Sauces: 1-5 Even Monsters Like Fairytales, 6-12 The Pale Horse
Recommendations and Discussion
+ Discussion ramble about my struggles and opinions with isekai tropes at end of post.
I probably donāt even need to say this but Isekai, villainess, reincarnation, time loop tropes are popular right now. There are so many series, often with similar long titles, summaries and cover art. I get lost in sauce and IDK what is what or how to work out what series I might like. So, Iām sharing two amazing series that explore these tropes in interesting and thought-provoking ways. There both a bit dark and spooky so perfect for October. Iād love to hear your recs and discussion too!
I want to be as mindful of spoilers so apologises for being vague and so rambly.
Even Monsters Like Fairytales
Even Monsters Like Fairytales is an exploration of villainess trope.
Summary: Sylph is a duchess, engaged to the Prince of Luxborn. She does everything which is expected of her, with the one exception; secretly reading fiction stories in the library. One day Sylph is approached by Lady Kana, an aristocrat girl and they become fast friends. Lady Kana betrays her, taking Sylphs position as Princeās fiancĆ© and framing Sylph as a villain. She is banished to the dark forest to be eaten by King of the land of monsters. The Monster King doesnāt eat her but instead grants Sylph one wish.
This series really investigates its premise; who is a villainess and why, how are villainess traditionally treated in stories and what should they do? Itās a tight 29 chapters, with a few bonus chapters (which are integral imo). The writing feels sharp and intentional just like the art. Iāll confess that I nearly dropped this series because King Faber looked like a PokĆ©mon or Yu-Gi-Oh! character to me and it was distracting lol. But Iām so glad I didnāt because the art and the story is really amazing, the compositions are WOW! Its bit more philosophical (?) than a character study. Its handling ideas like retributive vs restorative justice. The characters can feel a little inexpressive but that doesnāt mean it doesnāt have emotion. I found the end really moving. Itās tagged as romance, I would say itās a pinch of romance, if even that, ( honestly giving Doomed Yuri vibes ) just to set your expectations. Iām honestly glad it doesnāt have more romance; I think it would mess the story. Ā
The Pale Horse
The Pale Horse is a manhwa which centres on reincarnation. I know this a Manhwa not Shoujo manga, hopefully thatās okay in this sub. Iāve seen this tagged as josei, itās definitely mature. In some ways, itās the opposite of Even Monsters Like Fairytales. Its looong, the plot is messy, itās all emotion, all passion in the writing and art and itās great. Itās a mystery so I have no idea how to talk about it without doing spoilers. Itās about the horrors of being a woman, immortality, cannibalism/vampirism, grief, revenge, obsessive love and abuse. TW for gore, abuse, SA, implied CSA. Itās pretty fucked up. But its not glorifying those things⦠I think. Honestly, itās really hard for me to decide what I think or feel about this series. Every time I thought I could pin it down, something happened in the story which flips things. It can drag in sections and I'm not sure on the ending, it was written over something like ten years, but there are so many compelling arcs. And the art is just jaw dropping, the amount of detail and the expressions are incredible. This series will make you feel a lot of things and sticks in your head. Its one of the most interesting immortality/reincarnation stories Iāve come across.
Isakai Trope Discussiony Ramble
I wanted to share these recommendations because works that deconstruct or explore popular tropes can have uphill battle to get readers. What I mean is that to deconstruct a trope often you have to construct it first. A Condition Called Love is a perfect example. It integrates the Hananoiās idea of āperfect, doting loveā and reveals it to be deeply unhealthy for both ML and MC. But the only way to reveal that āloveā as unhealthy is first show it. And thatās where it can lose a lot of readers; before the reader gets to the deconstruction bit, they drop it. Series that are thoughtful deconstructions of popular tropes, often have similar blurbs, covers and beginnings as troupy clichĆ© counter parts. So please, if you have any recs that are interesting deconstructions of tropes, doesnāt have to be the tropes Iāve mentioned, or a series that just does the trope really well, please share. I should mention, that I love a lot of Shoujo tropes! I donāt think tropes are bad at all, Iām just looking for interesting stories.
That being said something I struggle with modern isakai, reincarnation, time loop series, ect is when the MC is largely unaffected by the premise of the story. There isnāt much reflection on how scary, confusing or disorientating reincarnation would be for example. I get thatās not the focus of some series, but I find that it removes a lot of the tension and intrigue of the story. When the MC is like āOh, this is my 500\**th life. I know exactly what I need to doā the stakes go out the window and I get kinda bored. Or sometimes, a series will start with an isaki trope, like classic hit by truck now in video game world, only for that plot point to barely come up in the story again. If you removed that beat the story would be completely the same but at the same time when it is brought up it kind of distracts from whatās happening in the main plot. What is the point?? I donāt get it. I guess itās a framing device?
(Huge Tangent about framing devises and Princess Bride for some reason )
Just like the kind of frame you put an artwork in changes the experience of the artwork, if you remove the artwork from the frame, the artwork is still the same artwork. Like the film the Princess Bride. The framing device is the Grandad reading the story to the little boy who is sick. The main plot is about Buttercup and Westly. If you got rid of Grandad and the little boy, youād still having the Princess Bride but a little different. I actually read the book of The Princess Bride as a kid, and I was surprised that there was no Grandad or sick boy. The framing is an adult man, remembering a story his dad would read him, finding that story and rewriting it as an adult. Instead of the funny remarks from the kid āGrandad, can we skip the kissy partsā there was like some weird adult man comments about boobs or something.
Is that whatās going on with the Isakei tropes, itās a framing device? And then that allows the exploration of character tropes like Tsunderes or Yanderes etc.
But⦠in these Isakei series MC are canonically in the book but are generally chill about being transported to a different world, not like Princess Bride book within a book thing. But maybe it is still like a book within a book??
Am I dumb? I donāt get it, what am I missing? Is the point that things are easy for MC and thatās the fantasy? I get it that, life is pretty hard and the idea of knowing what to do, I can see the appeal I guess. I am genuinely curious. I donāt know if I just havenāt read good series with these story beats or if these stories just arenāt my cup of tea. Please sound out! Let me know why itās your cup of tea!
Ā