r/pie • • Jul 07 '26

Homemade my beautiful cherry and black currant pie

Thumbnail
gallery
711 Upvotes

I am never bringing baked goods outside for a glamour shot ever again


r/pie • • Jun 01 '26

My First Ever Pie - Key Lime Pie

Post image
900 Upvotes

As an avid Snacker, I often find myself purchasing my favorite type of pie, key lime, from the frozen food section of my local market. I had some time on my hands, so I challenged myself to craft the perfect pie to reward all of my successes I’ve recently had in life. It was quite surprising to find that the recipie and process for this was almost boringly easy. The only challenge I encountered was the whipped cream, I could not whisk very fast as I was born with only three fingers on my dominant hand. A fun fact I learned about key limes during this process is the origin of the name. Pirates, after learning about the cause of scurvy, would pack many citrus fruits for their long voyages. Obviously, one of them was the key lime, which they soon discovered a secondary purpose for, beyond simply eating. Pirates often came across locked chests and buried treasure. They did not want to damage the insides by breaking the lock, so they tried squeezing lime juice on lock. The pure acidity in the liquid would cause the lock to lose its unique padding in a matter of minutes. This, allowing any metal object to adjust the turnstile inside. So, the key lime was born!

I would like to try a more challenging pie next, so please inform me of the ones available that fit the criteria. Thanks for reading.


r/pie • • 15h ago

Homemade Chicken pot pie

Post image
165 Upvotes

r/pie • • 8h ago

Homemade Apple Pie 🍎

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

It just needed some caramel sauce


r/pie • • 21h ago

Homemade Maple coconut oat pie

Thumbnail
gallery
102 Upvotes

To continue my weekly pie challenge until thanksgiving i decided this week to make a maple coconut oat pie that in my opinion was so good it transcended my palette and sent my tastebuds to dimension higher than myself and i for one can't wait for the next pie in this adventure.


r/pie • • 18h ago

Homemade Savory Tortilla Pie

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

Homemade masa harina tortillas, with ground turkey/mushroom chili, rice & beans- served with avocado mash & salsa😘


r/pie • • 1d ago

Blackberry/Peach Pie Ala Mode

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/pie • • 1d ago

Apple pie

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/pie • • 2d ago

Apple Cookies from leftovers

Thumbnail
gallery
255 Upvotes

I had some leftover dough and apples so I made dese golden cookies :>


r/pie • • 2d ago

Homemade Ginger honey tarts

Post image
18 Upvotes

Lil mini pies with a ginger caramel custard filling


r/pie • • 2d ago

Homemade Apple Cheddar Pie

Thumbnail gallery
49 Upvotes

r/pie • • 3d ago

Homemade Are Chicken Pot Pies Welcome Here?

Post image
797 Upvotes

This is the first pie I've ever made. There's definitely room for improvement but I'm so happy with how it turned out!


r/pie • • 3d ago

Homemade Thanksgiving Pie 🍂🍎

Thumbnail
gallery
206 Upvotes

Made my first apple pie of 2026! Picked the apples (Crispin), and then made the pie crust from scratch. 😊

Apple Filling:
🍎Crispin apples peeled and chopped into chunks

Then in pan heat together over medium heat for 6 mins:
🍏1/3 cup sugar
🍎1 tsp cinnamon
🍏2 tbsp butter
🍎4 apples
Let cool for a bit before setting in pie crust. (Also tasted delicious as an ice cream topper🍨)

Pie Crust:
🥧1/2 cup vegetable shortening
🥧1 1/2 cups All Purpose Flour
🥧1/2 tsp salt
🥧1 cup ice cold water to use as needed for dough consistency
🥧made leaf pattern with cookie cutter
🥧Bake at 400 degrees for 30-45mins


r/pie • • 2d ago

Homemade Chocolate chai peanut butter ganache pie in a sourdough chocolate cookie crust pie. 💀

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

All is edible, Rice Krispie, molding chocolate, edible paper, food coloring markers & gel.


r/pie • • 2d ago

ADVICE? Need Help With A Pie Idea

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/pie • • 3d ago

Homemade Happy Thanksgiving! Blueberry, cherry, and apple pie

Thumbnail
gallery
282 Upvotes

r/pie • • 2d ago

Homemade Peanut butter chocolate ganache in a chocolate chip cookie pie. 💀

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/pie • • 3d ago

ADVICE? Flavour/ texture differences between sweet potato and pumpkin pie.

5 Upvotes

Never eaten either (I'm British) but would love to for Thanksgiving this year.


r/pie • • 4d ago

Homemade My first ever pie (Pecan)

Post image
241 Upvotes

Holy shit this was way more work than I expected but, now I just wanna make a million different pies. It’s absolutely delicious. I used a 1:1 split of honey:corn syrup instead of just corn syrup, and it was amazing.

thanks for the kind words everyone, i appreciate it!


r/pie • • 3d ago

Homemade Some mini pumpkin pies made with leftover dough/filling

Post image
62 Upvotes

They were so cute and tasty. Happy Thanksgiving everyone!


r/pie • • 3d ago

Smoked pie?? - I need help!

6 Upvotes

I have Art of the Pie by McDermott. I followed the crust instructions to the letter, a few times, with the same problematic results. The melting “pea-sized lumps” of fat in the dough are melting and dripping out of the pie pan, and burning on the oven floor (or 1/2 sheet catch-pan, etc), creating smoke and a gross smokey pie and smoked-out house. Angry smoke detector, angry Husbeast. I’ve had this result with the all-butter and half butter, half shortening (or is it lard?) recipes.(It’s been awhile.) I had one pie where the crust was practically frying on a layer of melted fat in the plate. I had visible sizzle on the rim of the plate.

The finished pies LOOK great. Puffed and flakey.

My oven temp is accurate and preheated. I measure by weight. I use plain colourless Pyrex plates. Unbleached organic flour of good quality. Decent local (Canadian) butter and grocery store lard (shortening? Whichever is listed in the recipe) from the baking aisle.

I’m afraid to waste the time and ingredients again without suggestions. Why won’t the fat stay IN the dough??

Does anyone have a pic of rolled out dough that shows the visible fat pieces?


r/pie • • 3d ago

Homemade I miei pasticciotti e le mie crostatine con crema pasticcera e amarene

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/pie • • 4d ago

Cinnamon Maple Apple Pie 🍁

Post image
634 Upvotes

2nd place at a neighborhood pie contest!


r/pie • • 4d ago

Homemade Happy Thanksgiving! Pumpkin, apple, and black raspberry pie 🥧

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

My first time making pumpkin pie, and it turned out better than I could have ever hoped for. The rest were amazing, too!


r/pie • • 4d ago

First attempt at Apple pie

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

I never bake, but I decided to randomly give it a shot. I used Natural apples from the forest, and it took about 2 hours in total. Lmk what you guys think.