r/cookware • • Jun 16 '25

𝐌𝐮𝐬𝐭 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝 BEFORE making a post, please read here first!

25 Upvotes

Welcome to r/cookware ! We hope this will be a helpful place with many informational resources.

Before making a post, please make sure to read our rules as well as our Wiki.

We encourage you to ask questions, but please know that if your question falls within the many commonly asked questions explained in these posts, it will be removed.

Lately, we've seen a lot of questions asking for help identifying pans. In most cases, they are older nonstick pans. Here’s a quick guide to the three top materials we recommend — durable enough to last a lifetime with proper care — plus tips on how to identify them as well as some advice on nonstick pans.

🔳 1. Carbon Steel

  • Weight: Lighter than cast iron, but still fairly heavy.
  • Color: Usually medium to dark gray, may develop a black patina over time, or sometimes a blueish tint if "blue carbon steel."
  • Surface: Smooth but not glossy. Often looks seasoned or discolored.
  • Handle: Often riveted and long.
  • Key test: Magnetic. Looks like cast iron’s smoother cousin.

Tell-tale signs: Smooth, dark surface with some seasoning marks, feels heavy but thinner than cast iron.

⚫ 2. Cast Iron

  • Weight: Very heavy.
  • Color: Matte black (if seasoned); rough surface texture.
  • Surface: Bumpy or grainy feel (unless polished).
  • Handle: Often one solid piece with a helper handle opposite.
  • Key test: Magnetic. Often very thick walls and bottom.

Tell-tale signs: Extremely heavy, rough textured, looks like an old-school pan or something you’d use over a campfire.

🪞3. Stainless Steel

  • Weight: Moderate.
  • Color: Shiny silver inside and out.
  • Surface: Completely smooth and polished.
  • Handle: Riveted or welded, often metal and may have brand stamping.
  • Key test: May or may not be magnetic, depending on construction.

Tell-tale signs: Bright, shiny, reflective, and sleek — looks like what chefs use in restaurants.

🍳 4. Nonstick

  • Weight: Light to moderate.
  • Color: Inside is black, gray, white,

orange

  • or speckled. Outside varies.
  • Surface: Super smooth, slippery feel.
  • Handle: Often plastic or silicone-coated.
  • Key test: Fingernail or utensil glides easily; may say "Teflon" or "nonstick" on the bottom.

Tell-tale signs: Very slick surface, often looks brand new unless scratched; light in hand. When older, will be discoloured and scratched.

If you have an unidentified pan laying around that does not work as well as it once did (aka food is sticking more), you likely have a nonstick pan (especially if it was cheap).


r/cookware • • Feb 25 '25

𝐌𝐮𝐬𝐭 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝 How to make a sufficient "Seeks specific kitchenware" post!

12 Upvotes

Introduction

We receive endless repetitions of the same questions on this subreddit. This guide is to be referred to, whenever there is an obvious case of the user making a really insufficient low effort post, which could easily be avoided by reading the subreddit rules or this guide.

How to ask for which cookware to buy!

If you want to buy and/or learn about kitchenware and especially stovetop cookware you have come to the right place! However, it will vastly improve the experience of everyone involved if a minimal effort (which BTW includes useing an appropriate tag) is put into your post!

The more relevant information you include in your "Seek specific kitchenware" request the better for everyone including you, as you will get better advice and cookware recommendations in return.

It is completely allowed to request buying recommendations towards everything kitchen related, like mortar and pestle, mixers, blenders, ovens, tableware whatever, when using the "Seek specific kitchenware" tag but if the post is about stovetop cookware then there is also certain expectations that should be met.

Important stovetop cookware information includes:
The type of stove being used! Is it gas, induction, electric flattop, exposed coil stove?
The Budget! Self explanatory.
Location! are you from USA? Canada? EU? UK? At least the it be known in some way.

If you want a very quick overview of the subreddit or is just curious here is a link to our welcome page :)

If you are scared to make a cookware post, or simply want to learn more about cookware first, we highly recommend you to read the official cookware guide (which includes recommendations) first!

(There is still things not covered in the guide, like the exact cookware weights, asthetics and barely ergonomics, so questions about cookware are still letimate end encouraged even after having read the guide, the guide does however cover pretty much everything else, which is supricingly many important things so it's worth a read, but is entirely optional but needless to say also highly recommended.)

Two examples of improper low effort posts

Post 1:

Q: "Hello! I want the BEST frypan ever made, my budget is secret and I refuse to disclose my type of stove"

A: Well, congratulations! Here is an equally arbitrary recommendation: Solid silver cookware!

Post 2: (based on a true story)

Q: "Which is best, this random garbage or this random very expensive option? Oh you tell me that the cheap option is bad? okay which other cheap option to buy then!?! BTW screw the other option I just mentioned and the helpful comments as well, I'm just gonna waste everyone’s time!"

A real life example of an excellent post

The example below is taken from here: https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1q6i9od/comment/ny7xgaq/?context=1

"First of all I apologise if this is a redundant question, but after spending an hour or so looking through other subs, I haven't found the exact info I'm looking for. I have a glasstop range (not induction). I'm wanting to replace my entire cookware set to get away from non-stick. I've been experimenting with carbon steel and thinking about moving more toward stainless. The problem I'm having with carbon steel is that it warps and spins on my cook top which also leads to uneven heating of the pan. Once it cools off, the carbon steel returns to "flat". I have tried slow pre-heating and all that, but when the carbon steel pan hits 275 degrees F it starts to "bowl up".

So I guess the question I have is will I have the same issue with stainless? I'm ok with spending some money on the D5 stainless if that will solve this issue. I just don't want to spend the $$ for All-Clad or Made In etc if it will have the same issues.....I really just wish I had a gas stove.

Thanks!"

A post like this is almost guaranteed to get really good recommendations from people in the subreddit, even in unlikely cases where no helpful reply is made, I will personally help out with guidance :)

Again please consider taking at least a quick look at our official guide the Cookware Buying and Explanation Guide, before asking for a new pan, as it would likely be able to answer all your questions and definitely assist you in making a better one! You don't even have to read all of it, just the relevant sections of it!

Other types of non-allowed posts!

Posts which breaks the subreddit rules! Like the rules against asking for "How to clean and/or is my non-stick pan ruined" posts!

For your convenience a link to how to fully clean and restore your stainless steel cookware is right here: Stainless steel care and first help

And to repeat! Posts requesting stovetop cookware recommendations that neither includes a budget, location or a stove type will be considered low effort and a big waste of everyone's time and will most certainly be reported and taken down!

Making a crappy "Seek Specific Kitchenware" type post but using a wrong tag, possibly in an attempt to avoid the no low effort post rule will absolutely not work!

Posts that are generally low effort, but also uses completely wrong tag as well, especially blatant abuse of the "Cookware Review" tag will result in takedown + possibly an angry mod message, as posts like that makes the subreddit much worse for people looking for genuine reviews and not low effort garbage!

Remember that this is a kind and close knit community, where we respect each other, including each others time! Because of this, time wasting low effort posts are not welcome! If you want to post low effort posts in a less moderated place, I suggest that you go to a place like 4chan.

My post got taken down

There should most likely be an attached reason for why the post got taken down, if the post was not harmful, and didn’t unredeemably break any rules, then feel free to edit and improve your post and try again :)

If you dispute the reason for the post take down, and have valid arguments for that the takedown allegedly was a mistake on our behalf, then feel free to contact us in the mod-chat, and we will be open to work something out, possibly including putting your post back up! It's rare but has happened before, sometimes we makes mistakes too.

Of critical importance!

For your own sake and directly on behalf of the entire mod-team and r/cookware as well: If you haven't already please view the subreddit rules which on the Reddit app is found here:

I am sorry for the rules being near impossible to find, but that’s just how the Reddit App is!

And on the desktop is found by scrolling down here:

Also read the subreddit description on the picture as well.

Thank you for reading and, welcome to r/cookware! And BTW your posts doesn't have to be perfect, just good enough for us to know that you tried :D


r/cookware • • 1h ago

Cleaning Anyone have any tips to fix my wok, hasnt been used for over 6 years

Post image
• Upvotes

Pretty much the title, I inherited it a long time ago and never got to using it but now I wanna use it but I dont know how to get rid of the rust.

I would very much appreciate any help


r/cookware • • 12h ago

Cooking/appreciation A new pop of color in the kitchen!

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/cookware • • 9h ago

Cleaning How to reseal/fix this vintage scooper?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I’ve had this ice cream scooper since I was a kid- 20+ years old at least, they don’t make them like this anymore and I absolutely adore it. I think someone put it through the dishwasher and it went from a bright shiny silver to this dull and mottled dark grey. The texture is also unpleasant to touch.
After checking out some posts I think this is aluminum? Any tips on getting it fixed without damaging it? I read boiling it in water + vinegar and then scrubbing with barkeeper’s friend - just hoped to get some advice before I tackle this. I really want to save this item!


r/cookware • • 6h ago

Seeks specific kitchenware I’m looking for a 4 by 3 muffin pan with silicon removable cup, help plz.

2 Upvotes

My GF bought one for her mom for Mother’s Day back in 2010 and neither of us can find anything like it now.

I’d like to get one for her but it for real seems like something made up despite the fact I’ve personally seen the one she got for her mom.

Any help would be awesome.


r/cookware • • 15h ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Advice for stainless steel cookware

5 Upvotes

recommendations for 10" & 12" stainless steel frying pan and 4 quart sauté pan. would like to know your choice brand(s), name of a collection line,etc. this is the first time buying. i cook daily and enjoy creating meals my family enjoy and trying new recipes. I have had non stick and ceramic over the years. I want to get rid of anything with microplastics, or a surface that scratches and particles of coating mixing with food etc..and items that will last a lifetime. Let me know your personal pros and cons as well. Thanks in advance. EDIT - I prefer a flatter bottom especially in a sauté pan. Some designs have a more curved up edge. Not sure if I’m making sense


r/cookware • • 19h ago

Looking for Advice What do you wish someone told you about stainless steel before purchasing your first set?

8 Upvotes

I’m in the market for new cookware and I’m looking at a Tramontina try ply clad set. my husband was initially against stainless but he’s willing to give it a try. From what I’ve read about it so far, there’s a learning curve. And I really don’t want to ruin my new set or our food before we figure it out. as I said, I’ve done my research but here I’m looking for the “I wish someone would’ve told me this“ tips and tricks.


r/cookware • • 10h ago

Discussion Hestan Nanobond good deal

1 Upvotes

Got a relatively good deal for the 11 inch nanobond pan, I’ve been on the fence about getting it for a while because of price, so this is what I did:

Right now capital one shopping has a Macy’s deal, spend $200 get $100 back through gift cards.

On top of this, I called Macy’s after, gave them my order number, and they were able to remove ~15% off the purchase.

So after tax my purchase was $386.05, with -$55 from calling Macy’s and -$100 from the capital one shopping, for a total net price of $231. Anyways, thought I’d share if anyone else was interested.


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Looking for Advice MadeIn discoloration and blotches

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

I recently bought pans from MadeIn and most of them show heavy discoloration and blotches after the first use. I had steel pans before and never ran into this. Is it normal for pans to turn into what you can see in the photog's after one time use?

One pan is now yellowish and the other has those wierd blotches.

Thanks :)

Edit:

Thanks all. I'm just dumb and new to stainless steel pans.


r/cookware • • 16h ago

Looking for Advice Is it a bad idea to donate used Teflon pans?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/cookware • • 18h ago

Looking for Advice What are these cracks/holes with dried liquid

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I recently got a new baking dish, and now it has started showing these little cracks where it releases a darkish liquid.

Is it still safe to use, and what could cause this? It has only been used 3 times, and never above 220Celsius


r/cookware • • 22h ago

Discussion Breville toaster oven colorful models

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/cookware • • 22h ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Looking for Older Brand Indentity

Post image
0 Upvotes

Solved by ElCochinoFeo, identifying them as Baumstal. Thank you!

Original Post

Please allow me to preface this with: I did read through the rules and guides and I didn't see anything that prohibited this sorta post. Personally, I think it basically falls under the category of "Seeks specific kitchenware" since I am hoping the brand is still around.

The Context

My parents bought a set of pots and pans ~35-45 years ago when they were at their first house. As my mother tells it, it was a door-to-door salesperson type of purchase. The paperwork for them is long gone and the only branding on them is a simple logo I've been unable to identify. These pots and pans have lasted all these years in, I think, fantastic condition, used on both gas and electric stoves and only showing their age, not poor quality. However, they've finally met their match: induction. Though I'm pretty sure I could easily get another decade or more out of them, our new stove is induction and will not work with any of them.

The Question

Does anyone know what brand this logo on the pots is? If so, are they still in business and make quality induction-safe sets?


r/cookware • • 22h ago

Looking for Advice Is it worth buying the Demeyere Atlantis saute pan?

Thumbnail
zwilling.com
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm looking to replace my non stick cookware with stainless steel and I've worked out for the cooking I do (often curries, stews, one pot dishes for 4 portions at a time, some frying, using several times a week) the saute would be ideal first piece to get with its versatility.

I wanted to buy the demeyere Atlantis 28cm saute pan as the best out there (reviewing recommendations here) but at £389 I'm having second thoughts if it's worth the investment.

I'm based in the UK and have a gas stove (in several years may change to induction).

Others have said for those moving to stainless steel it might be better to get a cheaper pan first. Does anyone have the demeyere and can recommend? Or is there a cheaper alternative that would work just as well. I did see the recommendation list but not sure which specifically relate to saute pans. Thank you!


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Use/test based review Oven Dish or Stovetop Pot? // Pirofila da forno o Pentola da fornelli?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/cookware • • 1d ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Oven Dish or Stovetop Pot? // Pirofila da forno o Pentola da fornelli?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/cookware • • 1d ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Help me build my set

1 Upvotes

After 8 years with our All-Clad HA, which we were led to believe had a lifetime warranty, we're in the market. I want to go stainless steel and lean into the BIFL mentality. I've done an ungodly amount of research and spent way too much time over the last week scouring this reddit, watching youtube comparison videos, reading independent testing blogs, and I'm still left with more uncertainty than answers. I'm pretty sure chatGPT has even told me to just pick something already and leave it alone.

We're a family of 5 with 2 teenaged boys in the US, so we need reasonably sized cookware. Our most frequently used pieces out of our non-stick set are the 4qt saute for most dinners and the 8" frypan for eggs. We have a powerful gas stove which we have no intentions of ever replacing. We do a lot of meat and one-pot dinners.

After recommendations from other posts, I found a used Falk Signature 28cm Rondeau that will likely be our most-used piece. I also purchased Mafter and Strata carbon steels to compare for eggs and whatnot. I already have an enameled dutch oven and a smallish le creuset cast iron skillet that we'll keep in our rotation. I'm looking for opinions to fill in the rest. Our budget is flexible but I'm also trying not to go overboard. I'd rather get the right pans for our use case, but would like to stay closer to $1,000ish to build out the below...luckily there should be some good sales within the next 6 weeks.

I'll likely get either a viking or tramontina 8qt stockpot, since this doesn't need to be fancy. I use our current 8qt 3-4 times per year so not a commonly used piece for me.

I'm between a 2 and 3 qt saucier, mostly for rice, boxed mac n cheese, ramen, gravies & sauces, etc. I like the Demeyere Industry 5 or Heritage Steel for this, but am also considering a Fissler m5 saucepan instead.

I also want a 4-5qt saucepan for soups and boiling pasta. I'm leaning toward the Fissler M5 but could easily be persuaded.

I think we'll also need a larger 12"+ frypan. I mostly use the saute pan as it is, but I do occasionally need more room. I'm looking at Industry 5 or Heritage Steel for this as well. Should I get a smaller 8/10" stainless steel on top of the carbon steel?

Lastly, I'm debating if it would also be worth getting a 5+ qt sauteuse/essentials pan/chef's pan. I like the idea of the rounded edges for mixing pastas, but it's definitely not a "need" and is likely redundant. Maybe the Hestan Probond for this? Or All-Clad.

Is there any other piece that you've found necessary in your own set-ups? I'm struggling with not having a matching set aethetically, but I understand the logic behind it. Help me make good decisions!


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Identification Help identifying non stick vs carbon steel pizza pans

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hello!

These pans were a gift from my mom. I've taken awful care of them and am now trying to do better. Are they carbon steel or non stick?

They're lightweight, and I assumed they came as pre seasoned carbon steel. I thought I'd scrubbed the seasoning off where it's rusting, but am now wondering if I should toss them if they're non stick. I don't see any chipping coating exactly just more maybe scrubbed through?

Thank you for your help!


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Identification Need Help ID’ing This

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hey friends - I tried google reverse searching but haven’t had any success, so this is my last shot here.

My mom has favorite pot she uses for cooking. Unfortunately my 1 year old got into her kitchen and got into her cabinets and dropped the glass lid for the pot. Luckily he’s ok and she still loves him lol, but she’s also extremely saddened that the lid shattered.

I want to try to make it up to her and see if I can buy her a replacement lid or a replacement pot/lid, but I just can’t seem to find it. There’s no indication on what brand this is which is making it that much harder.

I’m hoping maybe there’s a small chance someone has come across this and can identify the brand or at least point me in the right direction?

Thank you!


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Discussion New Our Place Titanium Construction

0 Upvotes

Our Place just released a revamp of their Always Pan Pro titanium line. The pans are different from the construction for their earlier titanium cookware, which they're now calling "1.0". There's still a titanium interior, aluminum core, and stainless steel exterior, but the look and texture of the interior are completely different.

Does anyone have insight into what's changed and why? Maybe this is a titanium plasma construction, similar to the Viking PureGlide Pro and others? Or somewhere in between plasma and the texture they used to have?

https://fromourplace.com/collections/titanium-cookware

Edit: what’s with all the downvotes? I get that Our Place isn’t popular on here. I’m not recommending these pans, which only became available this week. I’m trying to understand how they compare to other options on the market.

Edit 2: what a strange launch, there doesn't appear to be any Our Place announcement and the product pages have photos of both the old and new pan constructions. The description on the website says the benefit of the update is easier cleaning and nothing else, while a Kenji video mentions better durability and nonstick. That seems contradictory, and it also appears to validate concerns about the durability of the old construction.


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Looking for Advice Is this a good deal (CAD)?

0 Upvotes

Someone at my work posted this for sale. I have seen mixed reviews for All Clad D3 but I'm wondering if its worth it for the price! What is everyones experience with D3? We are moving to a new house and are debating on replacing the electric stove with induction.

Thanks everyone!


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Looking for Advice Just got my first “serious” pan, Cuisinart MCP, can I cook on high heat?

0 Upvotes

Until now I’ve used a super cheap “stainless steel” (in quotes as I’m not sure what exactly it is, seeing as the surface is black), some nonstick, and an old enameled cast iron.

I enjoy high heat cooking. But I’m concerned about warping the pan. Is this something to be worried about? Is there anything I can do to mitigate it and still cook on high heat?

I don’t have much money to spend on cookware, and live in a dorm (limited space), so I’d prefer to make this last as long as possible and not have to buy anything else. If warping is genuinely a high risk, should I just return this and get something more resistant to it? Also worth noting that I’m in the UK.


r/cookware • • 1d ago

Looking for Advice Stock pot- Worth Spending More?

1 Upvotes

Hi there! I'm looking to gradually replace my non stick cookware with stainless steel. I've read the useful sub guide with buying recommendations.

For the frying pan it seems worth spending extra for the quality and go for Demeyere but am I right for a large stockpot (26cm diameter) it's not worth spending that much?

I was looking at this one from ProCook but I read not being fully clad is a disadvantage. Is this a good choice? Fyi I am UK based and have a gas hob (though may change to induction in a couple of years). I use the stockpot for soups , curries etc (batch cooking for family).

https://www.procook.co.uk/product/newprocook-professional-steel-stockpot-lid-26cm-95l?cq_src=google_ads&cq_cmp=21344371804&cq_term=&cq_plac=&cq_net=g&cq_plt=gp&nbt=nb%3Aadwords%3Ag%3A21344371804%3A165432026840%3A700954055884&nb_adtype=pla&nb_kwd=&nb_ti=pla-295999096974&nb_mi=127414221&nb_pc=online&nb_pi=6329&nb_ppi=295999096974&nb_placement=&nb_si={sourceid}&nb_li_ms=&nb_lp_ms=&nb_fii=&nb_ap=&nb_mt=&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21344371804&gbraid=0AAAAAD3uHvkl4m7J0JuiZ3V8DpAI3cyFw&gclid=CjwKCAjw0LzWBhBOEiwAKQd0cNHCM1roUZT6QDdaTQTOeWMEeG4xCt3el-N0nsfjULS0Hwl5UcaVUxoCmtUQAvD_BwE

Any advice/recommendations would be greatly appreciated


r/cookware • • 2d ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Concord Vortex (105k btu) or Concord Stronghold 16" drop-in (270k btu) for wok stir fry?

1 Upvotes

The stronghold is half the price of the vortex (150$ vs 300$) with more than twice the btu's. Is the vortex better for a carbon steel wok or is the brute force of the banjo burner on the Stronghold a better choice?

Vortex: https://a.co/d/0fcmW7Qf

Stronghold: https://a.co/d/0dQ2g13Q