Let me begin with saying that half of me feels terrible about this, and the other half feels smugly justified.
I (34f) dated, letās call him Josh (34m) for a little over 3 years beginning over five years ago. Everything was great in the beginning, but then the gaslighting, shrinking of myself, and constantly making me question my reality became too much to bare and we had a nasty breakup where he really dragged my name through the mud- in what I assume was an attempt to knock my confidence to ground zero and make me ārealize I needed himā
Anyway, i began plotting exacting my revenge in a way that would subtly make him question his own reality.
He was very vain, and proud of his āgood looksā and āgym bodā - but the truth is, after years of him comfortably torturing me- he hadnāt stepped foot in the gym, and the constant manicuring of his hair and beard went out the window long ago. Still, his ego remained.
I started catfishing him on dating apps(he made an account 2 days after we broke up!). At first just matching with him- (I had multiple accounts and conversations running at the same time). And denying him in a very specific way. I started small. For instance- Iād have a girl have a conversation with him for days and then ask for a photo- when he would send it she would say: āNo amount of witty banter could make me attracted to you unfortunately, Iām sorry. Best of luckā. Sucks but it happens. This was just oiling up the pan.
The next girl asked him what he was studying in school. of course I knew this already. I also knew I helped him cheat on every single one of his exams- so I objectively knew the material better than him. After asking some specific questions about a topic I knew he struggled with- the next girl turned him down on accounts of āneeding to find someone who is an intellectual matchā ouch. Iām just warming up.
The following two girls didnāt need a great setup to teach him a lesson- he offered the opportunity up freely. He told both girls variations of āmy ex was crazy/ women may be ruined for meā. Both girls gave him variations of āany man who says that was the problem/ ewwā glorious machismo complex must be shaking at this point.
Now, I decide I need to take it up a notch or itās going to get boring for him. He needs more of a reward for his tough taught lessons. In comes my friend- letās call her Ashley (31F). Ashley is physically Joshās type to a T- and a wild hearted individual. She was obviously down to join the scheme.
We make a profile for her and begin the process of courting him. He asks for a FaceTime, then a date. Everything is going fantastically. The day of the date comes up and Ashley reschedules, no big deal- just a minor inconvenience- and rescheduled for the following Saturday. A date I knew he wouldnāt remember without me. A date I knew he couldnāt miss and would eventually have to reschedule: his momās birthday. The following Saturday comes around and lo and behold- 20 minutes before the date- he cancels. I instruct ashley to wait an hour, call him, visibly upset- and ask if he can make it up to her by calling out of work tomorrow. He agrees.
The next morning- I have Ashley drop the bomb āI was upset and thought you didnāt like me so I got drunk, Iām sorry I called you.ā She claimed she didnāt remember asking him to take off of work, that it must have been the booze, and that she was actually busy that whole day, but she could swing by his job Friday night to at least get the ball rolling, and to prove to him she really did want to see him.
He ate it up.
I wonder if he was annoyed that he lost a day of pay. He never took days off in our relationship.
A busy Friday night at the restaurant comes around and we get ashley dolled up to the GODS. Her objective: cause as much emotional destruction as possible. I entered about 20 minutes earlier and got a seat in a dark corner, away from the server station but in view of what would become a spectacle.
Ashley enters the bar and immediately heads turn. She has a gravitational pull. She lingers, greats all of the men- and begins LOUDLY laughing at all of their jokes. She goes off script and gets hammered but it is glorious improv. Sheās screaming and breaking glassware. Telling him heās bigger in real life. Eventually, my ex snaps and gets sent home and takes her home- where she throws up in his brand new prized possession car. He never texts her again. 10/10 work Ashley.
A few months go by and I donāt see him active on dating apps, but I do see him active in the gym and not at bars on find my iPhone. Good for him.
Then one faithful day- I see him in the corner of the bar where we had our first date,with⦠A FIRST DATE. What an opportunity. And what a coincidence that Ashley and I planned on meeting up later that night. We can bump it up a bit for the plot.
Ashley zooms over and instantly gets into character. Ugly crying and moaning while b lining for their table āwhy didnāt you text me back, you said you liked me, you said I was different!ā The revenge bug was reawakened. I felt empowered by his fear and confusion. Perhaps he still had more work to do before he could enter the dating pool.
A few months pass and I admittedly got a little bored and stopped checking him like my little tamagotchi. He really seemed like he was doing good. Work, home, gym, even therapy.
Then Halloween came about, and that revenge bug got hungry again.
My plan was based entirely on behavioral patterns. He hadnāt gone out in a while, so surely his friends would drag him out on a holiday. Especially one where he can meet drunk girls in costume. So I got to building the perfect catfish costume. An unbelievable cosplay of a character from one of our shared favorite things. It is heavy on sfx makeup and contacts, as well as a wig- so I was undistinguishable. The costume itself is sexy, but a full body suit- so no identifying features would be revealed. In case that wasnāt enough to beckon him, I also got a phone case of his favorite movie, one I openly said I disliked, this way, if he had an inkling it was me, the phone case would push him in the other direction.
May I just say a plan has never worked so flawlessly. I started my night at a bar we both used to frequent. I got a drink and gathered a good spot in the center of the bar where I could be on full view. I pulled out find my iPhone. He was on his way. 5 minutes out. 30 minutes later he approached me and complimented my costume. Hereās where I was scared but years of being a dungeon master payed off. I pitched my voice slightly higher and breathier than my natural voice. He had no idea it was me. We spoke for a while and he got drunk enough where I could enter phase two.
He loves to question and play devils advocate and absolutely hates anyone who claims they have supernatural or psychic abilities. So naturally, I begin telling him that Iām actually pretty psychic and I sense a curse on him. He pushes by asking to prove it by telling him something specific about himself. Man, do I have boatloads of those. I tell him his three letter nickname, and that he prefers it because his name is tied to pain (heās named after his dad who left him). Heās ordering more drinks and asking more questions. Iām answering with cryptic accuracy. Enough to still kinda be bullshit, but enough to keep him interested. Then- during a cigarette I ask him. āAre you ready for what I have to tell you nowā
āYes.ā He drunkenly says.
āI sense romantic mishap in your life and itās been happening for some time now. There are wrongs you have to right.ā
His nerdy ass was eating this up.
āThis woman from the past, She holds love for you still, but it almost feels like that love is corrupted. There are things you both have not let go of that bind you together. Until forgiveness is given, this misery will linger.ā
In his drunk, nicotine high state- I could see tears welling in his eyes. I had won. I chugged my drink and went home. Irish goodbyed that dude.
He texted me (real me) the next evening. A long, sappy apology about how he didnāt take accountability in our relationship and how he should have treated me better. He admitted to all of his hurtful ways. It was beautiful really. He slipped a bit at the end and started fishing for forgiveness so I had to tighten the noose for the last time. It was such a shame, he was almost free of the curse. I texted him back two words:
āGet fucked.ā