For context/background: I’m in my late 30s and I’ve just moved here from the US about 6 months ago, so I began my first UK teaching role in September. I taught in the US starting in the early 2010s, then took a few years off to work in non-profits and get a masters degree in education. I taught again for a few years before moving into an Edtech role within a school, and eventually working for edtech companies, which I did remotely until this summer.
All that is to say, I have a diverse background with a range of experiences inside and outside of the classroom. I’m also a parent, so I have that perspective as well. Finally, I look very young - I always have - probably mid- to late-twenties so it’s always been difficult for people to take me seriously and trust my authority.
Here’s what I’m struggling with: I’m not sure if my current school is just not right for me, or if teaching in the UK in general is not the right move.
I am teaching at a school that’s an hour commute in each direction. The behavior of this particular year group is terrible and everyone in the school knows it. I was prepared for that. However, I had ZERO onboarding or prep before the first day of school. I was able to get into my classroom to set up and I was given a vague curriculum map, but I didn’t have any logins for curriculum resources until week 2, wasn’t told about the dozens of school traditions and norms (like requirements about notebook colors for various subjects or specific headings or markings, etc) and I had to find out by being told constantly I was doing things the wrong way by my students or HLTA.
I thought this would dissipate as the weeks went on and I became more confident in the (very specific) way the school operated, but six weeks in I’m still constantly getting corrected, told I’m going things the wrong way, and being monitored. My HLTA is older than me and has been at the school for a long time, so I respect that she knows a lot about the school. However she’s is always interrupting my lessons to correct me or yell at the students for talking or getting distracted. It makes me feel so inadequate and uncomfortable. She’ll say things like “you should really be using a ruler to underline your date on the whiteboard” or “shouldn’t the students be lining up now?” when I’m clearly finishing up what I’m saying to the class.
My partner teacher has also been at the school for a long time so I respect her, but the constant criticism and feedback is really starting to make me feel like I don’t know what I’m doing.
As an aside, my teaching philosophy is rooted in students’ well being and helping the whole child grow. That means ensuring they are happy, healthy, socially responsible and included, as well as teaching them content. I truly don’t mind a little chatter and some silliness here and there, as long as they’re getting their work done and participating in lessons. But my HLTA and partner teacher are constantly yelling at the students for talking and being too loud (they’re 9 and 10, of course they’re going to need reminding about indoor voices but they just talk loudly). I even took a break with them to let them ask me some questions about America once, and they were laughing and having fun, and my TA just yelled at them for being too loud and sort of scolded me for causing the noise. Also little things like the fact that I like softer lighting and absolutely despise overhead lights (they’re so overstimulating and harsh!) so I try to keep at least a few off and let the natural light be our main source of light through the windows. My TA and partner teacher are constantly walking in and just turning the lights all the way on and it’s like - I thought this was my classroom!
The other thing that really makes me hate teaching here is the expectations of perfection and almost being a drill sergeant instead of a caring, down-to-earth teacher. I’m just the kind of person who has never taken life or myself too seriously. Part of the reason I became a teacher was because I was inspired by passionate, caring and fun teachers that I had in my childhood. They made learning fun and I still remember the topics we covered while playing games, singing songs, creating art and participating in fun projects. I would absolutely hate school if I had to sit still all day, listening to a teacher talk at me and then continue to sit quietly while I filled out worksheets. Is this the expectation everywhere in primary schools here in England?
I’ve been scolded for letting students turn in ClassDojo points to come to my classroom at lunch for a lunch club. I’ve been scolded for letting students come to my classroom after school (with the aftercare leader’s permission) to help me clean the room and set up for the next day. I’ve been scolded for pulling a student aside and having a discussion with her because she was crying (“you’re fine, you should go back to your seat, you have work to do” is what my colleague said to her, then turned to me and said “if you let them do that once they’ll come to you all the time and just whine about everything”) and my TA and colleague step in to quiet my class or get them in line when I was just about to do the same. Again, I just don’t think it’s that serious if a student or two are whispering a bit or if they giggle about something quietly, because they’re human. I mean, how many of us teachers whisper or get distracted during staff meetings/inset days?? But I think my TA and colleagues assume I CAN’T control my students so they step in and demand silence.
Today my students were going outside for a brief movement break before an assembly where they’d have to sit for a while. I was walking them out when I was stopped by the office manager and asked a question. About 5 of my students made it outside before me, and of course my partner teacher was right there and said I really can’t let them outside without me, it’s a safeguarding issue, etc. I was right there, and they were running out onto the back playground area that is completely fenced in and I could see them. I take safeguarding very seriously but it’s all the little things that keep getting picked at, and often it feels like I can’t do anything right and I’m constantly being reminded of the rules as if I don’t know them.
Am I being too sensitive? Is this just not the right school for me, or is this how most UK primary schools will be, even if I move? The best part of teaching in the US was being able to close my classroom door and just TEACH. I made up songs about topics they were learning, we had class meetings where we got to know each other, we went outside on nice days and took our work with us, and they learned a lot and grew as humans. At my school now, I feel like I’m constantly under a microscope and I have to just “stick to the script”, keep the students silent at their desks throughout the day, keep them silent in the halls, and never let them get too close or comfortable with me.
Sorry for the novel. If you’ve made it this far, any advice from experienced teachers welcome!