r/mildlyinfuriating • • 13h ago

Don't hug me I'm scared No AI symbol is AI generated

Post image
17.7k Upvotes

708 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/caintowers RED 13h ago

Ideally all AI agents would leave some kind of pattern or marker on their output so any checker could identify whether it is AI generated and what AI did it.

I know a lot of them do it for images, like Gemini and GPT.

But, correct me if I'm wrong, I don't think they do it for text. And because they're trained ON human writing, of course what they generate is going to share similarities.

I take pride in my writing. It's a weird thing to get complimented on, but I used to get random praise like "your emails are so professional!". Now it's "did you use AI to write that?" And it's like no, but Google probably used my outbox for training data.

27

u/King_of_the_Kobolds 12h ago

Words cannot describe how much I hate you can no longer write a multi paragraph, articulate post on many subreddits without getting accused of AI.

6

u/Financial_Pin8385 10h ago

I also feel like I can't use the em dash anymore. That was my favourite punctuation mark

4

u/I__Know__Stuff 9h ago

Please don't change your writing style to appease the idiots.

2

u/TransientWonderboy 9h ago

When I was writing blogs as a digital marketing manager I was told to stop using em dashes for just this reason

5

u/OrionRBR 12h ago

Now you have to add typos and misspellings on purpose

1

u/ExIsStalkingMe 9h ago

You did it as well, but I always love leaving the end of any paragraph without a period. It started as a way to make my writing less stiff in the old days, but it works as a sign I'm not AI

1

u/caintowers RED 12h ago

Basically. I skip the proofread. Or if I do notice a mistake I just figure I'll leave it in there

2

u/I__Know__Stuff 9h ago

I proofread after posting. So most of my comments show an edit. How many AI posts do that?

(The reason I proofread after posting is because of the number of times I lost a whole comment while editing, either due to a system issue or a fat finger.)

2

u/Feeling_Inside_1020 12h ago

This isn't AI, it's a human, and you're right to push back— and that makes you special. Not many people catch that.

9

u/Rewdboy05 12h ago

Some of them actually started doing it for text a while back. It's actually really interesting how they figured out how to do it.

1

u/I_came_in_peace 11h ago

They will be doing that in the EU, at least soon

1

u/xADDBx 6h ago

> I don’t think they do it for text

"They" (the relevant western ones at least) are doing that actually. The TL;DR is that SynthId for text works by influencing the chance of the next token. Roughly: in a sentence

"I […] listen to music"

there’s a certain subset of words that make sense. E.g. often, regularly, sometimes, …; the text watermarking works by slightly increasing the chance of some words, e.g. often in this case.

Now that one word won’t work as a watermark; but when text with > 100 shows that it just happens to favor the marked words, it can be used to calculate how likely a text was made by a specific LLM.

That’s the gist of it anyway.

•

u/Ok_War9655 30m ago

The same watermarking technique is already implemented for text outputs, but it's only available in the EU because only they regulate this