Hey all! So I'm looking for advice. I'm traveling to shoot a "talking head" in a huge event space that has a lot of diffused light coming in from various high windows on the sides. I have a small 3-person crew, and will be renting a lot of grip there, but bringing my lighting kit (1 Amaran 600x, 1 Amaran 300x, 2 220's and 2 150 fabric panels)
We want the shoot to look very natural, as the space is really pretty as-is. I'll likely use a bank of windows to motivate the key light, so I want a key that is large and soft, with a gentle ratio for fill. I also don't want to create a huge setup, as we will need to move it around the space throughout the day. So I'm considering three options:
A 5 foot Light Dome on my 300x, and either bounce a little fill in, or use one of the 150s. One stand, easy setup.
A "one stand" book light, using the 300x (or 600x if needed) directed up into an angled 4x4' ultrabounce, then through a 6x6 silk. (Might need 2 stands if the 6x6' feels too heavy).
An "Umbrella Book Light". This is something I've seen set up on YouTube, but I just don't know how much I trust the sources... Basically it's just using a 6' umbrella instead of the the ultrabounce, but then still pushing through a scrim. It looks light and easy to move.
As the space is large and very evenly lit, I will use an 8x8' commando rag as negative fill on the fill side, and probably another to block out the actual window light, so my key will be doing the actual work. I know don't know if I'll be able to rely on the daylight being consistent.
I'm not super concerned with spill, as the space is just vast, and there aren't any walls behind the subject for a long ways. I imagine a book light might still need to be controlled a bit on the background side.
Soooo... my real question is about the key light - what do you recommend between a large dome, a book light setup, or the umbrella? Is it worth it to go tot he extra effort on a single, seated subject, or it is overkill?
I've done a fair share of corporate interviews, but limited time and crew usually leads me in the dome direction. I have a chance to make a choice now based on what will give me the prettiest and most natural feeling setup, and I want to take it.
And to be fully honest, I don't want to do anything that will make the client think "what is this rinky dink setup" - hence my hesitation about the umbrella. But in the end, what works is what works.
THANK YOU for your input!