r/Sherlock • • Jan 27 '20

Discussion Season 5. The facts. Is it coming?

1.5k Upvotes

No. It is not.

There has been no confirmation of Season 5 from any official, credible, or well-known source.

Do not believe everything you read.

There has been an influx of posts recently. An article is going around claiming that Sherlock Season 5 will be released in 2022. This is, as far as we know, not true. (EDIT: It's now 2024. It wasn't true.) There is no reason that some random small news outlets would get their hands on this, without any of the larger ones covering it. Nothing has been announced or confirmed by the BBC, the writers of the show, or the actors.

Please don't share links that you don't think are credible sources. However, we do look at reports, and we are removing any links that are posted with fake claims to Season 5.

If Season 5 is ever announced, there will be a stickied post, just like this one. It will be regularly updated with all new news, what we know, popular theories, etc. However, that day may never come.

Thank you all for keeping the subreddit as active as possible. Keep on posting your fanart, theories, memes, cosplays, and discussions as much as you like! :)


r/Sherlock • • 4h ago

Image Was doing some deep diving regarding Sherlock’s interpreted asexuality, and found this article… and it bothered me a bit

Post image
13 Upvotes

Link to article: https://femmagazine.com/asexuality-sherlocks-biggest-mystery/

If this has been discussed before a lot forgive me because I’m very new to this show and its fanbase. I just saw this and it was pretty important for me to talk about.

I’m someone who considers myself to be asexual. For me, I don’t care much for sex, I rarely think about it unless the subject is brought up to me, and I’ve never really looked at someone and desired to be with them that way.

Unfortunately in fiction there’s hardly any sort of representation for asexuality. The most notable representation for asexuality that exists is Todd Chavez from Bojack Horseman, who even had a coming out scene. There’s also Jughead Jones but they completely removed that from the CW show while it was canon in the original comics.

Sherlock Holmes could easily be among the few asexual characters we have. He’s an incredibly iconic fictional character, and we see evidence of his asexuality very consistently. But it kind of pisses me off seeing that Steven Moffat himself had the gall to straight up call it “boring.” That’s literally insulting to all the asexuals out there, because he’s literally saying the concept of asexuality is boring. Why does Sherlock need to get it on with someone else for the story to be more interesting? It’s already plenty interesting enough to see Sherlock being his own funny self and solving cases. The show is already fun and interesting as it is. I’m sure there’s people out there who want to see him get with someone, but if they want it that bad they should look somewhere else, as the heart of this show is supposed to be Sherlock solving big mysteries and puzzles, with some important emotional background plots.

Benedict Cumberbatch did also say in an interview how he believes Sherlock just suppresses his sex drive and that it’s not asexuality. But the truth is asexuals can actually still have a sex drive. Sherlock could have a suppressed sex drive and still be asexual. Both could be perfectly true. Asexuality is the lack of attraction directed at one person. Sex drive is the biological urge for sex itself. A person who experiences sexual attraction could have a low libido, but that doesn’t take away from their sexual attraction to the person. Libido has more to do with the hormones, and asexuality is not a hormonal thing. Same way being gay isn’t hormonal. It’s just how the person is, and what their preferences are.

An asexual however also has all the normal hormones with various levels of it just like anyone else. The only difference between asexuals and anyone else in that regard is how they act on sex and with who. Some asexuals might act on it with someone for the sake of doing it if they have a high libido, but it will still have nothing to do with the sexual attractiveness of the person they’re doing it with.


r/Sherlock • • 1d ago

Image The Jim Moriarty is a better adaptation then professor James Moriarty. ( from the books)

Post image
552 Upvotes

It's a bit hot take or a personal preference but to me jim moriarty makes more sense than the literature one. cause the only thing separate jim from sherlock is the people he's around not mortality or code. in the classic one james Moriarty was set as opposite of sherlock. like his evil version. Where in the series jim is definitely evil. but he has lack of sanity. and i think it should be the only key difference. the people around sherlock actually gives him his identity. so it's fascinate when moriarty says in last "you are not ordinary you are like me. " so i think he sees a mirror of himself.

what do you think let me know??


r/Sherlock • • 9h ago

Discussion I'm introducing the Sherlock series to my friend. Should I skip the episode "The Hounds of Baskerville"?

0 Upvotes

Sherlock is one of my favorite series, but I find this episode very uninteresting and I don't want to give that impression to my friend who is just starting the series. We already skipped "The Blink Banker," should we skip this one too?


r/Sherlock • • 2d ago

Image Unearthed

Post image
45 Upvotes

Just dug out some sheet music. Totally forgot I had this.


r/Sherlock • • 3d ago

Discussion I think one of the most telling parts of Sherlock’s neurodivergence is the fact that he kept John around mostly to info dump to him and I love to see it

71 Upvotes

Not to say he didn’t find John useful with actually helping with cases. And also not to say it’s confirmed he is canonically neurodivergent, I’m merely stating his behavior with how alike it is to neurodivergence. But you see how excited Sherlock gets whenever he figures things out or when he starts piecing puzzles together, he just HAS to let John know and tell him as soon as he sees him. You could say that he’s his partner so of course he’s going to, but I mean also with how sometimes he will talk really fast and frantically like he just has to say it. Because sometimes it seemed like it’s not just him using him as a partner but he also wants to share the excitement with him.

It makes me happy to see as a neurodivergent person myself, because I get the same way about stuff I’m extremely passionate about and hyper-focused on. If it gives me a strong dose of emotion and excitement I just HAVE to tell anybody who will listen. It could also be said it’s one of his ways of connecting with others since he doesn’t fully understand the more conventional ways that people do it. He only understands how to do it through what he understands in his own mind.


r/Sherlock • • 3d ago

Image Forwards or backwards: always backwards?

Post image
60 Upvotes

For the record: this is one of my favorite scenes, with everyone coming to the rescue, even including Anderson.

The logic seems to be focused on whether the bullet penetrated Sherlock’s body or not, based on not hearing the mirror behind him shatter. Because the bullet was still in there, it was important to fall backwards to reduce blood loss.

But had the bullet shattered the mirror (meaning it both entered and exited his body), would there be any advantage in falling forwards? I’d say blood loss would occur falling in either direction.

I’d argue that falling backwards was the best option because it covers both the scenarios of having the.bullet stuck inside (functioning as “the cork in a bottle”) and the bullet pierced through Sherlock’s body (blood loss regardless of falling direction). What do you guys think, are there any circumstances that would favor falling forwards?


r/Sherlock • • 3d ago

Which one is better, one with the blue tilt or the lesser known full image with the original colors

Thumbnail gallery
15 Upvotes

I was looking through images for references And found the full image without the blue tilt, and it’s from a news article

I never knew about it existed until now, so which one is better


r/Sherlock • • 5d ago

Sherlock Holmes Vs Batman: Who's the smarter detective?

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/Sherlock • • 5d ago

Discussion Why?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

A whole new side of Sherlock Holmes: In this new series, the master detective gives relationship advice.

https://www.tvinsider.com/1295231/scarlett-holmes-cast-premiere-date-trailer-details/

https://www.c21media.net/news/roku-giving-sherlock-holmes-a-rom-com-makeover-with-limited-series-greenlight/

Why do you have to do this to Sherlock? 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭


r/Sherlock • • 6d ago

Image This parallax on the tube this morning at Baker Street amused me.

Post image
533 Upvotes

r/Sherlock • • 6d ago

Discussion My review

32 Upvotes

I just finished the last episode of season 4 and I want to give my review for this show

Fav episodes: The Reichenbach Fall, A Scandal In Belgravia

Least favourite: The Six Thatchers , The Final Problem

Season 1&2: 1000000/10: Acting, storylines and editing were so peak the first 2 seasons, it really couldn't compete with any other crime show I've watched before. It got me so hooked that I've binge watched it in a few days. The chemistry between John and Sherlock was amazing, it was humourus, catchy, thrilling and sad.
'"The Reichenbach Fall" was an insane episode! Now I'm not one to cry at movies or TV Shows but the ending of "The Reichenbach Fall" made me sob.

Season 3: I was excited about season 3, but honestly was met with a bit of dissappointment. The downfall from the first two seasons was noticable, yet it was also great and humourus to get to see Sherlock from a softer and more social side. I missed the vibe from season 1&2 though. I think Mary was put a bit too much in the center of the story, sometimes it felt like Sherlock and John only being side characters.

Season 4: Well....yeah....just... Wtf?, no I mean it like WHAT. THE. FUCK.?! No more words needed.
The Final Problem felt like I was watching a psycho thriller written on Wattpad. Also I used to love these smooth editing effects and transitions they made, in season 4 it looks like made with CapCut.

All in all I would give this show a 9/10 for season 1-3 and a 0/10 for season 4.

I think I'll rewatch it one day, just not season 4. Did I say season 4 was terrible?


r/Sherlock • • 6d ago

Image Looking for Sherlock hoodie

Post image
9 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I know it's kind of a lost cause but like 10 years ago, I bought on the BBC store a black hoodie with " I believe in Sherlock holmes" written on the back in blue. I lost it in the paris subway and since then never found it again anywhere.

If you know where it could still be found or bought or if someone doesn't want it anymore. It's really a childhood thing for me so I miss it a lot 😭

And yes I still tried vinted and ebay...

Thanks for the answers !


r/Sherlock • • 11d ago

Image Sherlock Sholmes — BUT SHEEP!

Post image
39 Upvotes

I drew a few characters from BBC's Sherlock as Sheep! What's your fav one? Have a lovely day/evening/night!


r/Sherlock • • 11d ago

Image Realistically If u were put incharge of a spinoff of the bbc 2010 sherlock show what would u have done

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/Sherlock • • 12d ago

Discussion The Six Thatchers

46 Upvotes

Just started season 4, and I am honestly so disappointed for now. In my opinion this is the worst episode I've seen so far

  • Chemistry between John and Sherlock seems so off the whole episode.
  • Sherlock is getting dumber? Like where are the times where Sherlock solved cases with smartness and wits instead of sentiment ? Sherlock used to be a genius, now he only seems street-smart.
  • I think it's fine that we get to see a more social and emotional side of Sherlock but his intelligence shouldn't have to suffer from it.
  • Marys backstory is pretty weak, in my opinion they could've done a lot better. It made the episode boring because 99% of the episode was centered on her backstory
  • John cheating or thinking about cheating?! That is so out of character for him! Also Sherlock is the first one to notice someone having an affair but he didn't with John?!
  • The plot is so confusing! Its called "The Six Thatchers" yet these six thatchers are only the plot for about 30 mins.

All in all it just does not give the typical "Sherlock feeling" I have felt the first 3 seasons. It's kinda sad because I really really love season 1 and 2 and I found season 3 to be weaker but still good.

Hopefully it doesn't continue like this for the next 2 episodes.


r/Sherlock • • 14d ago

my sherlock & john fanart

Thumbnail
gallery
133 Upvotes

red john and blue sherlock, painted with procreates moriarty brush!! this took me 5 hrs and was well worth it imo. i also made them look more smiley :)


r/Sherlock • • 14d ago

Discussion Sherlock holmes Inktober

31 Upvotes

Sherlock Holmes Inktober

Hello everyone out there, Here is the Inktober list. It kicks off tomorrow. Feel free to use it if you’d like. You can write, draw, craft, do needlework, or even make music based on the prompts.

But first, a few ground rules:

🎨 Any form of creative expression is welcome—drawing, writing, photography, crafting, sewing, cooking, etc.

📅 Participation is voluntary; you don’t have to complete all 31 days. 💬 Feedback is welcome—especially positive or constructive comments. Please, no unsolicited negative criticism.

❤️ No scoring or grading. Saying "I really like this!" is, of course, highly encouraged.

🧠 Feel free to interpret the prompts however you like; there is no single "right" answer.

🤝 Treat each other with respect.

🚫 No pressure if someone skips a day or doesn't manage to finish something.

The list:

🎻 Violin

😑 Boredom

🏛️ Diogenes

🍳 Mrs. Hudson’s cooking

🧘 Patience

🔎 Clues

👁️ Observation

🩺 Doctor

🥱 Sleep deprivation

🎭 Behind the facade

🐕 Dog

🩸 Scarlet

☠️ Poison

🚨 Crime scene

👩 The woman

🌊 Waterfall

👬 Brothers

🚬 Pipe

🏠 Home (221B)

🌫️ Fog

🤥 Lie

👃👂👁️ 5 senses

🚪 Locked room

📚 Chaos

🎭 Disguise

⚖️ Morality

📡 Telegraph

💬 Quote

🎩 The rival

🌊 Thames

🌃 East End

Feel free to ask if you have any questions about a prompt. Otherwise, I hope you all have a great time! 🎨✨


r/Sherlock • • 15d ago

Image My drawing of Sherlock using pastel pencils on black paper [OC]

Post image
266 Upvotes

r/Sherlock • • 15d ago

Discussion The London behind the episodes: I mapped every place from Doyle's original stories onto the city as it was in 1889

22 Upvotes

Fan project, free, no sign-up, nothing to sell. Mods, if this doesn't fit here, feel free to take it down.

Rewatching the series, I kept wondering how much of the show's London was already in Doyle. Quite a lot, it turns out. So I put every street, station and building named in the original stories on a map of London as it stood in 1889, with the real Victorian maps underneath: Charles Booth's poverty map and the Ordnance Survey.

A few things that might be fun if you know the show:

  • Pick A Study in Scarlet and you get the London of A Study in Pink's source: Baker Street, Brixton Road and the rest of Watson's first case.
  • The same for the stories behind A Scandal in Belgravia, The Sign of Three or The Empty Hearse: each one lights up only its own places.
  • You can read the stories on the site. Tap a place name and the map opens right there; close it and you're back in the sentence.
  • There is a 3D fly-through of Marylebone, around Baker Street, drawn from the Ordnance Survey of the 1870s.

https://holmeshub.online

It's a one-person hobby thing with rough edges, and readers on r/SherlockHolmes already caught a few places I had put on the wrong street. So I'd genuinely like to know:

  • Which episode's source story would you want to follow on the map first?
  • Are there spots the show used that echo a place in the books, and that I should look at?

r/Sherlock • • 17d ago

Discussion If Patrick Jane and Sherlock Holmes collabed on a case, who cracks it first?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about what an absolute powerhouse a collaboration between Sherlock Holmes and Patrick Jane would be. They are easily two of the most brilliant minds in fiction, but their methods are polar opposites.

  • Sherlock Holmes: The ultimate analytical reasoner. He focuses entirely on hard physical evidence, logic, footprints, and forensic detail.
  • Patrick Jane: The master of human psychology. He focuses on micro-expressions, emotional tells, cold reading, and mind games.

If they were forced to team up against a joint threat (like Moriarty and Red John), how do you think they would get along? Would Sherlock’s rigid logic get him to the answer first, or would Jane’s ability to read and manipulate people help him solve it faster?

Who cracks the case first, or do they finish at the exact same time while driving each other crazy?


r/Sherlock • • 18d ago

Image Can someone help me find this fan comic?

Post image
24 Upvotes

It's from ~2014, and I saw it on Tumblr. It's a small, 4 panel comic, and it was poking fun of BC's chins. I drew an approximation, so hopefully it helps!


r/Sherlock • • 19d ago

Image Drew this about 2 years ago

Post image
67 Upvotes

I'm not sure why I drew those fish?? but I'm sure I meant to convey something with them...


r/Sherlock • • 20d ago

Discussion Is young sherlock worth watching?

55 Upvotes

I watched bbc sherlock a few months ago and I loved it. Then I read the original books (still reading them rn). And now I found out young sherlock is a thing- is it worth watching?


r/Sherlock • • 19d ago

Image this jit cracks cases

Post image
4 Upvotes