r/mildlyinteresting • • 1d ago

Giant lemon rinds on wife’s lemon tree

Post image
11.1k Upvotes

565 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

634

u/Own_Ad_409 1d ago

Oh cool I thought they were just mutants

538

u/Versipilies 1d ago

They are occasionally used as rootstock on citrus trees so anything that grows below the graft will produce the rootstock fruit or if the tree died back below the graft at some point the entire tree can just be the rootstock species.

127

u/doctorhiney 1d ago

This is extremely cool plant knowledge I did not know.

122

u/PoppyBroSenior 1d ago

Look up the difference between broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, brussel sprouts, kale, kohlarabi and collards. All of em are more or less the same plant bred for different genetic characteristics. The history of how the orange was created, how a lot of citrus fruits were made by hybridization, is pretty cool. Strawberries are one such fruit too. Selective crossbreeding and horticulture is pretty neat.

21

u/doctorhiney 1d ago

I’ve always known these facts but the rootstalk comment put them into actual actionable context for me. So cool.

2

u/ASpoonfullOfSass 1d ago

Apples are another fun one to read on! They are all done by graft. It's neat!

1

u/Xaxxis 1d ago

Bananas are one of the craziest plant stories imo

27

u/Versipilies 1d ago

The cool bit is more why they graft. If the rootstoxk is from a dwarf tree it will dwarf whats on top, if its more cold hardy it will make the top more so, but the most common reason is usually disease resistance. Unfortunately grafted trees often have a shorter lifespan due to the graft failing or getting infected with age. Peaches and plums will usually last about 15 years depending on climate

37

u/skintigh 1d ago

Yeah I had a thornless lime tree that froze and became a limeless thorn tree.

10

u/Versipilies 1d ago

Yeah trifolate and swingle are pretty common rootstocks and both can be super thorny. They will eventually produce fruit, not good fruit.... but fruit like things.... regrafting is pretty easy luckily. Flying dragon rootstock does look really cool though

12

u/OffRoadIT ​ 1d ago

Could you graft more citrus varieties to the healthy citron main stalk and have branches of lemon, lime, orange, grapefruit, and citron?

26

u/Versipilies 1d ago

Yes you can, they are often called "fruit salad" trees. Similarly you can have pears, apples, and quince on one tree, and peaches, plums, apricots and cherries on another. As long as the grafts are the same family it generally works, there are some odd non compatability issues with certain varieties. Theres an guy who makes trees with 40 different varieties per tree. Upkeep takes some work since you have to be more careful about branch pruning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_of_40_Fruit

2

u/dauntless-cupcake 1d ago

I think you have to stick within compatible “families” of fruit but yeah this is a thing people do!

1

u/jimmy_three_shoes 17h ago

Yep. Wife had a grafted rosebush at our old house and it died one winter from the frost and when it came back the next year we didn't get any blooms, and the year after that instead of the dark red blooms, they were a sickly yellow, lol.

110

u/KarazJam 1d ago

More like relatives, the lemon is a hybrid of a citron and a bitter orange.

69

u/Azsunyx 1d ago

You mean life didn't give us lemons?

32

u/sagebrushrepair 1d ago

Sometimes you just gotta make different trees pollinate each other, ya know? It's tough

It's sorta like making lemonade when all you have is citron and bitter orange

8

u/Craigglesofdoom 1d ago

It's not clear if the lemon as we know it was a deliberate hybrid or chance seedling.

7

u/Azsunyx 1d ago

So you're saying life finds a way

https://giphy.com/gifs/11FiDF2fuOujPG

5

u/YakGroundbreaking352 1d ago

no we invented them ourselves

2

u/DiGiorn0s 1d ago

Life also doesn't come with an egg roll. You gotta order it

28

u/Aerodrache 1d ago

Be careful with them; if they are citrons (they’d taste like a sort of mellow non-bitter grapefruit), then they’ll mess with medications the same way grapefruit does.

11

u/MadcapRecap 1d ago

They are one of the 4 original citrus fruit and are absolutely delicious. The flesh is quite tart but the white pith is sweet and has a texture a bit like an apple. You can cut it into long segments and eat both bits together.

50

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

60

u/Lord_Parbr 1d ago

How do we know you’re not a Reddit bullshitter? Seems like you’re doing a lot of denying and contradiction

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

3

u/Lord_Parbr 1d ago

Oh, I am

-52

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[deleted]

39

u/Lord_Parbr 1d ago

And you’re clearly not smart enough to know that just saying “they’re full of shit” isn’t a refutation. I was joking before, btw

4

u/smittyleafs 1d ago

I've found I abuse "...lol" at the end of jokes because I'm always worried folks won't pick it up via context.

1

u/Azsunyx 1d ago

"lol" is punctuation

7

u/DeficitAttention 1d ago

He said "bullshitter," but that's not his argument. He also claims it could simply be a mutant lemon and you can't tell by the photo. Now, if the other person is able to, or even cares, they could respond with how they know it's a citron and not just a mutant lemon.

12

u/churninhell 1d ago

Maybe they're a mutant lemon and trying to throw everyone off.

9

u/AleopardThatJumps 1d ago

wow things are heating up in the Cirtus fandom

2

u/Lord_Parbr 1d ago

Wait until the grapefruit fuckers show up

10

u/tonicella_lineata 1d ago

Just contradicting someone isn't really refuting their point, though. The person claiming it's a citron did actually link the Wikipedia page for citrons further down-thread, which very much supports their point. Ol' freudian_nipps, on the other hand, hasn't presented a shred of evidence - combined with the insults, it certainly sounds like they're just being contrary for the sake of it.

1

u/DeficitAttention 1d ago

You're right that it didn't refute the original comment, but I think the word refute was actually used by the other person. Contradict is a better word, but if his premise is true, it would cast doubt on the certainty of the original claim. He was rude calling the guy a bullshitter for no good reason, but that wasn't the premise of his argument. In any case, I think anyone could be forgiven for assuming it's probably a citron based on the photo. It wasn't that serious and I don't think the man being called a bullshitter was pretending to be some kind of lemon expert anyway.

10

u/Force321X 1d ago

Saying they're full of shit with no actual argument isn't being a contrarian ya know. Let me present the question then as someone who has had lemon trees. What is more likely? A Citron rootstock with a graft and that fruit grew below the graft, or a mutation?

5

u/tonicella_lineata 1d ago

Do you have a source for that? Studies of lemons with this mutation, maybe? Because this looks like a citron or citron-like hybrid, and the person you're calling a bullshitter did provide a source in giving us the Wikipedia page for citrons. And the rootstock info from other folks is also correct (which I personally know from being in gardening groups, but is also reflected on that same Wikipedia page).

So far, the only one who seems to be bullshitting here is you.

-2

u/i_was_me 1d ago

i am made of poo

2

u/Lucky_Cable_3145 1d ago

My Mandarin tree has Citron as the root stock and sends up suckers. I let one of the suckers grow and it produced fruit like that. All rid and very bitter.

1

u/asdkevinasd 23h ago

Those are heller popular in Asia for lemon tea, if I did not mix the translation up. They are called perfume lemon here and they are added to iced lemon tea.