r/bobdylan • u/ddiamond8484 • 2h ago
Misc. Carnegie Hall Nina + Field of Cops stopped me dead in my tracks while I was buying cat food at Ralph’s
Bob Dylan changed my life. He was my first concert, I learned guitar and harmonica to his songs, I was obsessed in high school to the point where people still associate me with him. I cannot stand “the next Dylan” comparisons. They’re basically always completely misguided and ridiculous, especially considering there’s like 50 different Dylan’s within his own discography! I don’t think anyone is the next Dylan, and I don’t think it’s declared for any other reason than to sell magazines and tickets. Now all that said, I posted this in the Cameron Winter forum and it recommended I post it here to, so I guess that’s what I’m doing?
When I was a sophomore in high school, 2000, I was in honors English and walking to class listening to Dylan's greatest hits volume 2 that my dad gave me, I was still pretty new to him. "A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall" came on and it stopped me in my tracks, and I just sat on some school steps (so my CD player wouldn't skip), gobsmacked by what I was hearing. When it ended I remember thinking "class has nothing to teach me" cause we were learning Chaucer's Canterbury's Tales or some shit, and I just left school and walked home. It was one of those Wizard of Oz black and white to color moments for me, you know?
I know I've had many of those since, but that one stands out, because I'd never heard anything like it before. Yesterday I was walking in Ralphs looking for cat food and Nina + Field of Cops from the live album came on and I had a similar moment/feeling. Just stopped dead in my tracks, staring at some friskies in a trance, blown away by what I was hearing. I love the album version, it’s one of my favorites and blew my mind when I first heard it. I’ve sung its praises many times here and to anyone that knows me- this one sounded next level, and just knowing how wild it is that the frontman for a band with a whole different sound managed to sell out Carnegie Hall after only a year of a solo piano shows for a strange sounding album, and get a film made and released by PT Anderson…it’s just fucking bonkers. And it isn't easy to let quiet notes linger like he does for some of the songs!
Anyway, just wanted to share that. What’s funny is I am such a massive fan, and I love his live stuff, but it can definitely feel a bit samey. I saw him at the Barnsdall Park theater like a month after heavy metal came out, and was so fucking excited, and I fell asleep during one of the songs cause it sounded too similar to others and the acoustics weren’t great.
So much of the magic comes from the arrangements and quirks, IMO- the song I fell asleep to was (maybe the debut?) of Long Island City Here I Come, which is one of my very favorite songs on Getting Killed, but hearing it solo piano at the time was just hard to hear the lyrics and felt monotonous.
But a year of touring nonstop has shown how much he’s leveled up- this is worlds away from that January 2025 show, and he was fantastic then.
Ok rant over.