r/Presidentialpoll • • 23h ago

Alternate Election Lore If You Can Keep It - Jay Triumphant while Republicans Lament the 1796 election

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

The voters, the relative few that there are in these United States at the moment, have spoken in the first competitive election of the nation’s history. John Jay of the Federalist Party has won a decisive victory, in a complete landslide, over Aaron Burr and the Republicans. The Hamiltonian economic policy, anti-mob rule tendencies, and pro-British sentiments will remain the political word of the day. Congressional and State Legislature victories have reflected the immense rise of the Federalist Party, as they have captured or maintained supermajorities in both chambers of the Congress. Due to a peculiarity in how the Presidential elections work, Aaron Burr has narrowly been elected as Vice President, coming second in electoral votes. Federalist electors spread their second votes between a variety of candidates including John Adams, Alexander Hamilton, and George Washington, and Oliver Ellsworth. Jay will not be happy with this situation but Burr is sure to be pleased to stay in the public eye, he is sure to try his luck for the Executive Office again in 1800 - if his own Caucus can stand him by then.


r/Presidentialpoll • • 6h ago

Alternate Election Poll If You Can Keep It - ABC Affair, Quasi War, and the 1798 Midterms

7 Upvotes

President Jay’s Cabinet

VP: Aaron Burr

State: Gouverneur Morris

Treasury: Oliver Wolcott Jr.

War: Henry Brockholst Livingston

Attorney General: John Marshall

Secretary of the Navy: Benjamin Stoddert

While a continuation of Hamilton’s economic policies; modest tariffs, industrial bounties, and central banking, proceeded smoothly, the majority of Jay's first two years in office have concerned foreign and military policy. 

President Jay sent Charles Lee, Timothy Pickering, and John Quincy Adams to France to try to settle the matter of ship seizures. There, they were met with French Ministers who demanded bribes before negotiations could get under way. These Minister’s identities were cloaked in official documentation released to the public, who were much outraged. The aliases given to these officials provided for the naming of the event as the ABC Affair. Totally incensed, Pickering and Lee broke off negotiations and returned home, Adams went back to his diplomatic post in Portugal. An undeclared, quasi, war at sea breaks out in the Atlantic and Caribbean, with Congress voting overwhelmingly to authorise military action against French ships, commissioning six new Navy Frigates, and a 20,000 man strong Provisional Army, led by Alexander Hamilton, to supplement the “Old” (Regular) Army. Republicans decry the heightening of tensions and seek to reopen negotiations with France.

To finance this new force, the Federalist Congfess has raised a new 1% land value tax, leading to unrest in Pennsylvania and much grumbling across the country.

In August 1798, Anthony Wayne was dispatched to Haiti at the head of a military mission of 3,000 men to help defend Haiti from reconquest attempts by France. Republicans and Adamites deprecate this as encouraging open war with the French, but the Federalists defend their man in the White House as a tough response to French bullying, protecting a nation of similar ideals to the US, and protecting the Americas from Old World influence. In response, the French Directory has sent General Napoleon Bonaparte, fresh from an astounding victory in Italy, to reaffirm Haiti's relationship to France. It remains to be seen if open warfare will break out, dragging Haiti out of its muddled semi-independent situation.

Domestically, the Federalist controlled Congress has passed the so-called ‘Alien and Sedition Acts’. Which have given the President substantial power to detain and deport dangerous citizens of foreign nations residing in the US, censor press, and personal speech that contained malicious or false information about the government. This package of laws also extends the required residential time for US citizenship from 5 to 14 years. 

Thus, we come to the midterm elections. While economic issues were the crux of the 1796 presidential election, the 1798 midterms revolve around far different policies. The Republicans disparage an authoritarian, oligarchical government that represses speech and deports immigrants, while the Federalists insist that these measures are necessary for national security. The Federalists seek close ties with Britain to protect commerce, some even advocating outright war with France, while the Republicans seek to make amends with France to avoid war and ally one of few Republics in the modern world. Lately, the Republicans, led chiefly by Vice President Aaron Burr, have begun to press for an expansion to suffrage laws, abolishing property and tax requirements, though the Party mainstream has hesitated to endorse a Constitutional Amendment on the manner. The Federalists see “mob rule” as a dangerous corruption of democracy.

48 votes, 1d left
Federalists
Republicans