Nothing about Midnight really seems to add up to me.
I do not understand the level of hype around the show. A few influencers are framing it as the greatest thing they have ever seen, comparing it to being at Hamilton at the Public, and staking a remarkable amount of credibility on that position.
But the broader response does not seem to match. There are only about 20 reviews on Show-Score, averaging roughly 72. That is not the profile of an undisputed breakout hit, particularly when most current Broadway shows, and plenty of Off-Broadway shows, are scoring higher.
Meanwhile, there has been very little traditional media coverage, despite reports that the run ends November 8 and tickets are being priced as high as $400.
Maybe the show is genuinely extraordinary and the wider reviews simply have not caught up. But the gap between the influencer narrative and the available audience response is striking. Something feels off.