Red

YOU HAVE 50 VOTES USE THEM WISELY

You can like a contestant or dislike them the contestant with the most amount of likes wins a prize the contestant with the most dislikes will be eliminated also you guys get to pick the prize

Example of voting style: [A] {B} means I like Jammy and dislike Ruby, the likes and dislikes counteract each other.

Also a question: Should I make this more comic book style so you get more story without there being a billion slides?

With the most resounding result of this 'what if?' yet, the Pen fans have their revenge, as Gelatin is eliminated with 4 dislikes! He would've won the prize, but Fries got the same amount of likes, and wasn't eliminated, Fries received an obelisk, which leads us to the challenge.

TB and GB have to hide the yoylite, FreeSmart has to hide a van, and Bomby and Nickel have to hide some balloons. Bomby and Nickel try to control the storm, like in canon, but the lightning strikes bomby just before they succeed, they both die in the subsequent explosion. FreeSmart and Fries go head to head, trying to steal each other's trinkets, during this conflict, Taco has a moment of reflection, realising that being on FreeSmart ​​hasn't really worked out for her, fulfilling the role that Needle did in canon. In the end, only she and Fries survive, agreeing to team up to defeat Team No-Name , which doesn't go too well. TB and GB hid the Yoylite in the underground factory, that strategy ends up working, as Taco and Fries get stuck in the Glowing Fungus Caves, giving the balls a clear way to retrieve the trinkets. So, with that out of the way...

Either like or dislike a contestant on FreeSmart, Fries, or B. R. O. S. Bunch to either receive a prize or be eliminated, Voting ends in 5 hours!

Alright Votings over

Likes: Ruby (2), Pencil (3), Pin (1), Match (1), Needle (2), Gelatin (1), and Firey (1)

Pencil you (surprisedly not surprisedly) wins the prize and you get to rewind 7 seconds back after death what a stupid prize

Anyways onto the dislikes

With no dislikes Needle and Ruby are safe

Needle: Yeah!

Firey is safe with 1 dislike

PIN MATCH GELATIN AND PENCIL you are the BOTTOM 4 only three of you are safe and One is eliminated

Match-cil you two are safe with 2 dislikes

PIN GELATIN I'll announce one of you two leaving and...

I'm sorry Gelatin your out with 3 dislikes and Pin survives with 2 dislikes

Gelatin gets flung to the WTF

Yellow face: oh wow a new roommate what's new?

Next challenge is to point the Rocky tower (idk what I came up with) since PBSB is kinda stupid and has the glasses PTSD loses

Whoever gets the most likes gets a prize and whoever gets the most dislikes will be in the WTF

here's the personalities like you already know:

Rocky: has a personality of being independent (no barfing because I'm not having that shit) always helps his teammates and nice to his friends (talks often) and he is sometimes rude

Coiny: he's just Coiny but can't talk

Firey: has a IQ of 5 but he is a very nice guy who has a crush on a leaf

Golf ball: who is very bossy that no one likes

Ice cube: has a mean personality and has no friends

Match: trying to be nice but also has no friends

Needy: she is a fast runner contestant who hates being called needy and pretty much reuses old lines and tryna get new ones

Pencil: not a rude contestant but she hates Match and she is sometimes nice

Pin: she is just kinda those chill people y'know

Spongy:just a chill guy in his own world

Teardrop: who helps her friends and teammates if they need it (could also talk)

Tennis ball: no one fucking likes him but actually he's smart and all and follows gb orders (that's until he got robbed but whatever)

Bomby: not the main character of BFDIA but he is here to play the game and win it

Book: just existed somehow and yet no one likes her okay but fr she's just kinda there

Donut: who is very bossy to his teammates as well but the actual nice dude

Dora: dadadadaddadadaddadadadada (Who has a personality of trying to be not voted out for being a non object and is very intelligent and is capable of doing challenges)

Fries: reuses old lines and still has that ego

Gelatin: has a IQ under 0 makes him the dumbest contestant but also a pretty nice guy to be with

Nickel: just existing and just chilling nothing else about his personality

Puffball: she is a pretty little ball who gets robbed pretty badly overall

Ruby: she has a personality of her hyper self and just here for fun

Yellow face: he's a racist (now I've thought about it)

That's all y'all guys voting ends on July 14th and probably a new post on that day so be careful

I'm going to keep this short, because the website fucking deleted my post after I posted it, because of that, I'm not rewriting the exact same story again.

In the most heated vote in this what if so far, Bomby wins the prize, and Taco is eliminated. This is because she got less likes than Bomby, so she goes to the WTF! ​Bomby chose Immuntiy to the Final 6, because he's mostly a pacifist, and wouldn't want to basically permanently kill someone. ​​

This episode is mostly the same, so FreeSmart gets distracted in the Superstore, Nickel and No-Name time travel, with the same result as in canon, Bomby is already safe, and Fries wins, as he isn't distracted by Needle's Evil Leafy shenanigans, so he wins ig.

Either like or dislike a contestant on Team No-Name, FreeSmart, or B. R. O. S. Bunch (BOMBY IS IMMUNE, DON'T VOTE FOR HIM) to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 5 hours! ​​​

W. O. A. H. Bunch is UFE, voting ends at 8PM UK time!

​

This is gonna be the most controversial elimination yet.. we had to spin wheels to determine who got the most likes and dislikes. As a result, Gelatin wins the prize and Pen is eliminated! Gelatin's prize is a Growth Ray, which probably won't help at all.

Onto the challenge. No-Name, FreeSmart and B. R. O. S. Bunch, (even though all of the bros are out), are separated into The Hearts, The Snacks, and the Quasi-Rhombicosidodecahedrons. This challenge isn't that important, the only major thing is that Fries has now abandoned No​​-Name. Most of the canon antics stay the same, except the final shrinking scene, which doesn't happen because now everyone is fighting over Gelatin's growth ray. Because of this, they all end up insanely large, except GB's team, who end up somehow inventing a shrink ray out of dust, which allows them to swiftly complete the challenge. One more important thing to note is that the trinkets for next challenge will be different, due to most of the contestants needing to get recovered. The cake at stake will be held ​​near Yoyle city, with that out of the way...

Either like or dislike a contestant on The Snacks or The Quasi-Rhombicosidodecahedrons to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 6 hours!

​​​

E

Welp, I can't say that I'm surprised. In a nearly unanimous vote, Ruby wins the prize with 4 likes, and TB is eliminated with 4 dislikes! Ruby's prize is a Disbandment Token, which she uses to disband B. R. O. S. Bunch, meaning that we're officially in the merge of BFDIAP! We're in the endgame now.

There isn't too much that changes, except one key thing, Ruby betrays Match due to her aggressive behaviour this episode. (This will come back in BFDIAP 21) ​and I'll only really list the challenge placements, as that's all that matters for this episode. Not the rest of the season.

Nickel- 6th

Golf Ball- 5th

Bomby- 4th

Match- 3rd

Fries- 2nd

Ruby- 1st

So, either like or dislike Nickel, Golf Ball, Bomby, Match or Fries to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 5 hours!

​

DISLIKE OR LIKE THE CONTESTANT IN BFDI THE ONE WITH THE MOST DISLIKES IS ELIMINATED SEE YOU AT BFDIAVV 11

We had to spin a wheel to determine who got the most likes, which resulted in Taco winning! She won the Mech Suit, which WILL BE IMPORTANT for the foreseeable future.

The duos have been formed, and, to be honest, this one doesn't need too much explanation, as Fries takes Taco, as she literally just got a state of the art mech suit. Long story short, Fries finds a battery pack for the suit, and they win without much hassle. TB and GB are tactical masterminds atp, so they take materials from every island and create some sort of device(s) to make their way up to the bunk bed. Bomby and Nickel do Bomby and Nickel shenanigans, which would probably, somehow, get them to the bunk bed for no reason whatsoever. Match+Ruby ​and Gelatin+Pen remain, but since Match and Ruby were easily able to get Pencil and Bubble back, so, unlike what happened in canon, the representatives of FreeSmart actually pull through, meaning...

Either like or dislike Gelatin or Pen to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 5 hours!

We only got 1 like and dislike, so puffball gets the prize, which was to delete someone's limbs, due to the fact that blocky is mean to puffball, she chooses to remove his limbs (his icon will be updated next time). Also, spongy is eliminated with 1 dislike! Because of this, no contestants switch over to B. R. O. S. Bunch. Also, the spike-throwing speaker box was stabbed by ​blocky just before he lost his limbs, as a prank, obviously. ​The image showing the hosts won't load, but they're TV and the Firey Speaker Box. Hopefully he'll not be too depressed in this 'what if? '.

FreeSmart has now officially formed! Luckily, they have taco and the FreeSmart Supervan, so they win the challenge​​​ easily, maybe even faster than in canon! (Bubble is also recovered) ​ B. R. O. S. Bunch, whilst still being the smallest team, are very physically capable, to add to this, yellow face has a plethora of gadgets that could help them if they decide to use them correctly. Team No-Name are still the biggest team, but they're still very dysfunctional, regardless of who inevitably fumbles the challenge, they still threw the challenge, so they lose. Don't worry, the plot of BFDIAP will start to differentiate from the canon timeline, starting in BFDIAP 6 or 7 (don't laugh at that)

With that out of the way, either like or dislike a contestant on Team No-Name to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 5 hours! ​​​

Last time, everyone except for Pen got a like and a dislike, so we spun a wheel twice, and... Nickel won the prize and Donut got eliminated! Nickel's prize was a pesticide, which repels flower, meaning that she can't host anymore. The bugs took her place, so it's time for Bug Dodgeball!

Fries goes solo, which works for a decent amount of time, but FreestSmartest soon grow tired of his arrogant demeanor and just get Taco to finish him off. While Taco fights Fries, the rest of the team decide to take on Team No-Name, which results in the deaths of Golf Ball, Tennis Ball, Ruby and Match. Meaning that only Pencil and Golf Ball are left standing, which would be true if it wasn't for B. R. O. S. Bunch, who decided to retreat until the most of the cast had died. They simply explode Bomby, which launches waves of bugs at GB and Pencil, which leads to their deaths, meaning...

Either like or dislike a contestant on Team No-Name, Fries, or FreestSmartest to either receive a prize or be eliminated! Voting ends in 24 hours! Remember, onpy one person leaves the show out of the teams who lost! (Since BFDIA 13 was a non-competition episode, the next part of BFDIAP will have a longer story than average.) ​​

25th: ????

How this What if works is that only odd numbers (Zero doesnt count) are allowed during the BFDIA cast voring- likely to spice things up. This is definitely going to change the final 2, because Book and Needle both got Nine votes, which is NOT enough to join.

Slide 1: Thumbnail

Slide 2: Voting results

Slide 3: voting results (organized)

After the rules are read, the teams try to form. TB still tries to go with oldies and newbies, which looks like this.

Slide 4: Oldies v Newbies

All of the oldies (except GB and TB) leave the team, and out of pity, David is kicked iut by Dora onto Golf Ball's team. Firey JR joins too, calling his team "crowded and stupid".

Slide 5: current teams

As for the contest, David would be surprisingly strong enough to make the sides somewhat even, until Firey junior burns the rope by mistake and disqualifies his team.

Slide 6: Elimination poll

Voting ends at 2 PM Est , thursday June 18th 2026. You can vote for as many people as you want.