r/LiveFromNewYork • SNL • 4d ago

Discussion Live Discussion - October 10, 2026 (Shane Gillis/Rosalía)

Welcome to the SNL live discussion thread for the 3rd episode of season 52! This week, Shane Gillis returns to host for the 3rd time, and returning as Musical Guest, Rosalía. For those new to the show, tune into your local NBC affiliate or Peacock around 11:30 PM ET to follow this episode live.

And if you're here early you still have time to do your SNL predictions for this week that are due at the start of the show! While you wait for the episode, we have some college football!

Enjoy the Episode!!

113 Upvotes

6.0k comments sorted by

122

u/bradytheguy1 4d ago

Nice ad-lib from Mikey, real SNL vet behavior

→ More replies (4)

58

u/EitherPermission2369 I'm Not Used To Chalk This Big 4d ago

I think my first f bomb live…oh SNL I’ll still love you 

→ More replies (3)

57

u/ldenso3 4d ago

Did anyone catch “sorry about earlier” at the end lmao

190

u/hyperjengirl New York's hottest club is J E L L Y B O W L. 4d ago

I love the zero applause at "My friend Joe Rogan"

→ More replies (6)

52

u/lovetheblazer What are we doing? What's going on? 4d ago

"Your breath smells like a book" is an underrated insult

→ More replies (1)

50

u/ToWitToWow 4d ago

Oh, she’s live live. Like, move the mic away and there’s no backing vocal live. Damn.
https://giphy.com/gifs/AgPt9udT567spxbSHf

49

u/jett_jackson 4d ago

Holy shit she needs to do Erika Kirk, she’s got the looks down and the eyes

→ More replies (1)

86

u/Classic_Wingers 4d ago

“You said a bad word!” The cast getting extra mileage out of this haha.

41

u/sexandliquor 4d ago

I apologize Rosalia I was not familiar with your game

→ More replies (1)

45

u/Robsurd 4d ago

Within a short time Grace was a daughter, a dying mom, and a hot ex wife. It just seems that deserves a mention.

37

u/James_2584 4d ago

I'm pretty sure Sarah in that outfit is unlocking somebody's fetish lol.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/bjkman SNL 4d ago

AND YOU SAID A BAD WORD

39

u/JediButterfly 4d ago

God, I hope they keep the live version for the online with Mikey’s ad lib

→ More replies (5)

39

u/giftopherz Totino's Sales Representative 3d ago

Mikey calling out "a bad word" at the end of the sketch was great

153

u/HanSolosSizzledHeart 4d ago

“My friend Joe Rogan” jeeesus CHRIST

→ More replies (3)

64

u/TheRealMe99 4d ago

JAJ IN A COLD AND ITS NOT TRUMP WE WON

→ More replies (1)

66

u/ShamrockShakespeare 4d ago

Jenny slate died for this?!?!

30

u/remotecontroldr 4d ago

Shutting the fuck up about what women wear was an option

30

u/Worried-Olive3613 4d ago edited 4d ago

For someone not taking his eyes off the cue cards he managed to squeeze that in pretty smoothly

32

u/BTGGFChris 4d ago

HELL YEAH MIKEY

31

u/shinbreaker 4d ago

Mikey Day showing he’s the king of improv

→ More replies (1)

31

u/BurgerNugget12 HR PICKENS 4d ago

Mikey with a great improv bit there

30

u/AmandaOhSnap 4d ago

lol Mikey day with the adlib

29

u/yobelkcip 4d ago

Great save from Mikey

30

u/ItsWillJohnson 4d ago

Guys the rules dont apply for hosts. Kristen Stewart came back after saying fuck in her monologue

→ More replies (1)

30

u/TheGoldenBoii 4d ago

Mikey’s a real pro.

33

u/CaptainHolt43 4d ago

The acknowledgement was hilarious, "YOU SAID A BAD WORD!" and even the "sorry about earlier"

34

u/gottahavemyPOPPs1 4d ago

Secret: Lorne wants f bombs occasionally. Guaranteed that sketch is 10x more popular now because of that

→ More replies (2)

34

u/jk1rbs 4d ago

Really wondering how she's set up to hold the en pointe this hold time.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/finalcountdown666 4d ago

She just said “let me show you the mic is on”

30

u/freshmanflop 4d ago

I always have respect for musical guests open to being in sketches

29

u/EbmocwenHsimah "Cause these men ain't what?" "SHIT!!!" 4d ago edited 4d ago

"Linda?"

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Realistic-Contract13 4d ago

Jane noping out of a sketch again!

56

u/stephapeaz Stop asking her if she knows stuff 4d ago

AND YOU SAID A BAD WORD

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Caliastanfor 4d ago

dropping Rogan's name at SNL isn't really reading the room.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/CaptainCanusa 4d ago

Jesus christ.

I have to assume a lot of that routine was like...a bet from the Austin comedy guys or something?

There's no way he thought "girls dress like whores nowadays" jokes and Joe Rogan/Theo Von anecdotes would do well here.

29

u/Imaletyoufinish_but 4d ago

I love that it was the Green Eggs and Ham sketch that got the F bomb dropped.

28

u/painful_fart00 4d ago edited 4d ago

Awww Lorne gonna be mad at ya'll! (-Miss Eggy)

24

u/Sp_Gamer_Live SHIIIIIIZ I AINT AFRAID OF YOU MOFOS 4d ago

WE GOT IMPROV

LORNES GUNNA HAVE A HEART ATTACK

24

u/Nyynks212 4d ago

Mikey day, a true pro

24

u/trumanburbank98 4d ago

Best f-bomb remains Samuel Jackson tbh just because of Kenan's "we gotta pay for those!" But Mikey was quick with it here too

→ More replies (3)

25

u/throwawar4 4d ago

There’s no way she’s just standing in point like that?? Is this her thing

→ More replies (6)

27

u/BobCirca 4d ago

I can’t help but laugh when Ashley’s voice hits that octave 😂

26

u/PowerHour1990 4d ago

Holy shit, Marcello has a second voice.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/SouthernInternal999 4d ago

good luck following that up Gracie Abrams

→ More replies (2)

27

u/UpperStudent5784 3d ago

Jeremy Culhane is so handsome in the opening!!

18

u/thisismycanceracct 3d ago

Jeremy Culhane is so handsome always

→ More replies (1)

52

u/FarmerFilburn4 4d ago

Mikey with the improv

→ More replies (2)

63

u/WildMajesticUnicorn 4d ago

"You're a loser and you said a bad word!"

→ More replies (1)

20

u/JediButterfly 4d ago

The voice change got me lmao

21

u/honestypen Lay off me, I'm starving! 4d ago

Rogan and Theo Von name drop?? Bill Maher next??

22

u/jonmay_work 4d ago

"my friend joe rogan" is not the name drop he thinks it is for this audience

→ More replies (1)

22

u/inksmudgedhands 4d ago

Kudos on the props department for the rolling window sofa.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/osnapitzsunnyy THE SEA TOOK THEM 4d ago

THIS WAS THE FIRST LIVE F-BOMB IVE WITNESSED LIVE MARK THE DATE

23

u/squintsforever 4d ago

Mikey Day is a legend for that. Haha.

23

u/mimzynull Well thanks Devil Daddy 4d ago

The James Johnathan joke was solid

21

u/Lane-Kiffin 4d ago

Mikey saved the sketch

24

u/SanchoMandoval 4d ago

Improv?? On my SNL???

24

u/IamGrimReefer 4d ago

the callback to the f-bomb was funny, and his apology sounded sincere.

23

u/Hup110516 4d ago

Mikey calling him out! 😂👌

→ More replies (3)

22

u/stephapeaz Stop asking her if she knows stuff 4d ago

take a shot every time Shane insults women 😵‍💫

→ More replies (1)

24

u/KTGTL 4d ago

I never once pondered why athletic shoes are called "sneakers" in my 41 years. Regardless of execution that's a great premise.

23

u/tealccart 4d ago

The kid with the cigarette 😭

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Bangkok_Dangeresque 4d ago

"We'll save you money, but it'll cost you" is just plain good writing

20

u/Dustmachinewind 4d ago

I'd never heard of Rosalia before, but that's pretty nice singing. Pretty cool to get introduced to a new musical act.

→ More replies (10)

24

u/EbmocwenHsimah "Cause these men ain't what?" "SHIT!!!" 4d ago

"Relax brother, you'll be reunited with her in two weeks anyway!"

"...what?"

22

u/ToWitToWow 4d ago

“These next two weeks without you is going to be really tough” is a great joke

23

u/joshklein37 4d ago

Did Shane skip the photoshoot or something?

→ More replies (1)

23

u/knightboatsolvecrime 4d ago

I think we found the official Grace breakout sketch.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/weeblewobble82 4d ago

Grace rocked tonight. She's an instant SNL classic. She needed no warm up period at all

23

u/EbmocwenHsimah "Cause these men ain't what?" "SHIT!!!" 4d ago

The "Something Got Cut" band shot!!

20

u/pink_faerie_kitten 4d ago

The HVAC ad was spot on. The guy that was sent to my mom's house to diagnose the furnace was polite and clean cut. The guys who came to install it were muddy and reeked of smoke. Took days for my house to air out (in the middle of winter) and the rug needed scrubbing

19

u/pink_faerie_kitten 3d ago

Weekend Update showed some teeth tonight. Much improved from the milquetoast, stale jokes of last week. They were mean and they mentioned the Nazi looking influence of the new pentagon logo. Really good and funny.

20

u/YOSHIMIvPROBOTS 3d ago

Rosalia is amazing!

19

u/Huge_JackedMann 4d ago

This must be how the sub feels for every musical guest

19

u/WhoseDuckIsItAnyway 4d ago

"Actually, I'm good. Have a good night." - Kam

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Phuckules 1% of Nuggets 4d ago

Kam just leaving, lol

20

u/Johnny_Carcinogenic 4d ago

wow history

19

u/ldenso3 4d ago

Wait did Mikey just improvise the bad word part???

19

u/EitherPermission2369 I'm Not Used To Chalk This Big 4d ago

I think Mikey and Andrew were the best people to handle the whole situation 

20

u/symphonyno87 4d ago

Tommy Brennan in this sketch has to become a GIF

19

u/bjkman SNL 4d ago

"See, we showed up"

19

u/James_2584 4d ago

JAJ is 100% this cast's Phil Hartman. The man is a fucking chameleon. Top tier impressionist and phenomenal character work. And super professional and hardly ever breaks!

18

u/ThisDerpForSale 4d ago

"If not, we can eat 'em!'

Holy crap I laughed at that a lot.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Careless-Economics-6 4d ago edited 4d ago

Ashley killed it as Woman at the End of Her Rope

19

u/EbmocwenHsimah "Cause these men ain't what?" "SHIT!!!" 4d ago edited 4d ago

"So, I am right here..." One line and she nailed it

98

u/Huge_JackedMann 4d ago

This is all divorced dude comedy. Not unfunny but it's kind of one note. 

→ More replies (6)

19

u/gottapoopweiner 4d ago

lol damn crashing and burning

→ More replies (1)

18

u/everynamecombined 4d ago

Mikey Day clutch af

19

u/IvyGold UCKF 4d ago

Mikey spins the F-bomb without breaking a sweat!

18

u/James_2584 4d ago

Okay, as much as I've cooled on Mikey, that was a top tier ad lib!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/parkerbing1 4d ago

Sarah Sherman oddly looked really good in that fit!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/SyNiiCaL Ooooooooh-weeeee, what up with that? 4d ago

I think everyone is wrong about the f bomb. SNL isnt gonna get in actual trouble, they'll pay a ridiculously affordable fine and the clip will go viral on social media. That F Bomb is nothing but an overall benefit for SNL

→ More replies (4)

19

u/michaelwavednoodles 4d ago

didn't realize it until his hair was different but ben lowkey has a period drama face

→ More replies (1)

18

u/FIDLARonTheRoofAZ 4d ago

A sketch about the origin of the term "Sneakers" is a good idea and feels more like something that would be on a Bargatze hosted episode since he typically writes actual witty standup material like that.

So it seemed weird for this to be a Gillis sketch... and then it became a sketch about something else... So it did make sense after all.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/jxmmychuu SNL "jumanji" 4d ago

As someone who’s worked a lot in manual labour, this hits the spot

18

u/OG_Casual-Thor SNL 4d ago

Close captions are telling me that she's "singing in Spanish"

→ More replies (2)

18

u/ToddHundley 4d ago

Perfectly nails how O'Leary sounds so condescending and like seemingly agrees with you while blowing off everything you say.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/The_Mike_El 4d ago

Those are some evil (cough cough Erika K) eyes.

18

u/pecanesquire 4d ago

Coco BEAN…

18

u/parkerbing1 4d ago

That Kevin impersonation was so good I can't get over the voice

18

u/AyRayKay SNL 4d ago

The fake mom in the bed hahahaha

18

u/swazal 4d ago

That was LIVE … amazing studio performance!

18

u/bradytheguy1 4d ago

idk but feels like the best musical performance on SNL in at least the past 5 years

18

u/mimzynull Well thanks Devil Daddy 4d ago

I'm an old head, usually focus on the hosts but this episode is like a throw back to when I listened to SNL for the musical guests. Rosalía is just transcendent

55

u/8racecar8 4d ago

Mikey Day improv pro

148

u/proserpinax 4d ago edited 4d ago

“Women are dressing like whores” “my friend Joe Rogan” yeah that tracks

Not making me feel bad he got fired from SNL lol

→ More replies (21)

67

u/CookieDoughSport69 4d ago

im never coming back am i

→ More replies (1)

15

u/kilokahn 4d ago

Oh man, why was he re-booked?

17

u/PinkCadillacs 4d ago

I don’t understand why Shane keeps getting asked to come back to host

→ More replies (1)

17

u/RiseFromYourGrav 4d ago

Reminds me of the bit from 30 Rock where Tracy is making jokes about his life as a rich person, and it's not landing. 

→ More replies (1)

17

u/smooth_sea 4d ago

His sense of humor feels stuck in 2006

16

u/Ok_Incident_6287 4d ago

How is Ben so adorable in every single outfit 

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Careless-Economics-6 4d ago

Mikey being a pro

17

u/mcd23 4d ago

Mikey with a moment of truly great improv

17

u/privateplant 4d ago

What is the trickery in the way shes standing like that so still

→ More replies (6)

17

u/Raptorpicklezz Tim is my rapper name 4d ago

As a Canadian who’s watched Kevin O’Leary on TV for longer than yall, this is surreal and JAJ is spot on

17

u/space_llama_karma 4d ago

He’s wearing two watches lol

→ More replies (2)

33

u/emo_sinner 4d ago

How is those whole monologue just weird and bad towards women

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Pandoras-SkinnersBox dannybangsanimals.com 4d ago

“My friend Joe Rogan…” should never open any sentence ever.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/MD_FunkoMa 4d ago

Sarah Sherman as Thing 1/2 is pretty dang good. Also beautiful, too.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/BearCertain8064 4d ago

Ya know, if they won’t let Sarah be batshit weird, at least they let her be trash lmao I’ll take my Squirm any way I can get her.

38

u/PixlatedDonut 4d ago

Is it just me or was that one of the best live performances of all time

→ More replies (3)

61

u/Parmesan_Pirate119 4d ago

As Miss Eggy would say "Lorne gonna be mad at y'all!"

→ More replies (2)

47

u/thatgirlnicola 4d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/n71ex8ztZnhao
Let’s wrap this monologue up…

16

u/Johnwi111505 4d ago

I hope we see more of saidah tonight

→ More replies (2)

16

u/James_2584 4d ago

JAJ's RFK Jr. impression has gotten a LOT better! A moment of silence for his vocal cords.

15

u/proserpinax 4d ago

JAJ not doing Trump is the reprieve I need tonight. Not that JAJ isn’t talented, Trump just bums me out

→ More replies (1)

17

u/CookieDoughSport69 4d ago

not enough fireball for this monologue

17

u/GreenStretch 4d ago edited 4d ago

God, what a horror show, Shane, Joe, and Gillis, Von in a steam room.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/dragonfliesloveme 4d ago

Name drops Joe Rogan?

🤨😒

16

u/negme 4d ago

Ok I’m woke again 

16

u/smallerthings 4d ago

Welp, he said 'fuck'

16

u/QueenFrostine15 4d ago

WOW F BOMB THIS IS WHY I WATCH LIVE 

17

u/SupaDupaTron 4d ago

And you said a bad word!

→ More replies (2)

15

u/RiseFromYourGrav 4d ago

Mikey Day with the improv win

17

u/EveningFlights stop asking her if she knows stuff :) 4d ago

lol, James Jonathan was silly. Sarah Sherman makes a perfect Who.

17

u/Cerblu 4d ago

Mikey Day, taking of advantage of the situation there.

16

u/matchamelodyy 4d ago

exactly why mikey is one of my fav cast members

15

u/Johnny_Carcinogenic 4d ago

JAJ always nails these period piece characters

16

u/turningtee74 I understand Rivers better than he understands HIMSELF 4d ago

Saidah getting a little more bit parts. Good start, hope she gets a feature bit soon tho

16

u/Sensitive-Meat-757 4d ago

Upfront HVAC is best sketch in this ep so far

15

u/AyRayKay SNL 4d ago

Uhhhhh what the fuck no strobe warning????

17

u/Ozzel Now THAT'S a STAR TREK! 4d ago

Very Kate Bush. I dig it.

17

u/Sp_Gamer_Live SHIIIIIIZ I AINT AFRAID OF YOU MOFOS 4d ago

I will say

that is one way to prove you are not lip syncing

16

u/Fast_Way8546 MOO-LAWN-ROUJ 4d ago

Mr Wonderful is perfect for sketch comedy as a character since I am 99.9 percent sure he is the devil lol

→ More replies (1)

18

u/streetsahead483 4d ago

Ben as Jelly Roll is inspired casting.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/PowerHour1990 4d ago

“I am not cancelling my submersible experience!”

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Mintcreme7 4d ago

Gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous. No notes.

15

u/MarkMcWrath 4d ago

"Your breath smells like a book" was good lol

15

u/maxmouze 4d ago

Grace Reiter jumping right into the show with the confidence of a seasoned SNL vet.

16

u/rupaulofitall #1 Ashley Padilla Fan 4d ago

Oh yikes

15

u/P_didnt 4d ago

My friend joe Rogan yes regretable

15

u/UsagiGurl 4d ago

Name dropping Joe Rogan so many times 🤮

15

u/stephapeaz Stop asking her if she knows stuff 4d ago

I laughed more during Dakota Johnson’s monologue

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Phuckules 1% of Nuggets 4d ago

lol, there is a fucking window to roll down

15

u/JediButterfly 4d ago

He doesn’t fucking like them

15

u/Phuckules 1% of Nuggets 4d ago

You could see his whole body implode on that

15

u/HanSolosSizzledHeart 4d ago

GUYS HE SAID FUCK! GUYS GUYS!!! HE SAID FUCK!

15

u/AnthonyCumiaPedo 4d ago

Ooops Shane about to get fired from SNL again

14

u/SanchoMandoval 4d ago

Welp this sketch will only be remembered for one thing

14

u/JediButterfly 4d ago

MIKEY WITH SOME IMPROV

15

u/smooth_sea 4d ago

Ahh Mikey with the save

15

u/Captain_Blackjack 4d ago

“Sorry about earlier”

14

u/would_do_again 4d ago

Props to props on the Cat’s wheels.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Johnny_Carcinogenic 4d ago

Kenan with a gray beard and gray hair is so good

15

u/Cerblu 4d ago

The Closed Captions be like [Singing in Spanish]

Yep, that she is.

15

u/Huge_JackedMann 4d ago

Is she in some kind of suit or harness? I find it hard to believe she's standing point for all of it? 

→ More replies (4)

15

u/AyRayKay SNL 4d ago

What a cool way to show that you’re live damn

15

u/Tsukiko_ When You Say That You Sound Poor 4d ago

Fuck ice

15

u/Skolney SNL 4d ago

Grace went from child to old lady in record time

14

u/Hup110516 4d ago

I had never heard of her until Akiva talked about her on The Lonely Island & Seth Meyers podcast, her voice is absolutely beautiful!

15

u/ResearchChem87523 4d ago

Rosalia killed it. Music Booker is the MVP of this season so far.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/drboobafate Drinker of Non-Alcoholic Bitch Beer 4d ago edited 4d ago

You know when bro’s facial expression doesn’t change at all during the monologue you know it (and the episode as a whole) are gonna be dogshit.

→ More replies (2)

54

u/Limp_Competition_512 4d ago

this episode is so male centric WHERE are my ladies

→ More replies (1)

43

u/sexandliquor 4d ago

About to risk it all for Sarah in that Thing 1 costume.

39

u/FadedBlackTee2 4d ago

'Sorry about earlier' good save

15

u/inksmudgedhands 4d ago

For those who are wondering, he isn't kidding. Hegseth is going to do a publicly aired execution by firing squad. That's where we are now.

13

u/the_Odd_particle 4d ago

MY friend Joe Rogan. Not his.

14

u/HeisenbergsSon 4d ago

Welp he might not ever come back

→ More replies (2)

15

u/nh18wheeler 4d ago

CMON SHANE THAT COSTS MONEY

14

u/symphonyno87 4d ago

HE SAID FUUUUUUUUCKKKIINNNNN

14

u/neatgeek83 4d ago

F bomb alert! Lorne might just retire before update.

14

u/dan_blather 4d ago

Might as well drop a few more, now that the damage is done.

14

u/ObviouslySteve 4d ago edited 4d ago

It was a pump ;)

14

u/YoungKeys 4d ago

Venmo us and say it’s for pizza lmao

14

u/lovetheblazer What are we doing? What's going on? 4d ago

"You have to Venmo us and say it's for pizza."

15

u/dexters_trap_house 4d ago

I tuned in for Shane, never heard of Rosalia. She's really good. Reminds recently when Olivia Rodrigo was on and I was like "all the kids like her, I'll see what's up instead of skipping" and thought her live performance was better than the studio recording of whatever that song was where she was at the table.

14

u/givemecoffeenowhurry 4d ago

I just had a seizure