r/ProductProbe • u/acoffeetablebook • 1d ago
Maybelline Sky High Waterproof, and why I went back to it after trying the tubing version
Maybelline Sky High Waterproof is the only mascara that keeps my curl, and I had to try both of the other Sky Highs to figure that out. My lashes are stick straight. Curl them, add a normal mascara, and they're flat again before I leave the house. My sister has the same lashes, and she's the one who told me to quit experimenting and go back to the waterproof.
This is the one, Very Black: amazon.com/dp/B08H46YXYH
I wore it first and only switched because taking it off is a pain. The washable Sky High gave me length, but it smudged by the afternoon and the curl gave up long before this one does. Then I tried Sky Tubes, the new tubing one, because everyone says it slides off with warm water. It does. My curl also dropped about as fast as I could put the curler down.
With the waterproof I curl first, do a second coat while the first is still wet, and they stay up through a full workday and a sweaty walk home. It won't do the curling for me, though. Skip the curler and not much happens, and by late evening the curl has come down a little.
Soap and water barely touch it. I hold an oil cleanser on my lashes for about 20 seconds before I wipe, and if I rush it I still lose a lash or two. If you want a mascara that comes off at the sink, or waterproof formulas make your eyes water, this isn't the one. If your lashes still drop with it, a few people with even more stubborn lashes swear by Heroine Make Long & Curl.
Anyone else with straight lashes found a remover that takes it off in one pass?