Upon rewatching the series, I was already well aware that romanticizing toxic relationships was a huge thing in the TVDverse & I really do feel like it’s okay to like problematic characters so long as you aren’t delusional about them being problematic.
However, I feel like when the first season was out I was reminded of Yellowjackets a little when it came to Josie/Lizzie & Shauna/Jackie. Both Jackie & Lizzie were heavily disliked by their respective fandoms at first so much so that people would assign false negatives that deeply misinterpreted their actual personalities & the actual story.
Shauna/Josie (who hilariously looks like Lottie, I thought she was played by Kaylee Bryant!) both display rage fueled, vindictive, & cruel behavior in both their pilots (Shauna having sex with Jackie’s boyfriend when Jackie expressed wanting to have sex with him then demanding he say he love her & Josie setting Penelope on fire) but people really have tunnel vision towards Jackie/Lizzie as they “villains.”
Penelope however fails to earn my sympathy about being set on fire because she drugs MG to make out with him in front of Josie. Hello? She gave out pens to spy on the whole school because…reasons I guess? Bullied Lizzie to “weaken” her so Josie could kill her & was her ableism was INSANE. She expected Josie to choose her over her family, rather than even talk to Josie she chooses to break up with her & start a bullying campaign.
Penelope calls Lizzie a black hole as if she isn’t the one who has been harassing the twins for an entire year. Then she has the nerve to try to give Josie a letter about going to Belgium & when she leaves Josie blames Lizzie for her NOT READING IT? The fandom was under spells during season one because why did everyone cheer Penelope & Josie like this?
Josie never spoke up for herself & while Lizzie should have been willing to listen, Josie never opened her mouth about what she wanted. She seethes when she doesn’t get it, & then lashes out. She is extremely ableist towards Lizzie blaming her for every problem & then in S3 she’s shielded from the consequences of her Lord Josiemort behavior. Lizzie hopping on Alyssa Chang’s back after Josie snapped her neck was crazy considering Josie never would do the same!
I can’t imagine how much worse Shauna would have been if she had some rat in her ear like Penelope telling her she was the biggest victim in the world who just #deservesbetter.