular population. Examples: women going through divorce, kids who have experienced trauma, teens, PTSD, people impacted negatively by religious institutions, first-generation immigrants, veterans, etc.
What I don’t see, and this is the part I’d like to discuss, is therapists who don’t like working with a particular group. I’ve seen a lot of “That’s outside of my scope, so I refer out” which I understand, and makes sense to me. But what if it is in scope and one does have the credentials and skills, but you just really don’t like working with a particular subset? It doesn’t trigger any personal trauma. There’s no personal experience contributing to countertransference. What if you just really dislike working with men, or teenagers, or depression, or intellectual disabilities, or pregnant women, or criminal offenders, or anxiety, or SUD, or (fill in the blank)?
Is that an ethical gray area? If you refuse to take that subset as clients, is it discriminatory? Does it mean you need to learn/grow more, be more accepting/empathetic, have better UPR? Does it mean you’re just human? If it is veering toward unethical, how do you know? How do you bring this up in supervision, or with peers without sounding like a bigot or way too picky? Should you overcome it and accept those clients anyway? If so, do you just tolerate it as one of the cons of the job? If you do that and get too many of that type of client, how do you still love your job and flourish and feel fulfillment in your chosen career path? Am I overanalyzing? (Probably.)
I hope I worded that OK and it didn’t come across as offensive, ignorant, or judgy or anything. I would just really like to engage in some discussion on this topic, because I don’t see it come up and I’m feeling a bit alone thinking through this by myself. I still work with all the clients that come my way, treat them the best I can, and don’t have any big feelings surfacing. It's more the realization of "I simply don’t enjoy working with this population.” I’m not really struggling. It’s just not part of my day I look forward to, and I just want to question this and learn more from others in my field who might have felt this way on their professional journey.
This is on my agenda for supervision, I’d just like to see some straight talk (especially from more seasoned therapists and/or others who have switched from a specialized population to a more diverse one), learn a bit more, and organize my thoughts a little bit before I bring it up in the limited time space for supervision.
TIA for any discussion, feedback, or experiences! (I wasn't sure whether to flair this as "discussion" or "support." It could be both I guess.)
TL;DR - How do you navigate client populations you prefer not to work with?