r/skeptic • • Feb 06 '22

🤘 Meta Welcome to r/skeptic here is a brief introduction to scientific skepticism

Thumbnail
skepticalinquirer.org
299 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 7h ago

💩 Misinformation The Russian Bots Went Silent. Or Did They? --Renée DiResta

Thumbnail lawfaremedia.org
100 Upvotes

There is a real event underpinning the story, and an authentic chart showing a dramatic decline in automated internet traffic. But the leap from a viral chart to the disappearance of Russian propaganda bots is a large one. Much of the apparent corroboration comes from anecdotes about how social media feels, rather than measurements of what actually changed. And this speaks to a broader problem...

Broken down into 8 bite size segments by a leading disinformation researcher

  1. What happened, and why does everyone think the Russian bots disappeared?
  2. Wait, what exactly is a "bot"?
  3. So what does the Cloudflare chart actually show?
  4. But couldn't the strikes also have disrupted Russian propaganda operations?
  5. Why did so many people believe the claims?
  6. Couldn’t disinformation researchers just check whether accounts stopped posting?
  7. What does this all tell us about the state of the information environment?
  8. Why is it so hard to answer these questions now?

So, ironically, a story about the disappearance of Russian propaganda bots became a viral misleading story on its own. 


r/skeptic • • 17h ago

🤦‍♂️ Denialism New Documents Add to Evidence in Climate Deception Case Against ExxonMobil

Thumbnail
insideclimatenews.org
199 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 30m ago

💲 Consumer Protection The skincare scheme that led to consumer complaints, lawsuits and a federal investigation

Thumbnail
npr.org
• Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 38m ago

❓ Help I WOULD LIKE TO GET SOME HELP OR ADVICE

• Upvotes

Hello. I am just deconstructing from Christianity and learning more about psychology and how our mind works has really had me questioning the existance of a deity or of God. However my deconstruction has not been easy and one of my biggest areas of difficulty has been miracles especially the untested and witness claimed ones. I understand perfectly that not all eyewitness accounts point towards truth and between being honestly mistaken to embellishment and even to fraud I often have little trust of the same. But there is a particular claim that especially feels sticky to me and I would like your help in evaluating the same.

https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/amp/article/2000125937/kenyan-nun-who-photographed-god-is-headed-for-sainthood

https://sisterannaali.org/page.php?id=MDAwNEZCa053WjNBM3A

These are the links to the story. For the most part I am more comfortable with the claims of crying blood and the images and I know the evidence needed to affirm the same though I would like to hear your views on the same. For me I believe the part where I am bit hung up is on the issue of the cameras being damaged. I know that a claim and a witness story is not enough and there is a need to establish more like what damage was caused and what is the actual cause of damage etc.

But I often feel like my arguments are weak and not emotionally compelling. It definitely hasn't been helpful that the only medium I have consulted this far has been AI.

I guess what I am asking for specifically is what are your views and opinions on the same especially with the evidence claimed to be provided and am I being overly skeptical by choosing to be uncertain over the same information or for not accepting testimony face value .


r/skeptic • • 22h ago

💲 Consumer Protection Justin Baldoni‘s Crisis PR Firm Linked to Smear of Consumer Safety Advocate

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
140 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 1d ago

Fact File: HPV vaccine safe and effective despite RFK Jr. claims, experts say

Thumbnail
ctvnews.ca
671 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 1d ago

The Tiffany Problem: the modern things that are counterintuitively much older than we assume | Sea Slater

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
49 Upvotes

It's natural to map the world around us with heuristics, but sometimes they can lead us astray or even reveal our biases and bigotries.


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

Natural doesn't always mean better: How to spot if someone is trying to convince you with an 'appeal to nature'

Thumbnail
bbc.com
109 Upvotes

This shouldn’t be news to any skeptic, but it is well-written and it is good to see stuff like this published on BBC.


r/skeptic • • 2d ago

Richard Dawkins Was Right: Why the God of the Bible Is Far Worse Than You Probably Think

437 Upvotes

Richard Dawkins famously called the God of the Old Testament “the most unpleasant character in all fiction.” What’s interesting is that he may have understated the case.

From divinely commanded massacres and the slaughter of children to the death penalty for homosexuals, the Bible offers plenty of evidence for Dawkins’ indictment. And since Yahweh is the God at the foundation of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, the implications extend to all three monotheistic religions. Take a closer look at these disturbing passages that reveal the dark character of its god.

https://fightingthegods.com/richard-dawkins-was-right-why-the-god-of-the-bible-is-far-worse-than-you-probably-think/


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

Ancient Egyptian Skepticism, GM 261, 2020

Thumbnail academia.edu
7 Upvotes
  1. Skepticism existed in ancient Egypt, contrary to the belief in absolute religious devotion.

  2. Religious practices often reflected personal piety rather than adherence to official cults, indicating skepticism.

  3. Tomb robbing from the Badarian period suggests a significant skepticism regarding afterlife beliefs.

  4. Literary texts demonstrate skepticism towards the efficacy of divine intervention and afterlife promises.

  5. Ancient skepticism diverged from modern ideas, focusing more on suspending belief than on questioning knowledge.


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

💩 Woo People Say These Peptides Hurt Them. Their Stories Are Muffled in MAHA’s Push for Medical Freedom.

Thumbnail
kffhealthnews.org
144 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 2d ago

⚖ Ideological Bias The Yandex outage probably didn’t blitz Russian bots; At least, not the troll traffic that blights social media.

Thumbnail
theverge.com
325 Upvotes

Lots of people are meming about troll bots going down but the data doesn't support that.

Besides the lack of data, simple skepticism and knowledge about how networks and traffic analysis work should make it obvious the calls are coming from inside the house.

Domestic traffic is less likely to be intercepted or straight up banned.


r/skeptic • • 2d ago

MAGA’s Talarico Mental Breakdown Conspiracy Implodes—Instantly

Thumbnail
thebulwark.com
853 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 3d ago

🚑 Medicine Anti-vaxxers target Texas measles doctors to cast doubt on deaths amid outbreak

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
350 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 2d ago

It was Big Tabacco this whole damn time!

Thumbnail
businessinsider.com
128 Upvotes

Ai was invented to cure cancer... To bring back smoking.


r/skeptic • • 2d ago

Anyone else getting ads for u/informedwaterchoices?

66 Upvotes

The single most disgusting piece of deliberate disinformation I have seen here on Reddit. They equate vinyl chloride (an odorless, colorless, deadly gas) with polyvinyl chloride, a common type of drinking water pipe. Kind of like equating pure sodium with salt. And they don't allow comments on their posts or on their user page. I presume that they're trying to sell some other kind of drinking water pipe that's much harder to use and/or much more expensive.


r/skeptic • • 3d ago

Our universe is not just a computer simulation, but try telling that to the billionaires of Big Tech | Michael Marshall

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
137 Upvotes

The baseless theory that life is just a Matrix-like computer simulation has caught on in Silicon Valley and is taking on increasingly religious tones.


r/skeptic • • 3d ago

Conspiracy theories and the conspiracy mindset: implications for political ideology

Thumbnail sciencedirect.com
47 Upvotes
  • Conspiracy beliefs have important political correlates and consequences, which can undermine trust and participation in democratic processes.
  • They are not the preserve of the ideological left or right, and are more common at ideological extremes, though may be strongest at the extreme right.
  • There are reliable individual differences in a generalized predisposition to believe in conspiracy theories.
  • This predisposition has been characterized as a conspiracy mindset, and more specifically a generalized political attitude.
  • Problems with this characterization and alternative ways of understanding the ideological significance of conspiracy theories are discussed

r/skeptic • • 4d ago

The rise of pseudoscience | How misinformation imitates science and why distinguishing evidence from opinion has never been more important

Thumbnail
meer.com
383 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 4d ago

🤦‍♂️ Denialism Controversial vaccine trial touted by RFK Jr gets go-ahead in Guinea-Bissau | Vaccines and immunisation

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
220 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 3d ago

Ancient Ram Inn rocking chair on table experiment

0 Upvotes

I recently went on an overnight ghost hunt at the Ancient Ram Inn in Wotton-under-Edge, Gloucestershire, UK.

The organisers described it as a relatively quiet night in terms of paranormal activity, although guests reported seeing flashes of light in the rafters, hearing knocking sounds, and feeling something tugging at their clothing and brushing against their legs.

Towards the end of the night, in a room called the barn, one of the organisers placed a wooden rocking chair on top of a table. Six people sat around the table, each placing a finger on one of the chair’s two curved rockers. One finger was positioned at each corner and two in the middle, where the rockers made contact with the table.

My finger was on one of the corners, at the end of a rocker. The rocking chair began to rock slightly, and I kept my finger on it, trying simply to follow the movement of the chair without consciously pushing it.

As the chair rocked, I distinctly felt several strong, sharp, brief mechanical impulses transmitted through the rocker into my finger.

Later, at home, I reproduced similar impulses by placing my finger on one end of a foot-long piece of wood, held in place by a heavy weight, and lightly striking the other end with a heavy hammer.

I don’t believe those impulses could have been produced by anyone else’s fingers touching the chair or by its rocking motion on the table.


r/skeptic • • 5d ago

🚑 Medicine Chiropractic Therapy in Paediatric Cases

54 Upvotes

The biggest issue I disagree with with my wife is Chiropractors being safe and beneficial.

My step daughter is presenting as though she has a hypermobility disorder, and instead of attending the specialist clinic I am a patient of, she is insisting on taking her to a chiropractor for assessment.

The chiro was trained as a GP. Which begs questions of why they didn't continue; and is also surprising that it hasn't raised more eyebrows. It's my wife's main defence of using the therapy.

My wife is very science based, and intelligent, but because she was brought up on it, and hasn't had any immediate relatives who can attest to the detriment and trauma that can be caused, she refuses to engage with any counter evidence.

I've tried to use unbiased search terms to find studies to illustrate what I'm trying to convey, but there seems, unsurprisingly, to be very few direct studies, and even fewer with evidence of the potential risks.

It may be that kids are less at risk having stronger bones and muscles than older adults, but I'd never be able to forgive myself if something went wrong.

Because I'm not her biological parent or will be decided by my wife and her ex.

Can anyone share recent research, or point me in the right direction please.


r/skeptic • • 6d ago

Denialism as health policy: case study of US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr | Seth C. Kalichman

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
177 Upvotes

Robert F. Kennedy Jr, the most senior figure in US health, has spent decades undermining vaccines, denying the reality of AIDS, and endangering Americans.


r/skeptic • • 6d ago

💩 Pseudoscience Can Polygraphs Really Detect Lies?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
16 Upvotes

In the inaugural episode of his Mosaic podcast, Bryan St. Laurent speaks with AntiPolygraph.org co-founder George Maschke about the pseudoscience of polygraphy.