I just bought the aw ultra 3 on sale from Costco, having been a long-term Garmin user (Garmin Fenix 6S pro). I was not impressed. Sorry for the long post but I need something to re-read if in the future I’m considering the AWU again.
TLDR Going to return the Ultra and go back to old reliable.
I didn’t have a cellular plan for the ultra so i carried my phone anyways on runs for the camera (for the Strava posts), for emergency calls, and Spotify. I used a cheap Amazon running belt so it was not inconvenient to carry my large phone (iPhone pro max 17).
I wanted to like the ultra but it did not make it a seamless transition. My initial motivation for getting the ultra stemmed from me feeling like I was missing out. The Garmin is starting to show its age, making lots to be desired. The Ultra offered a newer Bluetooth chip, meaning my phone would not disconnect from my watch as easily with distance. The multitude of apps seemed promising. Maybe I can finally be less glued to my phone. Maybe Siri on my wrist would make my life easier. Maybe Apple Wallet meant I can drive my car without taking my phone out of my pocket. Finally, nicer watch bands. But the grass is not always greener on the other side.
First, the battery had to be charged after 3 days. Running 2x in those 3 days really killed it. I’m not used to and dislike having to take off my watch to “top it off”. With my Garmin, I would charge it once every 2 weeks with 3-6 runs and there would be no problems.
Second, the Ultra OS is very cluttered. Starting runs is not as easy as 4 presses of the same button to start monitoring. It’s hidden behind layers of the workout app that makes operating while already starting to run tedious. In hindsight, a Strava complication could have been more useful.
Side note, in a poor attempt to be like a phone, why is every function compartmentalized? Why is the clock app separated into 3 separate apps? Why are vitals separated from o2 sats, HR, ECG? Despite me deleting everything I could for the sake of simplicity and access, it still felt very cluttered. Having to scroll or press through too many hurdles makes it feel less of a watch.
Third, the current running data is not as easily readable. I’m not sure if it is the displays or my eyes. But the heart rate and pace are all the same font, cluttered with other data points that make distinction while running not as fun.
In the workout app, I can decide what metric to display but despite having the much larger screen, the Ultra makes data less discernible. Strava’s app does not allow customization and its font sizes did not make it any better. Contrasting w the Garmin, the heart rate is prominently placed at the top in a larger font for zone 2 training. Its simple MIPS display is easier to read in the sunlight while also showing what I need to see: Total distance, time spent running and current pace.
I also ran with both watches at the same time during testing. Both watches reported similar data at the end of the runs. One thing stood out, Apple’s HR seemed to lag behind Garmin’s for a bit before it eventually caught up.
Fourth, despite being set to the “prominent” vibration setting, notifications on the Ultra are much more feeble. On the other hand, every mile the Garmin vibrates with clear tactile feedback.
Fifth, passive monitoring sucks. Heart rate isn’t always on like with the Garmin. It’s checked infrequently, quite literally 3 mins ago. I know the Ultra 4 is supposedly better at this, but that is not worth hundreds of dollars more for.
Steps are another important metric I would like easy access to. I want to know if I made it to 10,000 for the day. Instead, Apple focuses on its meaningless fitness rings. Active calories from moving, Exercise minutes, and Standing. I understand it’s geared for a different audience but its lack of customization makes it useless to me.
Sixth, the watch faces are all too much. I just want a simple display of time and date with easy access to data and workouts. In order to achieve this on Apple Watch, I would have to sacrifice my want of a simple screen for simplicity in function by adding more complications to the watch face. The action button didn’t make it any easier.
Seventh, Apple wallet didn’t work with my car despite multiple attempts. From Pairing to unpairing. Restarting the watch. Trying different times of the day. I was only successful once in unlocking my car and once in starting my car. It was my last straw.
Finally, it’s bigger and heavier. Enough said. I already have a big phone. Running with another big screen seemed redundant.