Hi guys, I need to make a difficult decision and all the people that I know are pretty biased toward one of my options. I recently took a difficult test (it was horrible) in order to qualify for a medical residency (USMLE type thing). In my country, this works like this: You take a 6-hours test and you get your score immediately. Most of us know how much we need in order to select our first choice. About 60,000 physicians took the test, so even though you know how you did, it’s not certain that you’ll get what you want, because it depends on how well everyone else performed. Then you have to wait 3-4 weeks until the results are published and you’re assigned to a block of 100 people who will be able to choose the specialty and place for residency. There are nearly 500 blocks. Once you choose your desired specialty you can begin to meet all the requirements of the specific institution you selected. If the hospital doesn’t accept you or you don’t find the specialty of your interest in the first choosing round you can wait for the second round where maybe some spaces free up because rejection can happen. There are 4 rounds. For specialties like the one that I want (ophthalmology) it’s rare, if not impossible, that you can find a spot in the second choosing round.
Back to the problem, I scored really great in the test and its very likely that I'm going to be in the first block or at least in the second one, so I can choose any specialty and hospital. The problem comes here, I have two options: doing my ophthalmology residency at a public hospital or at a private one. Both are pretty good but with some key differences:
The public one: for what I heard from some residents there, the workload is heavy, especially in your first year, so attending rarely have time to teach you. It’s mostly the senior residents the ones that do the teaching. In this hospital you don’t have lectures everyday because of the workload so you need to study on your own. One of the positive things and the main reason for wanting this hospital is that your surgical curve will be much larger (you will perform more phaco surgeries by your own) than it would be in private hospitals. It is not only an ophthalmology hospital so we can get consultations from other specialties. (I’m interested in internal medicine so it sounds nice to be able to be in touch with other disciplines and also learn from them in their specific fields). In this hospital once you choose it its almost impossible to get rejected.
The private one: everyone in my country (those who know something about ophthalmology) consider this the best hospital to be as a resident if you want to be an ophthalmologist. It’s a hospital exclusively dedicated to ophthalmology (this can be a good or a bad thing). It has several fellows so the majority of surgeries are going to be performed by them making the surgical curve shorter than the public hospital. Everybody says that in order to be a good surgeon you need to do a fellowship after your 3 years as resident (You can do that in the same hospital). The academia is exceptional, they have lectures everyday and have test regularly. This gives you the urge to study and perform well but it feels like being back in university once again (again, this can be a good or a bad thing). For you to be in this hospital you don’t only need to choose it, you also need to do an admission process where you need to gather some requirements, take an ophthalmology test and do an interview. All of this opens the door to get rejected and be in the need to repeat everything next year and be able to get a good score.
I think I have a pretty strong case to be accepted in the private one but you never know. I’m also pretty unsure if it is worth to take the risk. So I wanted to know what would you do? Would you prioritize strong academics or a large surgical volume? I’m from México.