Okay so I’ve been using Maybelline Sky High Waterproof (in Very Black) for like 6 months now and I feel like I need to finally give it props. I just reordered another tube on Amazon for around $10, and honestly, the quality you get for that price is crazy good compared to high-end stuff.
My lashes are pretty straight and usually droop after five minutes, but this stuff actually keeps them curled all day without leaving dark smudges under my eyes. The wand is super skinny and bendy, which I love because I always manage to get mascara all over my eyelids with big thick brushes. It’s definitely more about length and separation than crazy dramatic volume, but two coats gives that super clean "are those your real lashes" look.
The only catch is taking it off. Do not try using a normal face wash unless you want to lose half your eyelashes lol. You legit need an oil cleanser or cleansing balm to break it down.
Overall, the formula and hold feel like something you’d easily pay $25+ for, so getting that kind of performance for ten bucks makes it such a solid buy. Just thought I'd share in case anyone's looking for something high quality that won't break the bank