r/WoT • u/Gorillaz65Yonder • 5h ago
The Shadow Rising I think I finally understand why the Rhuidean and Tanchico storylines belong in the same book Spoiler
Finished The Shadow Rising and something occurred to me that made me appreciate the Tanchico chapters a lot more.
Rand goes into Rhuidean and discovers that practically everything the Aiel believe about their own history is backwards. They're a warrior culture descended from people who refused to fight. They despise the Tinkers, who actually preserved the Way of the Leaf their ancestors abandoned.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the world, Egeanin is discovering that sul'dam aren't fundamentally different from the women they've spent their lives keeping on leashes.
These are two societies whose entire understanding of honor depends on a distinction that turns out to be false.
For the Aiel, it's the difference between honorable warriors and contemptible people who refuse to fight. For the Seanchan, it's the difference between respectable women who control the Power and dangerous women who must be controlled.
And in both cases, the people who learn the truth have a very good reason to wish they hadn't.
What I find particularly interesting is how differently the revelations happen.
The Aiel have an entire sacred place dedicated to confronting their history. Their leaders have been carrying this knowledge for generations, even though it apparently destroys some of the people who encounter it.
Egeanin, on the other hand, discovers something that her society has absolutely no mechanism for admitting. There's no honorable way for her to process this information within the system she has spent her life serving.
It also made her character much more interesting to me. She's not some cartoonishly cruel Seanchan officer. She's capable of being reasonable and even decent to people, which makes watching her question her beliefs more uncomfortable. She has participated in something terrible without ever having to think of herself as a terrible person.
I went into this book expecting the big revelations to be about Rand and the Dragon Reborn. I wasn't expecting so much of it to be about what happens when people find out the stories their cultures tell about themselves aren't true.
Maybe I'm reading too much into the parallel, but I genuinely think these two plotlines make each other better.
Please keep discussion to book 4. I'm starting The Fires of Heaven next.