r/london • • 23h ago

Rules restaurant: £11m site of London’s oldest restaurant given to the National Trust

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/national-trust-rules-restaurant-london-b3065997.html

34-35 Maiden Lane in Covent Garden has been home to Rules since 1798 and has seen high profile visitors from Charles Dickens, to Charlie Chaplin as well as Edward VII.

The National trust said the £11 million freehold gift would secure the future of the building.

267 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

73

u/lordnacho666 23h ago

Is the food any good? Never tried it despite being in the area quite often.

111

u/IcarusSupreme 22h ago

Yeah it actually is, I mean you have to like the British Classics Steak and Kidney Pie, Braised lamb that type of thing but for a long lunch with wine etc it's a very nice experience. espicially if you eating on someones expense account. Its worth a visit as a bucket list type of thing

I vaguely remember my syrup sponge being very nice.

47

u/Gisschace 22h ago edited 20h ago

I went a long time ago, early in my career, to meet a journalist with my boss, as it's popular with old-school journos who want a long lunch with lots of wine in exchange for press coverage. Fairly decent standard fair, I'd say.

1

u/lordnacho666 22h ago

Do they serve really old school stuff like pip and squeak?

47

u/Able_Resident_1291 22h ago

Do they serve really old school stuff like pip and squeak?

Do you mean bubble and squeak?

11

u/lordnacho666 22h ago

Yeah lol

13

u/produit1 22h ago edited 19h ago

Mainly known for their game meat menu

29

u/Tiny_ghosts_ 22h ago

I have been twice for special occasions, and enjoyed it. Was nice food and atmosphere and didn't feel pretentious, thought the food was alright portion sizes too (not tiny plates). Too expensive for me for a regular meal out, but I didn't feel ripped off for a special occasion meal. I wouldn't suggest it to anyone who doesn't eat meat though, that's definitely the focus/highlight of the menu. Idk if they still do it but I'm sure at one point I saw a set meal menu that they do that seemed fairly reasonable

24

u/Speedbird1A 22h ago edited 22h ago

Really good, old school fine dining (including the “silver” service, white table cloths, etc etc). Feels like stepping into history dining there. Highly recommended. English food done right. Get some good wine too.

Only thing to note is it isn’t cheap!

10

u/FinnemoreFan 21h ago

Yes, delicious, proper traditional British cooking. We went for our anniversary dinner earlier this year and had the roast beef for two - fantastic.

10

u/FelisCantabrigiensis 18h ago

Yes. They make no apologies for serving very traditional British food, particularly game, and they do it well. They also have a pretty good cocktail game even if the cocktail bar looks like it's from 1950 unchanged.

9

u/Curious_Ad1505 18h ago

Long may it remain looking unchanged from 1950.

4

u/Holiday_Cat_7284 19h ago

I went two months ago and it was excellent. It's not groundbreaking or innovative, or especially exciting, but it's solid, you know what you're getting and it's well cooked and presented.

9

u/DameKumquat 20h ago

It's very good in a rich classic way. I can't tolerate much saturated fat and made the mistake of ordering cream of stilton soup (excellent, but basically liquid Stilton) followed by something else in a creamy sauce. The game is what it's known for, so if you've always wanted to try jugged hare or pigeon pie, it's where to go.

Best when someone else is paying - the location and history are included in the pricing.

4

u/DDMFM26 21h ago

It's very good cookery of that old school style. Great fun place

2

u/bridgeport4 12h ago

I went years ago, with a friend’s parents, not realising at the time it’s an ‘institution’.

I found the food very average, maybe a bit bland and under seasoned. I was taken aback biting into an unexpected shot (partridge if I remember correctly) - not unheard off, I understand, but that’s my primary memory from that meal.

I’m glad for the experience, but not sure I’d go back.

1

u/Bullseye_Bailey 8h ago

Went about 3 weeks ago and didn't think too highly of it given the price, about £100 pp (2 drinks + 2 courses) above average but I'd expect better for that price.

0

u/yourefunny 19h ago

I went a few times about 20 years ago and it was fantastic! A wonderful experience. My most recent time was about 6 years ago and it had dropped off big time!!! Hoping it has improved since as I have a lot of lovely nostalgia for the place. The atmosphere and wine list alone is probably worth it.

-9

u/militantcentre 21h ago

Very mediocre and insanely expensive for what it is. Bit like the original Ivy.

-8

u/Hobbs16 19h ago

No - it's boring. We got taken there by a supplier and there wasn't a single thing I wanted and the thing I ended up with was bland as fuck.

21

u/ultra_phoenix 20h ago

genuinely a good deed from this person

4

u/Dry_Counter533 17h ago

Just looked it up on Google Maps … Voltaire lived across the street

10

u/VitaObscure 21h ago

Ooh I get 20% off with the National Trust I wonder if it would work here. 

16

u/MegTheMonkey 21h ago

It won’t. NT have already said no perks for members

11

u/Marnidd 19h ago

I believe they already have plans to install a massive 2 acre grass car park next to Rules and a gift shop

1

u/VitaObscure 19h ago

It's not a member perk, but I wasn't being entirely serious! 

-23

u/MyStackOverflowed 22h ago

gifted from whom

22

u/echocharlieone 22h ago

It's in the third sentence of the article.

10

u/victoriaspongebob 21h ago

For those who don't want to pay to remove the ads, or let the independent litter their phone with their shitty cookies: 

The home of London’s oldest restaurant has been donated to the National Trust.

The charity said the £11 million freehold gift of 34-35 Maiden Lane in Covent Garden, central London, which has housed Rules since 1798, would secure the future of a building where “kings dined and writers and politicians plotted”.

The donation, from the restaurant's owner of 40 years J-P Mayhew, also covers items such as visitor books, menus, caricatures, photographs, stained glass and signs.

The gift also includes the annual rent from the ongoing restaurant business which will go into conservation work each year.

Since opening as an oyster bar at the end of the 18th century, Rules has outlasted empires, survived the Blitz and plans for a dual carriageway, and welcomed generations of high-profile figures from Charles Dickens to Charlie Chaplin, as well as Edward VII, who would rendezvous with his mistresses there.

Its diners have also included Liza Minnelli, David Bowie, Harrison Ford and Madonna.

There are rooms named after poet John Betjeman, who gave an impassioned speech in defence of the restaurant and its “invisible atmosphere” when Maiden Lane was under threat of development, and writer Graham Greene, who had birthday meals there and featured it in his novel The End Of The Affair.

The trust described it as a “rare example of living heritage” where both the historic structure and the original use of the building – a restaurant – remain intact.

Its interior is very well preserved and has seen more than two centuries of continuous restaurant operation, which since the 19th century has maintained the tradition of English “country house” cuisine, the charity said.

Hilary McGrady, director-general of the National Trust, said: “This place is an outstanding piece of living history, with its corners where kings dined and writers and politicians plotted, and the traditions it kept alive through wars and upheaval.

“It has defied the odds to be standing here today, doors still open and treacle sponge still on the menu.

“Mr Mayhew’s extraordinary generosity, and the care he has poured into Rules over many decades, mean this beloved place has a future measured not in years but generations.

“His gift ensures that one of London’s great living institutions will remain part of the city’s cultural life, with all its stories, traditions and character intact.”

Mr Mayhew said: “There are few restaurants in the world that have endured the test of time like Rules.

“With many years of hard work, and some extraordinary strokes of luck, it has survived everything from redevelopment plans and changing tastes to the Blitz.

“When John Betjeman defended Rules from the GLC’s (Greater London Council) plans to turn the Strand into a dual carriageway in 1971, he spoke not only of the paintings, sculptures, stained glass and red plush seats, but of its ‘invisible atmosphere’.

“My gift to the National Trust is in answer to that appeal.

“The Trust will protect this place in a way that no-one else could, safeguarding its bricks and mortar, its famous interior and its invisible atmosphere, too.

“I am grateful to them for believing in this idea and for protecting this building and two centuries’ worth of stories for people to enjoy forever.”

The restaurant’s proprietor Ricky McMenemy, who has worked there for 35 years, will become a commercial tenant of the National Trust.

He welcomed the donation to the National Trust, saying: “As an independent business, it gives us both the security and peace of mind that our home will be in very good hands and be protected and secure going forward.

“Having already established a very amicable working relationship with the Trust, we look forward to another two centuries in this, our home.”

While the National Trust cares for 39 historic pubs which continue to operate today, from the George Inn in Southwark to the Crown Bar in Belfast, 34-35 Maiden Lane will be the first building in the charity’s care to house an historic restaurant that is still in operation, it said.

5

u/LochNessMother 20h ago

This makes me slightly teary. Genuinely good news in the face of all the terrible stuff happening in the world.

-5

u/MyStackOverflowed 21h ago

I don't have time to read all that