Per the sub reddit post rules:
💰 **Budget**
* What is your maximum budget: Around $50k drive-away, through a novated lease
🚗 **Typical driving**
* Average weekly km: About 100 km (roughly 5,000 km a year, mostly around town)
* Longest *regular* trip: The odd regional trip, e.g. Melbourne to Bendigo (about 150 km each way)
🔌 **Charging**
* What charging is available at home/work? None. Street parking, so public charging only
🚙 **Vehicle class**
* Open to SUV, hatch or liftback
---
I'm about to get my first EV and I'd really appreciate some perspective from people who've had theirs for a while. So far it's been the classic analysis paralysis whirlwind.
To be fair, on mileage alone I'm not the obvious EV buyer. But it's going through a novated lease, and once you factor in the FBT exemption, depreciation, selling my current car and losing its running costs, it actually comes out slightly ahead of keeping what I've got. So I'm not too worried about running costs, I'm more focused on finding something I'll actually enjoy being in.
The main things for me:
- Comfort and a quiet cabin. I'd honestly take a nice place to sit over performance.
- Lane keep and adaptive cruise that feel smooth and natural, not jumpy.
- Easy to park. I'm on the street in Melbourne's inner west, so good cameras and sensors matter a lot.
- Public charging that just fits in, ideally topping up while I do the groceries rather than planning around it.
- Room to grow, as there'll probably be a baby in a couple of years and a pram to fit.
- And I'll admit I want something I like the look of.
I'm coming out of a CX-30 that's been a really good car, so that's my benchmark for comfort and build.
I know these are quite different cars, but they've ended up at similar money on a lease. Discounting has felt pretty significant lately, so is there a lot of stock sitting around? Here are my choices:
- Mazda 6e GT, my favourite on looks and cabin, but I'm a bit unsure about the length and pram life, and about judging the corners when parking
- Geely EX5, comfy and roomy, but a bit plain on the outside and I'm not sure how it'll hold its value
- XPENG L03, a bit of a wildcard, mostly because remote parking might get it into a tight side passage at home. Can these be test driven at the moment? Dealers seem a bit unresponsive
- BYD Atto 2, the sensible cheaper pick, easy to park but a bit plain for me, and charging seems really slow?
I've test driven the EX5 and the Atto 2. I think I could live with any of them, so this is really just optimising and finalising the choice.
What I'd love to hear:
- If you do low km and charge publicly, how has it actually been?
- What's turned out genuinely comfortable and quiet a few months in, not just on the test drive?
- If you own any of the above, what surprised you?
- Anything obvious I might be missing?
Thanks in advance, this sub's always been really helpful.